Brothers overall turned out to be a bad film. Sid barely had anything to do, and even couple of his good scenes from promos got cut.
He's still learning, and has a lot of room for improvement. But at this point he's also not as bad as IF makes him out to be. I don't think comparing him to someone who's done ten years of television drama is fare, but I think he held his own.
I disagree that Shraddha over shadowed him in EV, and SOTY definitely wasn't an Alia show. Alia was just a flower pot in that film. In fact I have enjoyed him in all his films. I think given the content, character and direction he's done pretty well in all of them.
9