Created

Last reply

Replies

63

Views

5.6k

Users

20

Likes

156

Frequent Posters

Posted: 2 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: cutepigs

My issue with Abhinav is also only this that he always nowadays calls Abhir only his son as if Akshara is the step mom. And plus ya, he keeps asking Akshara for support but doesn't support her anymore. Ever since they are in Udaipur and he has insecurity now, he doesn't support Akshara at all. Even in the hospital today, he didn't go to Akshara to support her, he allowed everyone to support him.


In front of Abhimanyu, he is now just a man who wants "his" son, not Akshara's son, his son. That's the issue I have with him, nothing to do with Abhimanyu or Akshara.

He always did that even in kasauli when only 3 of them were there.Even Ak used to say aap ka beta. That’s not degrading Ak and Ak is his mother and she don’t need any approval or acceptance from anyone. She has all the rights on him. Yes he is insecure of losing Abhir whom he loves more than his life so Ak is supporting him as he supported her from last 6yrs.
Lostin90s thumbnail
Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail 5th Anniversary Thumbnail + 4

Team Sharmas

Posted: 2 years ago
#32

Abhinav ka mandir main banau ya na banau par aap log Abhimanyu ke nam ka locket ya bracelet jarur pahan le



bye bye
Take care

Posted: 2 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: verve

I read the diff takes on this thread and many pts. are right in their perspective. I hope writers have achieved their purpose now 👏 These conflict of perspectives arise totally bcos of the vahyad merry-go-round of the screenplay that's going on for past mts.

Writers aren't sure of what they want. So they give Akshnav scenes to entice new audience & then backtrack it to not let go of Abhira fans.


During 1st UD trip, they showed them progressing with little gesture of removing ji from their names & instantly the next day Ak became paro and ran to Ab. One day they show Ak saying "I would choose Nav 100x." Then another episode give her dialogues "Mai apka ehsaan kaise chukaungi." They show progress with soft scenes, but backtrack it with Ak spilling her bedroom secret.

At this pt., audiences from both sides are bound to be left confused. What are writers ultimately aiming at? Plus the brilliant dialogues just add petrol to this fire.


Today it was glaringly visible that no one was standing with Ak. Even I mentioned this in my post. What was the purpose behind this? To show Gs are useless (we all already know) ; To show Nav is a bad partner ; or To whitewash Manjhari maa??

God knows.


The lengthy useless poems, inconsistent pacing, odd-even day arcs... this all is not only offputting, it's making it hard to articulate firm opinions bcos of unsureness what'll happen the v.next episode.

True , they r sailing on 2 boats at the moment .they r playing odd and even day to confuse the viewers but this will leave Ak in bad light if she is still in love with her so called soul mate and using AbN for now to fulfill her dreams.We all know that Most probably the end game will be Abhira but they r trying to drag as much as they can as the Trp’s are constant so trp contributors are happy with the story line. Only after IPL the story might progress.
Edited by Chaitu.V - 2 years ago
DevilHere thumbnail

YRKKH Fans

Posted: 2 years ago
#34

Ideally since they're showing AkshNav as a pair nd Ak keeps on insisting that Abhir is AkshNav child the precap scene should have been between them...even in today episode there should've been some scenes where both together r scared as parents but r being each other strength communicating non verbally or verbally...I guess that's what's missing...I kinda understand what u r saying with Nav fearing loss of Abhir but it was just sad how accept MJ no one consoled Ak but were rather fixated at the fathers , she's got rights nd everything but incorporating that in screenplay is also essential...AkshNav should've been a single unit here...these r tough times nd that was missing

jhustju thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: Chaitu.V

He is not insecure because he is an orphan he is insecure because he is scared of losing his son who he loves more than his life. Goenka’s r the worst family no one can wish for. I wonder why Ak never questions them though. She lives in delusion that her family loves her may be. AbM respects everyone except Ak. She is a punching bag for everyone right from Ar to AbM .At least I didn’t see AbN playing any sympathy card to grab attention from anyone today even Anand consoled him wonder why 😅 May be they wanted to white wash Mj..so they made her hug Ak as no one else did.Kairav stood up for his sister though and he also consoled Ak. Think They kept open options to root to Abhira or Akshnav so they r playing with the viewers.


Similarly for Akshara her fear of losing her son is her greatest fear. She finally has someone who loves her unquestioningly and unconditionally. Abhimanyu behaved like that because of his childhood trauma. Kairav is the way he is because of his experience with Anisha. Goenkas are the way they are because that is all Akshara has shown them. All the characters have a reason for behaving the way they did. We do not excuse anyone for their behavior so why should I excuse Abhinav? Also Jai Soni is doing himself no favors by the over dramatic acting that has been happening


I also think some of our opinions or viewpoints are colored by personal experiences. I will never ask for sympathy and I hate crying in public so even at my lowest point my tears were in the privacy of my bathroom or in front of my husband. I do not even cry in front of my parents. But people in my life and most people with compassion understand that just because someone is not making a show of their grief and vulnerabilities does not mean they are unfeeling or are ok with the situation. The last few months we have only see Abhinav focus on his feelings. Just because Akshara is not making a whole production of her hurt, fear and insecurities does not mean she is OK

Edited by jhustju - 2 years ago
Posted: 2 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: sweet_tania

Leech ka toh pata nahi but bahot attention seeker lag raha tha aj isiliye patient ke ward mai pair pakad kar roye ja raha tha.


Akshara se bhi kayiiiii zyada dukh sirf usi ko hai aisa mahol create kiya usne toh bhai saab! Kya pair pakad kar roya . Usko khud ko bhi acche se pata tha ki pair pakad kar roye ha nahi toh bhi abhir ka surgery ho jayega lekin fir bhi yeh stunt kiya patient ke room mai!

Bacche ki maa fir bhi kone mai akeli apne ap ko sambhal rahi thi lekin yeh bande toh full fledge mai busy tha yeh prove karne mai ki Akshara se bhi zyada dukhi wohi hai abhir ke liye.

ur reply cracked me up 😂😂

He heard that AbM cannot operate the kid as he is his son and Ar trying to convince him and Anand trying to find a Dr from more than half an hr but unsuccessful.God only knows what happened to that Dr.Roy who flew overnight without a visa. If u rem A few days back he challenged AbM that he can lose anything but not his son but today for Abhir’s sake he is ready to give up Abhir too so he said not my son but ur son.
Even I wondered why no one except Kairav consoled Ak even Anand consoled AbN ..writers ki jai ho 😅

Posted: 2 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: DevilHere

Ideally since they're showing AkshNav as a pair nd Ak keeps on insisting that Abhir is AkshNav child the precap scene should have been between them...even in today episode there should've been some scenes where both together r scared as parents but r being each other strength communicating non verbally or verbally...I guess that's what's missing...I kinda understand what u r saying with Nav fearing loss of Abhir but it was just sad how accept MJ no one consoled Ak but were rather fixated at the fathers , she's got rights nd everything but incorporating that in screenplay is also essential...AkshNav should've been a single unit here...these r tough times nd that was missing

yes , I guess they r intentionally confusing the audience so they r left with both the options open Abhira and Akshnav. But most probably end game will be Abhira but for now they r milking the viewers with IPL and constant Trp’s
DevilHere thumbnail

YRKKH Fans

Posted: 2 years ago
#38

I mean atleast from where I can see Abhira is their endgame...Nd i don't want to accept that pair without a proper redemption arc...yeh odd even storylines nd inconsistent screenplay ki jgh acha redemption arc hi de dete i don't think TRP affect hoti if they had played that we'll...coz tbh rn from the writing direction screenplay everything is shitty nd u can see that in acting as well...i consider most of the cast as good actors but currently I'm pretty much dissatisfied with all....So if this can fetch Trp that would too.... it's high time they do away with the ambiguity coz it's not like they're doing any justice to AkshNav ....this is my personal opinion but i don't see AkshNav as good well written second chance at love/friends to lovers trope

cutepigs thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 2 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: Chaitu.V

He always did that even in kasauli when only 3 of them were there.Even Ak used to say aap ka beta. That’s not degrading Ak and Ak is his mother and she don’t need any approval or acceptance from anyone. She has all the rights on him. Yes he is insecure of losing Abhir whom he loves more than his life so Ak is supporting him as he supported her from last 6yrs.


That's the same as every mother saying your child when the kid does some mistake. Repeating that in front of Abhimanyu is just trying to rub salts. Abhimanyu at least says humara beta to him, he says mera beta to only Akshara.

Insecurity seems to be making Abhinav regard Abhir as a prize to win, which gets him Akshara too. Right now, Akshara is the one who wants support, even between Abhi and Akshara, she needs more support, she is the mother who is close to losing her son, Abhinav might have been with her in the journey and supported her, Abhi might be the father, but Akshara is still the one who needs maximum support.

Noorain13 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 2 years ago
#40

I think Nav is called out based on how his character is shaped and how he is a hurdle for Abhira to reunite. I wouldn't say I am big on ITV shows but I have watched some and those with leaps/separations can go on for months before a reunion and here we are talking about ye rishta so for people to complain about him being in the show for over 5 months doesn't make sense. There are times his ss is more than others and at times he's barely seen for the entire week. I am sure if he was shown as an abusive husband and Abhimanyu would come to save his soulmate, no would have an issue with him.

I do think he was not brought in for this long but audience have seemed to accepted him and thats the reason he's still here and trust me Akshnav will never be the end game, it will alway be Abhira but they will keep Nav in the story for as long as they can and once his purpose is over, they will prepare his exit. His exit is certainly not needed at this moment where Akshara will need his support.

Also, I've seen a lot of posts mentioning he came to gain sympathy and made it all about himself or that no one cared about Akshara but Manjari. All I saw was a helpless father and if he didn't act that way he'd be questioned as to not having any emotions for Abhir anymore lol. The episode was literally 20 mins people. How can we determine that in that timeframe? If they showed this for at least 4-5 episodes. we'd see everyone consoling one another but within that span, it was not possible. Those who are grateful to KM for consoling AK are out of my league. That woman cannot be redeemed with a hug especially if Abhir had fallen sick in Akshnav's presence, we'd see how she would have started calling them out. This 60 something year old woman called out Abhir's parents for being irresponsible and we are over here being grateful lol.


FYI, if Nav sees the hug, he will definitely try to leave and AK will stop him but then he will get called out for manipulation and what not whereas AK is the one who cant let him go. Lets just accept the FACTS instead of being delulu.

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: cutepigs

1 months ago

Geetanjali vs Abhinav

I keep telling myself to not comment and then I get sucked in with Instagram comments smiley36 I was reading comments on who is Geetanjali to...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: shahsb_26

2 months ago

Akshara - Abhir - Abhinav :: A perfect Family moments

Those days were they had perfect family! Absolutely no one in this generation can even come close to precious rishta these three had! No...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".