ZGH or Humsafar? - Page 9

Created

Last reply

Replies

206

Views

29.7k

Users

57

Likes

602

Frequent Posters

nevah_mind thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#81

Originally posted by: sia.k_1


@Bold
I am sorry but i completely disagree with this. I think such scenes were the highlight of ZGH as they portrayed reality. Every parent for that matter would give such advises to their children. And in particular, Rafia was being more concerned as she knew how Kashaf was. She was so pessimistic and Kashaf had seen a broken marriage. I think every parent would be scared of the repercussions of it on their children.

if one has watched the serial carefully, one can notice scenes where Rafia's advises have worked in favor of Kashaf.
A scene where Zaroon's mom mentions that Kashaf keeps calling her regularly and keeps a tab on things and she's so used to her calling now that when kashaf doesnt call she gets tensed.
Another scene where Zaroon tells his mother how happy he is because Kashaf takes care of his every lil thing.

N Murtaza leaving Rafia was another issue altogether. till date there are families who want a male child and not a girl. So the issue is quite serious and 'taking care and cooking' doesnt even matter here. Every woman does that to the family. Im just trying to say that he left her for a very serious issue and not some trivial issues like cooking.

@Red part

So if one is educated u expect them not to give such advises to their own children??😕 Again i think educated or not educated every parent will give such advices to their children for their good.

Its a very special show which i love so i wanted to just post my opinion. No offence meant to you.😊

No question of any offence.😊 You put down your point of view very well. I see where you are coming from.
Rafiya and her gyaan really bugged me, for reasons I have mentioned. But again my stance is different for other reasons. I also know that this is the most natural and common thing in our society, and it completely fine, give the social set up and norms.

Also in Durreshahwar, though I didn't agree with many of the messages given, I really liked it as a story and production. It was very well made, and surely worth watching not only for performances, but even for the way relationships were handled.

I love to hear different points of view. It also helps one into being tolerant and respectful of opinions which are totally different, which always have merit too.

The best thing, as we call can see, is that our take and what we get out of these serials can be so different, yet nothing is wrong.

And i sincerely feel there is no comparison between the two shows. They were of different genre. And its more of individualistic choices so i guess the whole debate about who's better and which is better is pointless😆
My point exactly from my 1st post here. Its a matter of what appeals to an individual. Doesn't make sense to compare the two.



Edited by nevah_mind - 11 years ago
Jenny_lover thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#82
ZGH is my first luv
luv Zashaf
excited to watch Humsaf ...on Zindagi...its OST and Fawad Khan every girls dream hero

b/w Comparision Post r NOT ALLOWED on IF...

kinjalshahshah thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#83

Originally posted by: RockChicGirl



Ofcourse I will give it a chance Kinjal if time permits. Since I am so prejuidiced against HS already I might like it. 😆

About the bold bit: Thats true...and thats why I really appreciate ZGH. Every character even minor ones had their own graph and own problems. Whether it was Zaroon's parents, Kashaf's mom, Kashaf's dad and his second wife, Zaroon's sister...all major supporting characters went thru their own ups and downs in the show over the years it covered. The characters gave their opinions on the Zaroon and Kashaf but none of them interfere and make it their lives mission to create problems for them. I never understand how can anyone really do it in reality. Every one of us have our own problems. Thats the major grouse I have against Hindi soaps too.


👍🏼

exactly shreya, all i wanted to say why judge before even watching..see if i went by others review i wud have skipped the best show ever (for me) i wont name it here but that show is close to my effing heart despite negative views...Btw even after watching HS you feel mehh then i take full responsibility for suggesting you to even though i know its not my insistence that compelled u to watch it😃

just watch it as any serial u place to watch...i remember when i saw HS(just after ZGH) i did not expect another ZGH coz not all shows can give you/touch you with same feeling/impact..every show has its own charm good or bad depends on individual likings.. and i was impressed with the show in different way compared to ZGH but that does make any one of them more superior over other (atleast for me)
I frankly didnt understood TMs point to compare these two shows- coz they hav Fawad in common😕 Or TM assumed these two are Fawads best shows😕 whtever it is i dont agree comparing these two shows or any other show for that matter

I often see people mocking love stories are liked in Indian hence HS is promoted well..i think every channel runs on money and unfortunately they by now know Fawad sell so they are promoting HS heavily not coz its a love story..plus i dont see HS as love story but as a story with different emotions love btw two companions being the prominent one.just like many stories that r being aired on Zindagi currently and will air in near future..i dont see why thr is strong dislike for love stories all of a sudden..Love is the integral part of fictions/non fictions with its definition changing as per characters and settings...not every story has to be depressing dark with realistic shades to be considered as worth watching..sometimes fairytales do make good stories

Ok i will stop it here coz its your wish ur choice wht u want to see how u want to see..as a frd just wanted to recommend after that upto u..plus wanted to request everyone pls stop comparing😕 Give opinions abt individual shows, like reading them but why compare this and that

Btw my fav Fawad shows: Dastaan and Satrangi though former i cant see without bucket full of tears and running nose so avoid watching even a still from that show while the later i feel like as if i am sitting in Satrangi bus😃 bt i hav different pecking order fro all of fawads charcters😛

Edited by kinjalshahshah - 11 years ago
-Sadiaa- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#84
@Kinjal , Its not Disliking of Love Stories , Few ppl here are bashing MK frm the day one & Most of MK fans dnt want to create fight thts why ! They didnt air to few comments on her face !!

first of all U dont want to watch HS ,Dont Watch IT !! Please HS dont deserved low mind ppl like few of u !
Secondly,MK or anyother human didnt make their face off their on.!! *Few ppl have passed comments on her Lips,Her complexion..etc.*
u dont like an actoress (without evn watching her work) OK!! its well & Good ! Bashing her on her face 👎🏼 Where these type of things took u ??

MK or HS has a Huge fan following tht doesnt mean U must have to watch tht Show & Love BUT Atleast Give Respect to the fan base & The Actors which they deserves , Actors are also humans , They r not ur personal property tht U can comment someoned lips etc.



Haters please Dont Watch Humsafar !!


nevah_mind thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#85
@kinjalshahshah
well said.

To me, Humsafar is more the journey of two soulmates more than just romance on the face of it. The most important thing in their relationship was the love for each other, despite the ugly situation. That was what touched my heart, and that's why I will always say that the whole serial makes a difference only when one watches every episode and reaches the end.
IMHO, if one ffwds even one scene, there will be some link which is missed to make the full connection at the end.

@mamukibhanji:
I'm not sure what and who exactly you are mentioning, but true, I think its very important to respect people's opinion and fan base. I'm not a big fan of Mahira and think others are way more talented. But she was so good as Khirad, and seeing all these other "way more talented actresses" that I mentioned, I don't think any of them could do justice to that role.
I remember watching an iv of hers, where she said that Momina Duraid kept telling her she had to do Humsafar, because she kept saying "you are Khirad, you are Khirad"
To be able to see that in her, was great vision by Momina, and Mahira delivered perfectly. I don't think Asher would have been what he was, if he didn't have a match in Khirad from Mahira. She was too good. Just TOO brilliant.
Edited by nevah_mind - 11 years ago
-Sadiaa- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#86

Originally posted by: nevah_mind

@kinjalshahshah

well said.

To me, Humsafar is more the journey of two soulmates more than just romance on the face of it. The most important thing in their relationship was the love for each other, despite the ugly situation. That was what touched my heart, and that's why I will always say that the whole serial makes a difference only when one watches every episode and reaches the end.
IMHO, if one ffwds even one scene, there will be some link which is missed to make the full connection at the end.

@mamukibhanji:
I'm not sure what and who exactly you are mentioning, but true, I think its very important to respect people's opinion and fan base. I'm not a big fan of Mahira and think others are way more talented. But she was so good as Khirad, and seeing all these other "way more talented actresses" that I mentioned, I don't think any of them could do justice to that role.
I remember watching an iv of hers, where she said that Momina Duraid kept telling her she had to do Humsafar, because she kept saying "you are Khirad, you are Khirad"
To be able to see that in her, was great vision by Momina, and Mahira delivered perfectly. I don't think Asher would have been what he was, if he didn't have a match in Khirad from Mahira. She was too good. Just TOO brilliant.

I dont want to share their names,those who hurt us Know Who they are !!

I read comments here in this Forum & thosr commentd hurts me BADLY as a Fan & as a Human as well
nevah_mind thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#87

Originally posted by: MamuKiBhanji

I dont want to share their names,those who hurt us Know Who they are !!

I read comments here in this Forum & thosr commentd hurts me BADLY as a Fan & as a Human as well


that said (my post in bold) there is a new serial with her coming up, right? I'm looking forward to watching that. i get the feeling that she is going to be very good in it.
Serendipity.. thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#88

Originally posted by: MamuKiBhanji

@Kinjal , Its not Disliking of Love Stories , Few ppl here are bashing MK frm the day one & Most of MK fans dnt want to create fight thts why ! They didnt air to few comments on her face !!

first of all U dont want to watch HS ,Dont Watch IT !! Please HS dont deserved low mind ppl like few of u !
Secondly,MK or anyother human didnt make their face off their on.!! *Few ppl have passed comments on her Lips,Her complexion..etc.*
u dont like an actoress (without evn watching her work) OK!! its well & Good ! Bashing her on her face 👎🏼 Where these type of things took u ??

MK or HS has a Huge fan following tht doesnt mean U must have to watch tht Show & Love BUT Atleast Give Respect to the fan base & The Actors which they deserves , Actors are also humans , They r not ur personal property tht U can comment someoned lips etc.



Haters please Dont Watch Humsafar !!



Your POV is justified but please dont take it personally to heart😳 See its a public forum and everyone has a right to express their opinions whether you like it or not. Not everyone can like our fav stars right. Each one has a different opinion. I think its best to respect each one's opinion and move on. Again, its individual choices and opinions. Its best to leave it at that.😊


AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#89

Originally posted by: RockChicGirl



KZK is my most hated show like ever. 😆And from what I read HS sounds heavily inspired by it. Doesnt matter who is playing what role and how good they are.
I think I liked ZGH because it actually preached all the morlas which Hindi soaps claim to preach and but never end up doing it. If the show is successful it will go on forever. If it isnt they wont even allow its story to be told. You just can never get invested. But ZGH effectively preached some basic morals like the importance of education, hardwork, men and women being as good as another, importance of giving time and energy to your family etc.



The morals of Hindi soaps? Surely there is more to the world than just that...some values and morals are universal or in the very least, cut across barriers...the sensitivity and NUANCE with which ZGH tackled relationships is more or less unheard of and impossible in the average Hindi soap...and sadly this thread is overtaken with debates over Fawad, Mahira etc. when as I'm repeating for the zillionth time, UMERA AHMED is the reason that ZGH strikes such a chord...but I guess I'm preaching to the choir...oh well.
-Sadiaa- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#90

Originally posted by: sia.k_1



Your POV is justified but please dont take it personally to heart😳 See its a public forum and everyone has a right to express their opinions whether you like it or not. Not everyone can like our fav stars right. Each one has a different opinion. I think its best to respect each one's opinion and move on. Again, its individual choices and opinions. Its best to leave it at that.😊


No I m not talking abt U ! Criticization & Disliking Someone Work is Fully Justified !
I jst want to say tht NoOne have a Right to Bash someones Face (Lips) !! Its Totally different thing !

Lets leave, I hope after this nobody ll comment Badly on things which are not in human control !

In Hatred Dont Stoop tht Low tht Theres No Way Back !!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".