shilpa and judges/judging..

im not questioning their judging but is it just me or does she just like comedy acts.. she willingly gives 9/10 to either really dramatic performances or really comedy.. so to impress shilpa, just make her laugh?? is that wat dance is abuot? todays episode.. thats all that the boys did... and tomorrows seems like angad's solo is pretty serious..(song or topic) i donno..

is it just me or is it like this...like sometimes arshad seems bias too but not all the time and vaibahi has been pretty fair on my behalf but its just shilpa who is bugging me.. i mean i know her scores before the dance is even done! WAHT UP WITH THAT!

she's a bad judge...thts all i knw

thats what i even thought ...she has been carried away with all the secondary things other than dance.........
no wonder comments and scores coming from a flop actress are like this...her judging is unbarable when u compare with other two...

she is there only to show off her diamond ring and nothing else

Hey whatever you have said i felt same even.... Its not about Shilpa only but about all judges. Are they here to judge dance show or comedy show????

If contestants makes you laugh then you give them highest score and contestants who actually dance gets lesser marks. Some of the boys act are really bugging me... Why there is comedy flavour and drama in many acts... We are watching dance show and not comedy show......

i still cant get over the fact that she gave 10 to KK for his dance...

yipee, I truely appreciate efforts done by Karan. I have seen his Charlin Chaplin performance. His foot work was really really bad. But after watching his yesterday performance, he had worked really really hard to improve himself........

But if its about comparing Hazel and his performance together, I felt Hazzel was better than him. Its good that he made everyone laugh by his act. But isnt it injustice to Hazzel that she got less score despite of the fact she was better....

Same with Girls, Mahiya Mahiya performance. They got 1 mark less. May I know why?? Just because boys team made judges laugh??? So ridiculous!!!


If comedy is criteria to judge any performance in this show then change the name of this show.

Originally posted by: yipee

i still cant get over the fact that she gave 10 to KK for his dance...

wht judging is that?

as much as i love KK, iwudnt give him more than 8 for that...

i agree Karan didnot deserved 10......and i didnt find his perf funny...why were the judges laughing so much?? Even i am a big fan of Karan and kritika but still i would say Karan's perf from nowhere desreved 10 or 9

i agree with darshu n cutiepie...

agreed karan has improved but still his perf did not deserve more than 8...IMO hazel had tougher steps and "danced" very well...karan did score more in the expressions dept...so they were more or less on par...

giving one 10 and the other 8 was def not justified and was poor judging IMHO...

same with the grp act...though i agree girls had come co ordination problems esp in the beginning, i thought they were better than boys...boys comedy part in the dance wasnt funny to me at all TBH...

so again here the judging was bad...y 8 to gals and 9 to boys?

similarly i think kapil danced better than sangita in the duet...the duet choreography was bad and the concept was silly...i agree sangita had a gud presence of mind...but a diff of 19 and 23???? that was wrong...kapil had more finesse in his steps IMO...

i think today's whole show had "judging" problems...except for fusion round where i more or less agreed