Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 35
CHACHI vs CUTEY 11.12
CONFUSED SOULS 12.12
🏏South Africa tour of India 2025: India vs SA - 2nd T20I🏏
Is Yrkkh in trouble?
Hrithik ‘praises’ Dhurandhar but he also disagrees with its politics
Happy Birthday champion: Gaurav Khanna
Film Critics Guild issues statement
I hope pari sudhar nahi gayi ho!
Critic Roshan is back with another review of Dharundhar!!
Akshaye Khanna is the highest grossing actor of 2025!!!
Saahil & Pooja Set To Return!!
Dhurandhar emerges a BLOCKBUSTER
Industry support for Dhurandhar (a compilation)
Paresh Rawal deletes his distasteful tweet on Anupama Chopra
How convenient
Next season’s contestants - speculations
They're showing this, but in Durga pujas, both Ganesh & Kartikeya look like youths in their 20s
So frnds the birth of shiv-putra kartikey is near in dkdm. So i want to ask few things to all the knowledgeble peoples here. 1) why kartikey is not seen in any pic wid mahadev-parvati and ganpati bappa. 2) i read on twitter that after killing tarkasur kartikey didn't returned to kailash. Is it true? And why? 3) i too heard that in his temple womens are restricted to enter. If its already discused then kindly close the topic and if not discused then kindly narate us the story of veer kartikey.
1) Karthikeya is very much part of the shiv parivar and was very popular God in whole of India one whole Purana "Skanda Purana" is dedicated to him however his popularity has decreased in the North after the middle ages and that of ganesha increased hence Ganesha is more popular in the north. Story of rivalry of Karthikeya and ganesha symbolically signifies this shift in the North.
2) Receding of karthikeya towards the south indicates his reduction in popularity in the north and southward increase in popularity
3) Karthikeya worship in North is in the brahmachari form, although very rare in the North karthikeya is unmarried and elder to ganesha whereas in the south he is younger and has two wives Sri Valli and Devayani. there is very old karthikeya temple in haryana( Pehowa township) where women are not allowed.
on the whole there is a large difference in how south and North view Karthikeya, for bthe Northerners he is a Brahmachari and for southerners he is married and has two wives.
Best regards
krishna
1) why kartikey is not seen in any pic wid mahadev-parvati and ganpati bappa. - Basically that's because Karthikeya is not popular in North India. And that is because, his reign or whateveryou call was in South India. He stayed there like Ganesha stayed in North! You'll find Skanda included in all paintings or photos in South :)
2) i read on twitter that after killing tarkasur kartikey didn't returned to kailash. Is it true? And why? - No. That is not true. Karthikeya does come back the story of Karthikeya leaving kailash is a different one. He leaves because he thought Ganesha cheated and got the fruit of knowledge. On that occasion, he gets angry and leaves Kailash3) i too heard that in his temple womens are restricted to enter. - No dear, everyone is allowed there. I think you got it confused with Ayyappa :)