Legalities of a live-in relationship - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

23

Views

3.2k

Users

10

Likes

45

Frequent Posters

vamita thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#11
Garui can lie and do anything, but what will it make of her...? The lie will be a lie and it will be behind her mind as far as she live...She can't just ignore it...! And further, haveli people can say to the court that Gauri had come to Jaitsar and knew about Jagya...! Though she might take utmost care, she simply can't lie without solid proof...And whatever legalities, she won't do anything, because, she knows if she did, she might very well get trapped...She is not really a innocent here as well and a person who commited crime, has always fear in their mind, which will keep them away from doing any such thing...So, I am sure Gauri won't do anything as of now...Her face will be open for whole world to see then and she will never be able to meet anyones eyes...So, it is better, if she and Jagya, both try to get hold of their life and move on...It is true that they need to get punishment...Jagya more so...And they will get it...Both lost the people who loved them and whom they loved...Gauri loved Jagya and lost him., Jagya is thinking about Anandi and feeling guilty and wants to give her happiness, but it is too late...So, they will feel the pain of it all their life, every moment, when they see their loved ones with someone else...
mahi12 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#12
i am sorry but just to satisfy our hatred for Jagaya for what he did with Anandi we support Gauri to put wrong blame on him for Domestic violence and abuse ..i am really sorry i can support Anandi to file this case on him not Gauri who is twice bigger cheater and liar than him 🤢
-Purva- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 4 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#13
You are right the only legal recourse Gauri has is under the DV Act - the Act covers emotional, physical and mental abuse of any woman from the men. This Act not only protects a married woman, but also a sister, mother or any woman who is living under the same roof.

So Gauri need not provide nay proof for her marriage or legal status, but only that she and Jagat were living in the same premises. However, much more than proving her legal status Gauri needs to prove actual incidents of abuse.

Except for the final showdown between Gauri and Jagat there is no proof of him abusing Gauri. She was better qualified and financially more secure than him. They did not have a joint account and Jagat was dependent on the pocket-money she gave him, so her case would become very weak.

She cannot even claim that he abandoned her or cheated her, because the first time they both got married - they were both children and that marriage was annulled by the MahaPanchayat.

The second time they got married, Jagat was already legally married and they were both aware of the fact that their marriage is a fraud.

The third and the most recent attempt to get married - Gauri herself told everyone that the ceremony was going to be a surprise for Jagat, while she lied to him that she was doing arrangements for a friend's wedding. There is no court in the country that will force a man to get married to someone against his will. In fact what Gauri was doing was an attempt to socially blackmail him into marrying her, which is illegal.

So far as I see Gauri has no case.
ButterflyOnRose thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#14
o so we want Gauri to become Anandi's supporter and take Anandi's revenge from Jagat🤢and we will be happy with her lies too 🥱 ...by the way if the Singh family can escape from their crime of bal vivah of two children which is no less than bigamy in my view by their repentance why Jagaya should be go through torture torture torture and no redemption ever for him he is recieving hell lot of punishment he is losing everthing in his life perhaps cvs should hang him to death then it will some satisfy some viewers 🥱
-Purva- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 4 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#15
You misunderstand Sidra- this is only a discussion to understand what legal recourse women in a situation similar to Gauri can have under the IPC.

Anandi is not even in the picture or relevant to this discussion, except as the shadowy wife of Jagat.

As for Jagat - nopes not hanging, that would be too easy an escape for a man who cheats on two women and abuses his family. I particularly like the current status of Jagat - homeless, jobless, penniless - he was senseless to begin with anyway.
ButterflyOnRose thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#16
well perhaps i misunderstood sorry for that 😆but Jagat cheating on two women i don't believe that phrase because when gauri married him she knew everything about him so cheating her i don't think so😕she is not at any single point a victim of anything ...i would prefer him presenting himself to jail then at any point this women sending him into ..but i do wish there was some law where such women like Gauri should taste jail too ..she is no way less than him but in many cases greater than him
Resh..... thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#17

about live in relationship i have read somewhere that supreme court has given no objection to live in relationship... a man and a woman can live together without marriage provided they should not be below 18 years and either of them are not married... if any one among them is married then their spouse can file cases against them...

In the serial, Anandi could have filed a case against jagya... and now even Gauri can file case against him as he has been living with her more quite some time...
-Purva- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 4 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#18
@Sidra - yeah he hasn't ever really cheated on Gauri, so well we can only blame him for cheating on Anandi.

Unfortunately the law is limited in its scope - Jagya can be punished by law only if Anandi files a case against him, but Gauri cannot be.

Ironically if the situation was reversed, i.e. if Gauri was the married partner then her husband could've filed a case against Jagya and sent him behind bars.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

@Resh - Even now Gauri cannot file a case against Jagya, because all they have is a live-in arrangement. She is not his legal wife. So she cannot claim that she was abandoned or anything.
ButterflyOnRose thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#19
@Chitrashi...yes you are right unfortunately the law is limited to only men here not women like Gauri which i don't approve much law should be extended for such women in jail too 😆even i think only Anandi can file against Jagaya which she won't ever 😆either Jagaya presenting himself to court for lying to court about his martial status ..but didn't he himself knew nothing about his Bal vivah getting legal at that time 🤔because if i am not wrong it was bhairo who told him later but yeah mistake was of him was hiding it to court he should have asked about it and he never accepted it later either but Gauri for what can put him behind bars when she for everything was willingly involved with him after knowing everything there are many witnesses for it she has no proof either for her lies 🤓
sreevask thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#20
Gauri has education n economically independent...now if marriage with jagat is over, she need never care 4 anyone/anything in the world...not even jagat...

Even now, she requires jagat just for a social status/security tag...if she really wants to get it...she will beg mafi to haveli log.. N get her tag (jagat) back..
She will never file any case against jagat...as she follows her ideas rather than legal/elders advice...
No use in investing our emotions on this character...
For Jagat , he right now needs financial assistance from Bhairon, which is possible by Anandi's proactive measures as she wished such betrayal may not b done 2 Gauri... N try to reunite jago..as well as allow acceptance of jago back by haveli log..b4 she moves ahead with Shiv

Edited by sreevask - 13 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".