| First Three Seasons Frustration Thread #2 | [DT Note: pg-65] - Page 35

Originally posted by: AuthorSneha

I might be downvoted, but Akshara is at fault. I understand she must be in shock because of losing her son but atleast after few months toh she could have informed.

Manjari deserved to know the truth. Baat nahi karni thi because of Ruhi, toh atleast text/e-mail kar sakti thi.

Akshara has always taken impulsive rash decisions in the garb of sacrifice.

I don't like birlas but just imagine all these years what abhi's mom must have felt, that her child is happy but never tried to contact her & cut her off? What roohi must have felt? That her poppy built a new life with Billa boy & new baby & never tried contacting her?

💯

She doesn't deserve to be a FL and legacy FL toh bilkul bhi nahi!!

Manish and co are aged now. Akshara should ve been taking care of them!!!

Instead because of Akshara, they had to raise ruhi, being great grand parents. And ruhi has taken care of them!!!

Why is the blame on Goenka's now??

Akshara is solely responsible for all the mess in Goenka's and Birla's life.

Yes this is what I said in my above post.. Manju would have definitely wanted to reach out and look out for abhimanyu.. She would know..

Originally posted by: AuthorSneha

That was different. Of course we might disagree, but Akshara was given divorce and thrown out of the house. If there is any ounce of self respect, why should she go back to abhimanyu?

& She did call to inform.

Those people would have either taken her baby from her, or she would have had to go back to birla house. Should she have hidden is subjective but I can understand why she did it .

But in this case, it's different. Manjari didn't kick her out of house , she chose to leave goenka house on her own will. & There was no need to inform about baby sharma also since she has cut off, good that she didn't . My point was only Abhimanyu 's mother had a right to know her child died.

How is it different?? She got pregnant before their divorce. He had all the rights to know about his child!!!

Which Akshara conveniently hid just for revenge. This is yet again the same scenario, where she decides what others should know. Selfish, self centred woman

In that case she should have told Ruhi started the car? Made her guilty for Life and ruined her life..

How conveniently that Kid forgot..

Originally posted by: Swathiyaa

In that case she should have told Ruhi started the car? Made her guilty for Life and ruined her life..

How conveniently that Kid forgot..

Why is the kid being blamed now??

She was 6 yrs old. Huh!!!

Goenka's didn't worry about her because abhimanyu went with her and they knew she is with him!!!

It's simple as that!!

And if Goenka's are not aware, even Birla's wouldn't know!!!

Ruhi starting the car is not the reason arohi died. It was akshara who took wrong decisions at that point. Instead of screaming and running to arohi and pushing her from the location she decided to control the situation by trying to control the car. The car has horns too. Which madam conveniently forgot. Blaming ruhi for just starting car who is just 6 years where as akshara who is 30+ years unable to make any decision to fix the situation is not blamed is hilarious.

Originally posted by: MouMalikPatra

It's not clear if Birlas know about Abhi and Abhir. My best guess is, they do as Akshara informed them after some time. But by the time Birlas have left Udaipur and didn't inform Goenkas as their ties were already cut. That is the best case scenario. Because going by Akshara's nature, she wouldn't kept something this big from Manjari at least. She won't contact the Goenkas.

No it's impossible that Birla's know and Goenka's doesn't. Ruhi is the connect between gorillas. If Birla's knew, ruhi would definitely know.

And since they have removed Birla's from equation, Manju knowing the truth doesn't matter in the story. It's about the Goenka's now.

Sach and sach jaane wali bhi ab iss duniya mein nahi hai!!!🤣🤣🤣

Both the scenarios are different. Cannot compare it with Akshara hid about Abhir from abhimanyu..

Like I said, Should she have hidden about Abhir being abhimanyu's biological son from birlas is subjective but I can understand why she did it ."Mere pass tumhe batane ki koi vajah nahi thi. Maine nahi btaya kyunki tumhare aur abhir ke beech sirf khoon ka rishta hai, asal mein tum uske baap nahi ho"
The answer for why Akshara hid was given by her when Abhimanyu questioned ki bataya kyu nahi. Remember the dialogue when Abhi asked her ek bure pati ki saza ek baap ko kyu di ?

Though yes, I agree abhimanyu should have known. Because Marraige where a child is involved is not the same like a relationship break up where you can completely cut off without any communication. Yes, abhimanyu deserved to know about abhir, but I also understand why she hid it, though legally it's wrong.

& This is only speculation, we don't know if Akshara has not informed manjari about abhimanyu 's death. Also, the goenkas treated akshara horribly & if she cut off contact with them, she did no wrong. My point was only, if she has not informed manjari, then she is at fault.

Originally posted by: AuthorSneha

Both the scenarios are different. Cannot compare it with Akshara hid about Abhir from abhimanyu..

Like I said, Should she have hidden about Abhir being abhimanyu's biological son from birlas is subjective but I can understand why she did it ."Mere pass tumhe batane ki koi vajah nahi thi. Maine nahi btaya kyunki tumhare aur abhir ke beech sirf khoon ka rishta hai, asal mein tum uske baap nahi ho"
The answer for why Akshara hid was given by her when Abhimanyu questioned ki bataya kyu nahi. Remember the dialogue when Abhi asked her ek bure pati ki saza ek baap ko kyu di ?

& This is only speculation, we don't know if Akshara has not informed manjari about abhimanyu 's death. Also, the goenkas treated akshara horribly & if she cut off contact with them, she did no wrong. My point was only, if she has not informed manjari, then she is at fault.

It was the same situation birla's were never bad. Akshara painted them as bad inorder to justify her deed of hiding the kid from her father. So both are same situation as akshara hid this from abhimanyu as she felt he rejected her and she may not have informed manjari as she must have felt manjari rejected her.