Parvati Replaced- All discussions here only Nt Pg 41 - Page 41

Created

Last reply

Replies

476

Views

60.4k

Users

81

Likes

817

Frequent Posters

Annujam23 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
Reading all of the above comments...I Guess one reason for Cvs nt showing stories of shiv Parvati n ESP aadishakti was they were going to replace Sona n make it totally mahadev centric n am sure Sona would have known this fact...price hike was one of the things they narrowed down to n were negotiating, other than that her role was many times sidelined...but why hers others were too!!!!
I am sure makers know best n they have done well in past, so they must be riding high on confidence...!!!!
As for watching DKDM,even general audience I know r confused about the replacement but more so about the Ramayana track...if later on it clicks u will see a surge in trps, otherwise it might come down to serious reality check!!!
Edited by Annujam23 - 12 years ago
Vr15h thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
Actually, this serial would have done fine just showing Mahadev alone doing some of his activities - after all, not every story about Mahadev includes either Sati or Parvati, important as they are. If shown properly i.e. authentically, viewers would have been fine w/ that. Somehow, the PH never thought it possible - they think that the public lives for jodis and jodis alone, not knowing that for something like this, they would follow it for Mahadev alone.

I wouldn't really complain if they show Mahadev alone doing his stuff, w/o any Parvati (although she would be needed in the Andhak story, were they to show it). In the Bheemasura story, Parvati ain't involved, nor is she involved in the Ayappa story, and in Manasa Devi, some versions actually have her as a villain, so it would be safe to exclude her, unless they want to show her as evil. In the Arjun-Kirata story, I've read the extended version where Parvati, Nandi and all their ganas take disguises and accompany Kirat when he goes to visit Arjun. But if they want to keep it simple, they could just show Mahadev appearing b4 Arjun after Kirat confronts him alone.

So yeah, there are roles left for Parvati, but the major ones are done and dusted. So this serial could salvage itself if it rushes the Ramayan, then gets back to Mahadev only stories.

But the magic is clearly over
Edited by .Vrish. - 12 years ago
Ranjusha thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
Vrish they had ruled out Andhakasur as was informed by the writer to one of us when suggested to him stories that can be shown in the show related to Shiv this was during the Jalandhar phase when one of the producers where asking audience for stories they would like to see in Mahadev.

I don't think they will show Ayappa either so think of what else can be shown if these two are removed from the list.
A-A-S thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: Ranjusha

Vrish they had ruled out Andhakasur as was informed by the writer to one of us when suggested to him stories that can be shown in the show related to Shiv this was during the Jalandhar phase when one of the producers where asking audience for stories they would like to see in Mahadev.

I don't think they will show Ayappa either so think of what else can be shown if these two are removed from the list.


Ranjusha, did they give any reasons for why they don't want to show these stories in DKDM?

These things are actually related to Mahadev - if they don't show them in DKDM then where else are they going to show them?

If they will insert Mahadev into things where he wasn't necessarily involved then why won't they show these stories, where he is very much involved???

If they are worried about timelines(!) then they could always start off by showing these as flashbacks/someone telling someone else a story.
Edited by A-A-S - 12 years ago
Ranjusha thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
No idea but Andhka was ruled out by the makers which is related to Mahadev only and would have made a great story as he is ansh of Shiv Parvati. Came as a surprise. God knows if in the future if they will ever rethink the decision.
Ramayan one would think would be the last option makers would resort to.
Minaxi was already shown horribly in Mahadev so they don't plan to reshow it again. Devsena was rectified last minute thanks to suggestions made by one of our friends to the writers and he incorporated and made her manasputri of Brahma.
Karunima thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
Ramayan in Mahadev some saying is Shivayan. Pity poor Ram and what he will be reduced to in this show.
Vr15h thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
Well, Bheemasura happened post Ramayan, so they can show it as a natural sequence to events. Arjun-Kirata they can show in the Mahabharata phase.

But I'm disappointed that they've ruled out Andhak, Ayappa and Manasa Devi. If this is a serial about Mahadev, shouldn't his entire family be shown - particularly since they are sourcing it from different sources? Andhak is one of the nicer stories, although it would have a problem from a timeline standpoint - since he was adapted out to Hiranyaksha and later continued his activities. It would neatly span the Satya-Yuga and Treta-Yuga divide.

Manasa Devi story would have to happen during or before the Mahabharata, since Manasa's son Rishi Asthika was the one who persuaded Janamejaya to end the massacre of Nagas.

Ayappa story can happen anytime, unless they are worried about offending Vaishnavas. But I'd think they've already pissed off Vaishnavas by showing Mahadev as running everything in the Ramayan
Karunima thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
They can still show the story of Manasa Devi if they want to. But God knows how they plan to attract the audience obviously they want Mohit Mahadev to be the front runner in everything.
You will see him in many more roops and disguises and slowly it will be just him in the show because pretty much everything else is lost in oblivion.
varaali thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: .Vrish.

Ayappa story can happen anytime, unless they are worried about offending Vaishnavas. But I'd think they've already pissed off Vaishnavas by showing Mahadev as running everything in the Ramayan


There's nothing to offend Vaishnavas here. Ayyappa is known as Hari-Hara putra.

If at all, the Shaivites may get offended since, Srimad Bhagavatham does not show Shiva in a favourable light. For instance, SB says Shiva got infatuated and began running after Mohini, blah blah...but the CVs can always sidestep that point (as they did with Bhasmasur).
Annujam23 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
Nope they won't go there...bit controversial for them!!!..the makers won't try to hurt the sentiments of shiv followers..the series will meander around shiv mahimaa so the versions will be toned down to appease all!!
Edited by Annujam23 - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".