Ranbir & Katrina in Kishore-Madhubala in Biopic N:11

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Yuvika

@Yuvika_15

Moderator

+ 9

Posted: 12 years ago

#31

Originally posted by: Cutieee1992
People are actually saying Madhuala wasn't known for acting? Madhubala was a great actress as well, but her beauty was so much that it overshadowed her talent as per by critics at that time. A famous actor, forgot his name, even forgot his dialogues the first time he met her struck by her beauty and some journalist, who had seen her, had said if Madhubala was alive today, she would have give a run to actress like Madhuri and Ash. Even her debut I heard was a big success. Just because her beauty was too much to overshadow her talent doesn't mean to ignore her talent.
Today she is more remembered for her beauty than acting because for acting, there were other actress as great as her as well, but no one was ever as beautiful than her so in a way in looks she had been above all and was best remembered for. That doesn't mean she was great in acing; otherwise, she wouldn't have been always included in top actress and legends of 100 years of BW. She was an inspiration to Madhuri's dancing too. Go watch Pyar kiya.

Comparing KAT to Madhubala is like an insult to Madhubala. Even my fav actress can't be better than her. She was a legend. Be it beauty, dance, acting, she had it all, but too bad her personal life was mess.

well said I heard that too abt a famous actor forgetting his lines...he said so himself and said he was just in awe of her beauty that he just forgot everything...like aishwarya is said 2 b beautiful but see her without make up she seems an average girl...but madhubala was on another level...she was sum1 tht made u look at her twice without make up...that was a first.

her acting was great but as u said her beauty overshadowed it...which was a pity...

she died quite young I feel... but then she was a blue baby so was bound to have health issues attacking her as she grew older.

aish is said 2 b the first actress to attract Hollywood interest but whoever says that has forgotten tht b4 aish it was madhubala that attracted Hollywood interest...infact big successful filmmakers really wanted her 2 work in their movies but her father declined those offers and she remained onli a part of BW...

Edited by Yuvika_15 - 12 years ago

Quote

Winzy

@nicegirl_good

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#32

I don't mind kat as madhubala looking at the tv version of madhubala

I would rather have someone as pretty as Katrina as MB 🤗

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

theprince

@theprince

Rocker

Posted: 12 years ago

#33

kat in this film and kat in Jagga Jasoos they will kick Anushka and choose Kat in BV in blue ray of YJHD DP will not be in the film but Kat 🤣

Quote

Monk_Princess

@Monk_Princess

Beginner

Posted: 12 years ago

#34

😭

To me Madhubala is the ultimate beauty --how would I spend the rest of my life knowing that Katrina is being considered her equal---?

Join two eyes of Kat to get one of Madhbubala, her so called lop-sided smile was so enchanting and the way that smile crept mischieveously into her eyes was mesmerizing---

To those who say Madhubala did not know how to act---just watch one song of her at least , just one--note the delicacy and variation of expression , how her eyes danced, how her smile and expression changed---She was unparallelled then, and so is she even now---

please someone get this project shelved--please--😭

Edited by Monk_Princess - 12 years ago

Quote

AidanQ

@AidanQ

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

#35

Of all people they signed Kat to play Madhubala? 😲

Quote

Angela

@TuesdaysChild

Navigator

Posted: 12 years ago

#36

Originally posted by: pakeezah
Madhubala was not known for her ACTING
that was meena kumari

and arguably KAT is prettier than madhubala

Madhubala had a lopsided smile and supposedly non feminine
hands n feet

But KAT in madhubala make up and get up

Ooohhh, blood red lipstick, eyeliner, wavy hair, pale face
Her sharp balanced features with the doe eyes will look awesome

Oh dear.😭

Quote

..Supriya..

@..Supriya..

Explorer

Posted: 12 years ago

#37

nache re nache madhubala...🤢🤢

Quote

pakeezah

@pakeezah

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

#38

Originally posted by: Yuvika_15
this movie shouldn't happen esp if its going to be Katrina playing madhubala ji...no offence to her fans but choosing kat 2 play madhubala is an insult to madhubala...Katrina unfortunately will not be able to pull off the role...I know many will say she's not even done it and ur jumping to a conclusion but seeing her acting over the years this surely is one role she should stay away from.

____________________

thats what they said about Raajneeti...lol!!!😆

and turns out Katrina was one of the surprises of the film..i guess the non politics

loving public went to see Raajneeti just to see the beautiful Katrina.

Result? Hit. Hit. Hit.!!!

(and sorry, no disrespect to yesteryears stars,BUT our stars Vidya, Madhuri, Hema

Jaya Prada, Rekha, Shabana, Smita, Priyanka,Tabu are AS talented as they ever were.

And our stars Zeenat, Parveen, Neetu, Madhuri, Katrina Chitrangadha Deepika AS attractive and hot

as any of them were.

Just because they were from 1950s and now only names dont mean our girls are

any less