Aamir's Interview - Page 6

Originally posted by: joie de vivre

^^Well obviously 😃 ,as a fan,I consider it my prerogative to defend my favourite...But I like to believe that my defense has some rationale and is not plain jabberwocky...

There you go. You are talking about Mr.Bachchan's strong retaliation and then use words like this for my comments. So I prefer to be an intellect here and my reply is 'No comments'. 😉😆

Originally posted by: joie de vivre

Please do not pass off your opinions as facts!Anything and everything we state are merely our PERSONAL opinions,not universal facts

Please keep your advice to yourself on what I should and shouldn't say. Nothing is a fact. We all are merely stating our opinion. You don't like it then leave it.

But I think it's fine he comes out of his shell to publicize his movies. If someone prefers to only give interviews right before the release of his movies, that's fine. But as his fan I am happy to have him blog away regularly and wish us Happy Diwali in the midst of his family crisis and read our comments and take our names and reply to us.

Anyways, I don't agree with his comments on Black. I do agree about Amitabh's overacting. But I like Black as a film and I don't think it was insensitive at all. It was a very positive film and it was beautifully presented.

Lagaan : Kachra's hand disability

Fanaa: Blind Zooni

TZP: Dyslexic kid

And Aamir Khan talks about Black "I found it very insensitive, it sends out very wrong signals. It was extremely manipulative. I could see the effort in the manipulation, and the art of the director is in not letting you see the manipulation. Also, the sensibility wasn't right for me."

😆 I rest my case.

Originally posted by: Maya_M

Mr.Bachchan got National Award for Black. 😆 No wonder Aamir stopped talking about national awards.

😆😆😆 If Black had got Oscar, AAmir wud have stopped praising only the Oscars😆😆😆

PS: Aamir really has his priorities right...

Originally posted by: admail_bd

Anyways, I don't agree with his comments on Black. I do agree about Amitabh's overacting. But I like Black as a film and I don't think it was insensitive at all. It was a very positive film and it was beautifully presented.

really guys! This is mad! If AB had remained Mute and given a Sarkar-ish performance in Black, he wud have ruined it all..his role was a very very eccetric alcoholic wierd man...a disappoting view from sumone who can understand and appreciate both Ranbir and Sonam IN Saawariya!

PS: All said and Done, I like Aamir's acting, But I wish HE wud stop This kind of manipulation...

Originally posted by: tpam

i love aamir khans work!!! and he is definitely a gr88 actor!!and my fav too
bt i cant support him talking like this abt senior b!!!senior b remains my all tiem fav actor !!!! he is the legend and he got national award for black , and it is amazing movie atleast for me!!!

i just didnt like aamirs uncalled comments on black and slb...

I think Aamir called the character Big B was playing over the top, and not his acting.I loved Black and Big B definitely did a great job, but I do agree with Aamir when he said how leaving a child alone and hitting it is not the way to teach. That was rather insensitive.

^^^But that was the best part of the movie...abt a harsh reality sensitively handled...The viewer must see the sensitivity of that act...

the man should stop deep thinking and shouldn't think of himself he should respect other people's work too on one hand he is saying that he is not promoting his film thorugh blog and use it to have one to one connection with his fans on the other hand he refused madam tussades offer couldn't he accept for his fans and secondly he says he didn't give any interview for fanna and rang de that is only beause hje was just an actor on them here for TZP he is director producer and actor that is why giving interviwes . i don't know what does he wants from the industry to dance on his tunes and world to praise his work the man needs to calm down and give evryone break i ususally like those kinda interviews but i don't know why whenever i read his interview i just see oh i am so great my opinion matters i am the best i know everything kinda attitude

Originally posted by: Maya_M

There you go. You are talking about Mr.Bachchan's strong retaliation and then use words like this for my comments. So I prefer to be an intellect here and my reply is 'No comments'. 😉😆

And when did I say your opinions are jabberwocky😕.....Forgive me,but if you misunderstand me,I am not to be blamed mate.....

Originally posted by: lucky_lakshmi

^^^But that was the best part of the movie...abt a harsh reality sensitively handled...The viewer must see the sensitivity of that act...

I know, but that's not the right way. I work with intellectually disabled people in Canada and over here, that manner of teaching would never be accepted. But again cinema gives you the liberty. Having said that Black was a wonderful film, and so was Khamoshi, but yes parts of Black such as hitting the girl, and the kiss were not needed.