karan took it all without a word and with a smile.

I felt that was so rude, too.
I just wanted to go and give the guy a hug.

True, he isn't the best dancer in the show, but he is improving. Telling him to improve, or work harder can be done in a nicer way.

---
And this is from my point of view, as a fan who didn't even know who Karan Kundra was before ZND started.

I don't think it was rude or inappropriate in any way. Karan IS a bad dancer, and he himself accepts it so many times in interviews et al. If someone told me I was bad at something, and knew I was, I would take it with a smile too. And you can obviously see how much I am a fan of Karan, so I am actually very very proud of his attitude towards it all.

I was actually happy with the scores yesterday about their dance for once. Everyone must get an equal treatment on the show, something that wasn't happening since the past few weeks. I guess yesterday set it more right with the scores at least.

Really though, the only thing that's keeping me hooked to this whole thing is Karan. I swear I'd stop watching almost immediately if he and Kritika left. Last year was so much fun, this year is plain boring now.

arshad said that literally???????????????????????? thats bad...i think karan is visibly improving

I dont think I really worded what I was going to say well...

What I meant was, I agree with the points, but not the comments.
Agreed that he deserves the same treatment as everyone else, and should be marked with the same guidelines but those comments were uncalled for.

And this is NOT only for Karan, I was not happy with the comments some of the other contestants got too in earlier episodes. I just feel that the judges can put their point across without being rude.

It was rather blunt. They could've said it politely but frankly we've seen much better Hum Tum rounds, specially 'Ranjha-Ranjha'.

I'm not saying this as a fan of Karan's....but what Arshad said was plain rude, admittedly Karan isn't the best dancer on the lot or anything anywhere near that, but he is trying really hard, to say your a bad dancer is robbing him of any chance of improvement, if i was working hard on something and someone's opinion which mattered to me said, your bad at this, then i would give it up. There is a way of putting the same thing across in a different way.

Karan really respects Arshad's opinion as he has said that in number of his interviews, so it would have hurt him a lot. but he took it so sportingly. with a smile, he is very innocent and clean of heart. I know the dancing was not good, but he is trying his best and is still smiling and enjoying his time there, anyone else in his place, would have given up trying to dance. Give him that much at least.

Plz dont favour ur favorite couples or actors saying that the judgement was rude and all. This is a dance show not a comedy or favorite actor contest etc. Judge the dancers by their capability and talent.
Personally i think the act was not up to the level of ZND2. Fine it was entertaining but mostly they were not in sink, not completing steps, no finas, and the guy was lip sinking gals lyrics, only thing was there was the chemistry. I think what judges said was true. They got what they deserved.

Karan is the most humble, down to earth and innocent person. Even the judges know that he'll never amswer back or argue with whatever judgement he's given. In every dance performance, he shows tremendous improvement. Many other contestants have had problems with the judges whenever they were given bad comments like Angad, Siddesh, Kapil, etc. But Karan accepts whetever he has been told. That doesnt mean that the judges give him rude comments everytime. U need to be more fair. Ur judges need to learn qualities from Karan!
Well I agree, Karan Kritika's duet was not as good as we had expected it to be, but the thing is they are not trained dancers!! They are just learning..unlike Mukti, Sushant,Siddesh, Akkshat, Sanjeeda, Rakhi, Abhishek, etc, who are either trained or are professional dancers. But Karan and Kritika have never performed in any reality show before this! Why cant the judges be more encouraging? And the main problem was with thier choreography.. I hated their steps..I m just too dissappointed with everything that's going on in the show. 😔 I wish both of them leave this show and start shooting for Kitani Mohabbat Hai season 2 instead.
I love Karan and Kritika even more after seeing their attitude and respect towards the judges yesterday.

Originally posted by: maneeshaF

Plz dont favour ur favorite couples or actors saying that the judgement was rude and all. This is a dance show not a comedy or favorite actor contest etc. Judge the dancers by their capability and talent.
Personally i think the act was not up to the level of ZND2. Fine it was entertaining but mostly they were not in sink, not completing steps, no finas, and the guy was lip sinking gals lyrics, only thing was there was the chemistry. I think what judges said was true. They got what they deserved.

well U didnt get the topic.. it says that Karan accepted everything with a smile...the judges said what they felt but they were very rude. If any other contestant was in his place, he wud have definately answered back, but Karan just kept quite listening to what was being said about him. U dont need to go against the topic here..if u are so interested in talking abt their performance, then open a new thread.