Originally posted by: 786ahf_bi
Ikr...really loved yesterday episode...all clearly explained...
Suddenly all start bashing and say it's going against religion...they need to understand that it is a show not a real life story..
You're right that she didn't go against religion and she only questioned the reason for Halalh Nikkah, but you also need to understand that when the show is based on muslims and slightly highlights Isalm, the topic can't be against Shariyat. People are supporting CVs that they didn't make Zaya go against religion yet they through the episode never explained the reason why a Halalah is necessary. Aliya questioned about the HN(Halalah Nikah) but never got the answer, if the Molvi had given an answer then the viewers wether Muslims or not would have had a better understanding as to why this is such a big issue.
The main point is that when you're taking up a show like Beintehaa and they're shown as Muslim, many Muslims watch it and they consider Aliya as a role model, and when it comes to something against religion it's not just a fictional story and a fictional character anymore, it's a "FICTIONAL SHOW" representing a religious community. These are the things you must take into mind while taking on such a show.
I hope the CVs will also think of what will happen next, as doing 2nd Nikkah for the intention of halalah is also haram and if Aliya wants to marry Rehaan she has to do it with pure intentions of marriage not as a way of Halalah which is a sin. Secondly Aliya's parents should know better as they're older. Yes Aliya loves Zain but her parents need to tell her the rules of Shariat. Divorce is always done in anger where the man may later regret that's why there's is rule of UNINTENTIONAL HN as a lesson for that 1st man to not take divorce so lightly.
The one perspective for HN is:
aksar aisa hota hai keh aik mard ne ghussa mai aa ker apni bivi ko talaq de di, baad mai ehsaas hua keh os ne apni bivi ke saath ziadti ki hai, iss masla per jab molvi sahib ke paas jaata hai tu molvi sahib farmate hai keh ab bivi ko dobara ghar laane se qabal Halalah kerna hoga, matlab yeh keh aurat pehle kisi aur ki bivi bane gi, os se mubasrat kare gi, phir talaq le gi aur phir dobara os shaks se shaadi kare gi.
aik wafadar aurat ke liye yeh naqabil-e-amal aur na-qabil-e-bardasht baat hai keh woh apne original shohar ke ilawah kisi aur ke bistar ki zeenat bane, jab ziadti mard ne ki hai tu kisi aur ke bistar per jaane ki saza aurat ko kio di jaati hai.
aik tu pehle shohar ne najaiz (ghussa mai aaker) talaq di, iss talaq se aurat ko jo torture hua os ka andaza woh aurat hi laga sakti hai, os ke baad os ko mazeed torture dene ke liye os ka nikah kisi aur se ker dia gia, aur os ko intimate hone per bhi majboor kia, torture ki mazeed inteha yeh keh ose dobara talaq delwaya gia, aur phir os ziadti kerne wale shakhs se dobara nikah karaya gia.
iss poori kahani mai ziadti sirf aur sirf aurat per hoti hai. kabhi kabhi aisa bhi hota hai keh new shohar talaq nahi deta, aur kabhi aisa bhi hota hai keh new shohar se talaq ke baad pehla shohar dobara nikah bhi nahi kerta.
Edited by zunara_ali - 11 years ago
