karan took it all without a word and with a smile.

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Divya

@Star_45

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

#51

i didnt really like there performance

i didnt like the song , they could have done bettter (Y) :\

Quote

charmz517

@charmz517

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

#52

Originally posted by: -Sneha
I don't think it was rude or inappropriate in any way. Karan IS a bad dancer, and he himself accepts it so many times in interviews et al. If someone told me I was bad at something, and knew I was, I would take it with a smile too. And you can obviously see how much I am a fan of Karan, so I am actually very very proud of his attitude towards it all.

I was actually happy with the scores yesterday about their dance for once. Everyone must get an equal treatment on the show, something that wasn't happening since the past few weeks. I guess yesterday set it more right with the scores at least.

Really though, the only thing that's keeping me hooked to this whole thing is Karan. I swear I'd stop watching almost immediately if he and Kritika left. Last year was so much fun, this year is plain boring now.

Right on Sneha! Couldn't agree with you more! 👍🏼

Judges are doing their job and all 3 of them have personal and professional experience as dancers/choreographers. They have every right to speak the truth, which is why they were brought on the show to judge. When Karan did good, they gave him AWESOME comments, so how about look a the positive?

Anyone who watched last season, would realize what "UNFAIR" and "RUDE" is. Malika Arora constantly put down Jennifer Winget every time she performed. One episode was hilarious, where Malika said that Jennifer screwed up and messed up Amit (Tandon), right after that, Saroj Khan who was the guest judge said that Jennifer is actually the one that held the performance together and that if she didn't know how to control her body weight and didn't perform on rhythm, then Amit wouldn't be able to perform any of those lifts (that they did). What a slap in Malika's face, where she has nothing to say and just looked down. That is when you know who is technically experienced in dancing and who is not. 👏

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Sneha Desai

@-Sneha

Inactive

+ 3

Posted: 15 years ago

#53

Originally posted by: priyankumupal

I usually won't defend a point so much if i didn't really believe in it. but i respect your opinion as well. i'm not so hurt because i'm a fan of Karan's (which is only part of it) i'm also hurt because it was not the way to express your opinion to a human being who is trying his very best to improve.

p.s- yha i love Ishaan and Suhana, they are really sweet and shows the reality of life as it is.

I guess we should agree to disagree then! 😉

And yeah, I always defend my points a lot... 😆

Oh definitely, Sasural Genda Phool is a top-quality show. But most on SP don't usually keep that standard after 20 episodes like I was saying in the Debate Mansion. I hope this one does, I really do. Pratigya as well, I like the new concept and experimentation those creatives have tried, as far as going to make the main lead a gangster. Superb, I've got to admit. And then, there's Rishta.com as well, which unfortunately though, hasn't got that much of fame. Three shows that perfectly combine television requirements and real life. 👍🏼

Side note: Thanks for agreeing with me everyone else, DC, Charmz and so on! I guess we've known each other for some time that our minds function the same way! 😳 Miss you girls! 🤗

Quote

Anchi.

@Anchi.

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#54

Hey I sumwhat partially agree wid al u guys
Shibz hugs 2 u🤗u spoke my heart👏👏dat was what I wntd 2 say but I guess ur beta at explaining.....Well we don't kno whether Arshad said dat as a joke or he was actually trying 2 make Karan realise that he is a bad dancer......but dat comment was realy rude noone has d right 2 say dat 2 ny1 n he commented dat on National TV.....believe me its so embarassing wen ur told lyk dat infront of ur friends audience n so mny ppl who r wtchng u....n Arshad's way of commenting was vry rude.. He cud hav encouraged Karan by sayin dat he wud lyk him 2 work harder n giv beta performances in future... He is a Judge he has d right 2 say what is right n what is wrong n he can criticize d contestants for their weak perfo but he can't b so insulting.... Karan I don thnk tuk it 2 heart he instead tackled d whole situation vry nicely makin dat comment 2 be funny although he might hav felt hurt n he really respects Arshad.....its clear from his interviews...Arshad was d one who once for his 1st perfo wich he dint lyk askd him 2 work hard n wen next tym he did dat he was appreciated by him d most n called him a Rockstar n now juz coz d perfo was slightly weak on dat particular epi he called him a bad dancer!dat was not required at all...n Karan we r so proud of him he respects his judges comments!

Anyways Karan is deffo working hard on his future perfo n we r sure he'll be abl 2 impress al of us wid his coming perfo!Gud Luck 2 Karan!⭐️

Edited by blossom18 - 15 years ago

Quote

Prani

@Pranii

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#55

Originally posted by: shibz
well i read all the posts here..n i agree wit almost everybody..
wat i hav2 say is dat every coin has 2 sides...few follow heads while few follow tails..😳

i wudnt hav bothered much for Arshad' comments if i din see pain in karan' eyes...it was soo clear dat He was hurt..! though He tuk it all sportingly He was disheartened for sure..
yea may b Arshad dint mean2 hurt Him...but i cannot believ dat Arshad is soo foolish dat He dint realize His comment was insultin..

for Some here Hu say U wudnt feel bad if someone said U wer bad at sumthin u kno U are...n dat karan Himself kept sayin dat in His interviews.., den i wud like 2 correct...that karan did say He was a bad dancer befor He joined ZND n neva in any interviews afta He did..
also...its discouragin n painful wen u kno u r improvin at sumthin U wer bad at..yet nw u r reminded of it..wich used2 b your weakness..n u r said dat U are stil the same..dat too by sumone u respect a lot..
Moreova nw dat He has developed the confidenc in Him...dat He can danc n the same Arshad Hu had praised Him before nw says "He cannot dance" is really sad...
Its vry easy 2 say dat karan wud hav accepted it n therz no reason 2 feel bad bout it...But den...none of us is Karan n none of us hav faced dat situation wher u are made fun of on the national TV n in between your colleagues.. He too has self respect.. but dats not the point...as we see Hez nt the one2 make a big issue of anythin..(Hez an easy goin fellow n innocent too) wat remains is the hard work..the heart n soul karan has put in2 this sho... none of us kno hw much He has worked hard for it.. So its really disappointin wen u expect for gud comments n the worse comes as a shock...besides karan was performin 1st tym wit His sweetheart n was pretty excited for dat round...so dat can als b the reason He got upset..

havin said dat....as a person we kno kk is...He wud'v taken even this positively...😃

regardin His FB status..He was happy that Judges liked thei chemistry so He preferred puttin up dat rather dan writin bout the minus points.. He knows His fans wud b happy2 kno bout thei chemistry in dance...so thats wat He wud hav thot of highlightin rather dan showin upset n depressin everyone around😃

but m happy...dat atleas nw i dun see anybody pointing thei finger at karan sayin He dint deserv those points unlike las tym....mny had prob wit Judges praisin karan...

regardin the scriptin..i believ most part of the sho is scripted nt completely..

🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗

this is to u and stuti and anchal 😳

totally luv u guys, and also to the topic starter :))

u guys made me see the things that never occurred to me :D really thanks a lot.

i m in love with Karan all the more after all this and reading ur posts and respect him more than ever. aww god bless him, he is indeed the sweetest and bestest and i m soo very proud of him.

i still havnt been able to watch the epi😭 so i cannot comment on anything with certainty. but whatever u guys hav written, cudnt agree more.

and ya as i read others posts, they r right in their own way but i hold the view that Arshad shud never had said such a thing, there is always a polite way. and i really m so sad how it seems they r always making fun of Karan😭 like when i caught a glimpse of the epi, hated how Arshad pointed at Karan and said that the person who came in front of Shilpa's car is Karan, really felt bad and angry😡😭 but luv Karan for everything that he is😳 and luv u guys😳

Quote

-Olly-

@-Olly-

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#56

hey thanks pranii🤗this is for u thank u for liking my post it was something that came from within my heart i couldnot bear arshads coment he was so rude hate him 😡. by the way u also imagined arjun in place of harshad in tere liye me too😛😉 he would have rocked it but we have to wait till kmh 2 july i think .what say ready to rock with arjuhi again😉😉😉😉😉😉😉😉😉😉😉😉

Quote

Miya

@-Miya-

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#57

it was said in a very discouraging way!! Judges are there to judge and point out faults..to help the dancer improve in their performances..but here? i agree that the performance lacked that something, some steps weren't clean and at times their nervousness especially around lifts and runs was evident

even a "you could've done better, much better" would've done but Arshad had to pull it this far..he probably knew that Karan is a fun loving type of guy alway joking around so maybe he wanted to play along but he didn't realize when he took it too far

discouraging is not a good sign of a judge :( i'm disappointed

Quote

Prani

@Pranii

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#58

Originally posted by: olly13244
hey thanks pranii🤗this is for u thank u for liking my post it was something that came from within my heart i couldnot bear arshads coment he was so rude hate him 😡. by the way u also imagined arjun in place of harshad in tere liye me too😛😉 he would have rocked it but we have to wait till kmh 2 july i think .what say ready to rock with arjuhi again😉

aww that's really sooo shweet of u :)) 🤗 luv u for luving Karan so much and being soo so sweet 😳

tere liye, i just caught glimpses, not interested in it. and sorry but no i didnt imagine Karan in Harshad's place but the similarities were really hurting😭 kept on reminding me of Arjuhi.😭😭but ya only a few months or say weeks to go then our Arjuhi will rock the screen 😃

by the way whats ur name buddy? so nice talking to u😳

Edited by Pranii - 15 years ago

Quote

144398

Hibernated

Posted: 15 years ago

#59

I was just reading through the comments and they have been a mixed review upon Karan and Kritika's Performances.....

All I would like to say is that although they might be some flaws into their perfomances but instead of discourage them the judges should encourage them to do even better next time......And if they find any faults into the Chorogaphy section then I would suggest that they should speak to the Chorograpers first.......

I would also like to say that it is not entirely Karan and Kritika's fault.....Whatever steps they told to do,Crops to be used or whatever face expressions to make in specify places were all taught by the Chorographers.....So I would rather say sepak to them first....Karan and Kritika is just doing their job and were doing whatever's being asked to do in Stage....

Examples

Lets say it was a first day of nursery for the toddlers.....All they know is how to trouble people and play......

Within 3 months they would have to get them self ready for the School and therefore would have to learn by them self how to eat,drink and write Alphabeticals letters and numbers.....But it has been 1 and a half months now.....Although there are trying nearly there but not 100% There.......and also the teachers havent been giving them their 100% to them instead they told them rudely its been 1 and a half months since you came here and still you dont know how to eat/drink and write....but good at giving us a hard time......Wouldnt that make a child feel hurt and low....That the teachers instead of encouarging them to do things they made the child feel good for nothing......

And that is all I would have to say.......Instead of judges directly saying and making Karan feel he cant dance at all they should encourage them to do alot more better next them and ofcourse try to discuss with their chorographer as well...Where they have to work more on....Dancing,Face expressions,steps they could improve on and others......

Edited by priyagurung - 15 years ago

Quote

taz

@kripsy

Navigator

Posted: 15 years ago

#60

Okay, everyone critcising the choreography:

It is common sense that you never give someone more then what they can handle. It would be utterly unfair to give Karan and Kritika the kind of choreography that is beyond their capabilities. Many of you admit these two are amateurs and they are nowhere near the level where you can expect the kind of magical moves like Mukti and Sushant or even the cute steps of Aamir and Rashmi. They were given what the choreographers thought they could handle - and even that was quite a lot considering Kritika mentioned how hard she was having to work to get the steps right and how they had been rehearsing a lot more. I think it is really unfair to criticise the moves especially when they weren't executed properly by the dancers.

As for Arshad being "rude", I got the feeling from the circusesque performance Karan did a few weeks back, that he thought he was good. Agreed he has improved immensely but he is not in anyway "good". I think Arshad wanted to make that clear and also he was encouraging, after making that comment he expressed how much he loves Karan's energy and enthusiasm and if that is harnessed with lessons he would become an awesome performer. This isn't kindergarten and these two aren't children, they are in a profession where people are under constant scrutiny. At least the criticism from Arshad will be valuable to them as members of the entertainment industry as opposed to the comments of random people suffering tunnel vision.....

Edited by kripsy - 15 years ago

Quote

1 2 3 4 5 6

karan took it all without a word and with a smile. - Page 6

Related Topics

Explore Topics