Rinky should start respecting herself & act maturely! Loved IshRa - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

49

Views

5.2k

Users

13

Likes

135

Frequent Posters

anjs thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#31
very good topic Dev...and also the comments are very well...though my opinion slightly differ...i feel Rinky's situation is more of a result of Toshi, Ishita and Mihir's decision, rather than her...
I do understand Toshi's mindset, unfortunately neither Mr Bhalla nor Raman tried to make her see reason

in the mandap, .she didnt need to marry immediately, it wasnt her fault that the groom was a fraud...but a girl needs the support of her family in such situations, and instead of doing that, Toshi, Mr Bhalla and Raman were just sitting around with a morose face, saying that her life is ruined...any girl will become more weak emotionally if her family say such stuff...so Rinky also became too vulnerable...

i expected atleast Ishita to pacify Toshi, that life doesnt end here, but her solution was more retarded...by getting the next guy available

now mihir gave her a lamba lecture, promising a future together as soulmates...and he did proved to be a good partner, when he helped her with her studies etc...maybe during that time she fell in love with him...

hence i dont think Rinky is being immature...

she is a newly wedded bride, who was shown a dream of a happy marriage by mihir...albeit for a few days...and now suddenly it seems like a mirage...any girl will feel insecure in such situation...

its mihir's responsibility to make her feel secure...more so now cause mihika has been given a clean slate...also him stating work reason, doesnt hold much value, since he had all the time in world to cheer up mihika...esp when he knows that mihika isnt alone, she has her family with her...

last but not the least...i dont think Mihika is a victim...whatever has happened with her, is her own doing...initally when Ashok used to provoke her, Mihir had asked her to resign...but she shut him up, that she can handle moron's like ashok easily...then doing so much for shagun...despite knowing what a selfish woman shagun is...after that handling ashok's black mailing alone...what was she thinking...that mihir will be happy to be saved, after knowing that she married ashok...even after knowing that suraj is well, she stayed put with ashok...waiting for him to force her...who had asked her to do that vulgar dance in the party with ashok ? he hadnt held at gun point than...

plus her marrying ashok, automatically directed the problem named shagun towards ishita and raman's life...

so basically, i think the major contributor to rinky's life mess, is toshi and mihika...and ishita n mihir to a smaller extent...

but i do agree with you, that rinky needs to stop crying n take charge of her life...if mihir wants to spend time with mihika...let him do so...she shud do what she wants to do...infact i loved it when she left for bhalla house without informing mihir...and also loved in the precap how she back-answered mihika...mihika has done enough, she doesnt need to interfere in their marriage life more...esp advising rinky, when she knows that rinky is insecure with her closeness to mihir...

mihika shud just leave mihir rinky alone for now...give them some space to atleast let mihir move on n give a chance to their marriage...having her hovering around, will never give mihir the chance to move on...he will keep feeling guilty for not trusting mihika that time...

btw, i dont hold mihir guilty for mihika's mess...she is alone responsible for it...her u-turn can make any person doubt her...
Edited by anjs - 10 years ago
anjs thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: gravity23


I agree...

Also, Ive always felt Rinki had a soft spot for Mihir..since earlier..

and so she has eased into this marriage better than Mihir has...

I hate the fact that Mihika shud choose to go talk to Rinki abt it, no matter how provoked Shagun might have led her to be

She could go ask Mihir wat happened...but not Rinki...coz she's after all the EX...

And no wife wud stand for that shit...

and if Mihika DID mention something about the trip, then hands down its HER fault


I really wnt the elders to step in...sit Mihir down and have a word with him

and if it seems Mihir wants to go back to Mihika, then OWN HIS FEELINGS in front of Raman...instead of confiding only in Rinki and leading her to do some sacrifice shit...

why shud she?

Also, I just want this sordid triangle love story to end...Rinki was better off as a careerist woman...I dont want her chopping her locks and getting under-eye bags coz of a man who doesnt love her or care to see her in the capacity she exists in his life right now...as his wife


and wats with Mihir blaming himself and Mihika lecturing Rinki ki, "trust ur man"

Really?

Did SHE trust Mihir when he was almost set to be engaged to Trisha?

No..she was crying buckets, and being all indifferent...

Did she blame herself ki "Maine kaise soch liye ki Mihir aisa kar sakta hai..." yada yda...

then why is Mihir expected to be a mind-reader and know the motive behind all of Mihika's actions?

Also, WHY cant CVs bring in a plot...that makes Mihika move away from Delhi and Mihir and all this sordid nonsense...?? isnt it the most logical thing to do?
dont exes usually do that? MOVE AWAY...to bury old memories and create new ones?

How insensitive...tht not even the Iyers are coaching Mihika as to wat she shud be doing right now

no one cares how Rinki might be feeling at this point


agree with all your points...esp the bold one...just a week back Amma was worried with Subbu being around Ishita damaging IshRA marriage...so why didnt she think that Mihika being around Mihir can damage Minky marriage as well...esp when Mihir still might have a soft corner for Mihika, whereas Ishita has moved on from subbu long back
gravshrav23 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: anjs

very good topic Dev...and also the comments are very well...though my opinion slightly differ...i feel Rinky's situation is more of a result of Toshi, Ishita and Mihir's decision, rather than her...

I do understand Toshi's mindset, unfortunately neither Mr Bhalla nor Raman tried to make her see reason

in the mandap, .she didnt need to marry immediately, it wasnt her fault that the groom was a fraud...but a girl needs the support of her family in such situations, and instead of doing that, Toshi, Mr Bhalla and Raman were just sitting around with a morose face, saying that her life is ruined...any girl will become more weak emotionally if her family say such stuff...so Rinky also became too vulnerable...

i expected atleast Ishita to pacify Toshi, that life doesnt end here, but her solution was more retarded...by getting the next guy available

now mihir gave her a lamba lecture, promising a future together as soulmates...and he did proved to be a good partner, when he helped her with her studies etc...maybe during that time she fell in love with him...

hence i dont think Rinky is being immature...

she is a newly wedded bride, who was shown a dream of a happy marriage by mihir...albeit for a few days...and now suddenly it seems like a mirage...any girl will feel insecure in such situation...

its mihir's responsibility to make her feel secure...more so now cause mihika has been given a clean slate...also him stating work reason, doesnt hold much value, since he had all the time in world to cheer up mihika...esp when he knows that mihika isnt alone, she has her family with her...

last but not the least...i dont think Mihika is a victim...whatever has happened with her, is her own doing...initally when Ashok used to provoke her, Mihir had asked her to resign...but she shut him up, that she can handle moron's like ashok easily...then doing so much for shagun...despite knowing what a selfish woman shagun is...after that handling ashok's black mailing alone...what was she thinking...that mihir will be happy to be saved, after knowing that she married ashok...even after knowing that suraj is well, she stayed put with ashok...waiting for him to force her...who had asked her to do that vulgar dance in the party with ashok ? he hadnt held at gun point than...

plus her marrying ashok, automatically directed the problem named shagun towards ishita and raman's life...

so basically, i think the major contributor to rinky's life mess, is toshi and mihika...and ishita n mihir to a smaller extent...

but i do agree with you, that rinky needs to stop crying n take charge of her life...if mihir wants to spend time with mihika...let him do so...she shud do what she wants to do...infact i loved it when she left for bhalla house without informing mihir...and also loved in the precap how she back-answered mihika...mihika has done enough, she doesnt need to interfere in their marriage life more...esp advising rinky, when she knows that rinky is insecure with her closeness to mihir...

mihika shud just leave mihir rinky alone for now...give them some space to atleast let mihir move on n give a chance to their marriage...having her hovering around, will never give mihir the chance to move on...he will keep feeling guilty for not trusting mihika that time...

btw, i dont hold mihir guilty for mihika's mess...she is alone responsible for it...her u-turn can make any person doubt her...


I mostly agree with ur comment anjs..

only that, I feel...at the mandap...Toshi and Raman totally rounded up on Ishita (with Shagun getting that NRI's Canadian wife into the picture) and blamed her squarely for everything...as if Ishita Rinki ki Maa hai...aur uski shaadi ki zimmedari uske sar hai..baki exempt hain

Ishita isnt treated like a daughter when things go wrong...she is treated like a typical bahu...and she caved in and had no choice...Toshi ranting and whining is so goddamn irritating ki kisi ko bhi panic attack aa jayega aur woh darr ke maare aise hi decisions lega

rem how BLINDLY Raman signed the papers Shagun gave him? without bothering to go thru it once HIMSELF? Coz he was in a hurry to get Adi home? for Toshi? That wman...she has such regressive thoughts...its coz of her old-fashioned, idiotic mentality that her children are facing so many probs today

am sure she didnt do a bg check on Param...before shipping Simmi off with him..and TILL DATE...In her mind, Param is pati parmeshwar for Simmi...divorce kyun nai le lete yaar?

Romi ko "mera beta" soch soch ke badhawa deti rahi...even when did tht Mihika kaand...and then Sarika pregnancy kaand...

and now Rinki...because she is so worked up in the head ki usko GKC/GKL milega ki nai...ki Rinki se kaun shaadi karega and all...she made Rinki go thru the burner

I abs agree with u when u say for a girl it matters a hell lot if her family stands up for her...yahan toh ganga ulti hi beh rahi thi..woh kehti toh bhi kya kehti...she was shocked and disturbed...and then Mihir came along with his "fresh start, clean slate" promises...

so she saw a glimmer of hope, and on the premise that Mihir put forward, that they're frnds...she gave this marriage a chance...

its not like she jumped with joy at the prospect of getting married to him, as many ppl think...coz she DID look hesitant

All this BS abt him being busy with work, falls flat wen we as an audience see him chatting and laughing with Mihika, and not bothering to even talk t his wife

WHICH husband will tell his wife - ki Im gonna be busy...wat will u do here? go back and stay with ur mayka?

I mean, at that rate, ALL THE HUSBANDS who are busy shud mandatorily ship their wives off to their mayka coz they're busy

that totally indicates he isnt VIEWING this as a marriage only

warna biwi se door rehna kaun chahega??

ulta Rinki ke Bhalla House mein rehne se...Mihir-Mihika HAMESHA aamne saamne aate hain...

why is it so difficult for Mihika to understand that she NEEDS to get out of Mihir's sight and not give this preachy advice to Rinki?

I totally understud when Rinki left the house...uska husband munh be bol raha hai he regrets marrying her...wat shud she have done?

sit at his feet, care for him, shed tears, beg for his love?

I totally get Rinki's point

And Mihika is NO victim

CVs shud just stop painting her as one...that ludicrous track where she married Ashok to "save" Shagun and MIHIR...ruined it all


sunitas123 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: DiyaRathore

Sorry, I beg to differ. Rinky reacted the same way that a typical wife would've reacted in her case. The "Love" you're talking about is a bubbled up thing sold by Bollywood as per its convenience, reality is something very different.

Please note that Rinky-Mihir marriage was neither a contract marriage nor it was a mariage of conveience. When suddenly Ishita brought up the proposal out of nowhere in the shaadi mandaap, Rinki was clearly hesitant. It was Mihir who convinced her by saying that "it will be fresh clean start" from his side. He promised that thier friendship would guide their way of marital life through concern, care and mutual understanding. It might not sound like a "love" story to you as it lacks the exciting color of Bollywood defined "love" but in reaity, it's more than love. It's like two soul mates finally have found each other. Mihir had promised Rinky to be his soulmate.

If I were in Mihir place, I would've been ashamed of myself for marrying a woman when I claerly love someone else. Why would Rinki suffer because of Ishita and Mihir? Mihir clearly gave assurance to Rinky at the time of wedding that he had moved on from his past and wanted to create a new beginning with her.

Rinky's reaction to Mihika's proposal or advice for the vacation/honeymoon was bang on. Any wife would've reacted the same way. Will Ishita take it LIGHTLY if Shagun advices Raman where and when to go for thier (IshRa) pending honeymoon?


DR, Ishita may not mind if Shagun gives her advice where Ishita and Ramn should go for the honeymoon. But most likely Shagun would love to go on a honeymoon with Raman no matter where😆 Ishita put up with Shagun in the Bhalla house for sooo long, she has too much patience and trust in her husband. Rinki did not even have a single conversation with Mihir. Therein lies the difference.
gravshrav23 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: sunitas123


DR, Ishita may not mind if Shagun gives her advice where Ishita and Ramn should go for the honeymoon. But most likely Shagun would love to go on a honeymoon with Raman no matter where😆 Ishita put up with Shagun in the Bhalla house for sooo long, she has too much patience and trust in her husband. Rinki did not even have a single conversation with Mihir. Therein lies the difference.






And THANK GOD Rinki isnt like tht!! Thank heavens...

My heart used to bleed wen Ishita used to go OUT OF HER WAY and make those impossible sacrifices

shuru se hi, if she wud have put her foot down she wud not have been taken for granted by the Bhallas

Rinki isnt like tht...and I dont think its fair to expect those standards of her

I mean...WHY shud she?

A woman putting up with ALL THE SHIT that comes her way isnt always a sign of strength

compromising too much is also a sign of weakness

Rinki may not have had a love marriage with Mihir...but her expectations of him as a wife, arent skewed...she's acting perfectly normally :)



Edited by gravity23 - 10 years ago
gravshrav23 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: anjs


agree with all your points...esp the bold one...just a week back Amma was worried with Subbu being around Ishita damaging IshRA marriage...so why didnt she think that Mihika being around Mihir can damage Minky marriage as well...esp when Mihir still might have a soft corner for Mihika, whereas Ishita has moved on from subbu long back



At the moment so much happened it didnt cross my mind...but come to think of it, it was SO DAMN INSENSITIVE of the Iyers and the Bhallas (Ishita conveniently left the scene) to insist Mihika share the frame with Mihir..its not just ANYBODY...Its a woman Mihir shares a past with...deeply loved...ad still does, in a corner of his heart

are the family members so callous not to realize Rinki's feelings?

wat makes them say SHE is paranoid? Like Raman bit her head off saying she's getting obsessed and all

how was he behaving wen Ishita and Mani spent days hanging out and chit-chatting? Not nice, right?

And Mani wasnt even Ishu's ex!

And yet, Raman could not bear it

I hate it when CVs bring hypocrisy in their plots...very pissing off
sunitas123 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: gravity23


I mostly agree with ur comment anjs..

only that, I feel...at the mandap...Toshi and Raman totally rounded up on Ishita (with Shagun getting that NRI's Canadian wife into the picture) and blamed her squarely for everything...as if Ishita Rinki ki Maa hai...aur uski shaadi ki zimmedari uske sar hai..baki exempt hain

Ishita isnt treated like a daughter when things go wrong...she is treated like a typical bahu...and she caved in and had no choice...Toshi ranting and whining is so goddamn irritating ki kisi ko bhi panic attack aa jayega aur woh darr ke maare aise hi decisions lega

rem how BLINDLY Raman signed the papers Shagun gave him? without bothering to go thru it once HIMSELF? Coz he was in a hurry to get Adi home? for Toshi? That wman...she has such regressive thoughts...its coz of her old-fashioned, idiotic mentality that her children are facing so many probs today

am sure she didnt do a bg check on Param...before shipping Simmi off with him..and TILL DATE...In her mind, Param is pati parmeshwar for Simmi...divorce kyun nai le lete yaar?

Romi ko "mera beta" soch soch ke badhawa deti rahi...even when did tht Mihika kaand...and then Sarika pregnancy kaand...

and now Rinki...because she is so worked up in the head ki usko GKC/GKL milega ki nai...ki Rinki se kaun shaadi karega and all...she made Rinki go thru the burner

I abs agree with u when u say for a girl it matters a hell lot if her family stands up for her...yahan toh ganga ulti hi beh rahi thi..woh kehti toh bhi kya kehti...she was shocked and disturbed...and then Mihir came along with his "fresh start, clean slate" promises...

so she saw a glimmer of hope, and on the premise that Mihir put forward, that they're frnds...she gave this marriage a chance...

its not like she jumped with joy at the prospect of getting married to him, as many ppl think...coz she DID look hesitant

All this BS abt him being busy with work, falls flat wen we as an audience see him chatting and laughing with Mihika, and not bothering to even talk t his wife

WHICH husband will tell his wife - ki Im gonna be busy...wat will u do here? go back and stay with ur mayka?

I mean, at that rate, ALL THE HUSBANDS who are busy shud mandatorily ship their wives off to their mayka coz they're busy

that totally indicates he isnt VIEWING this as a marriage only

warna biwi se door rehna kaun chahega??

ulta Rinki ke Bhalla House mein rehne se...Mihir-Mihika HAMESHA aamne saamne aate hain...

why is it so difficult for Mihika to understand that she NEEDS to get out of Mihir's sight and not give this preachy advice to Rinki?

I totally understud when Rinki left the house...uska husband munh be bol raha hai he regrets marrying her...wat shud she have done?

sit at his feet, care for him, shed tears, beg for his love?

I totally get Rinki's point

And Mihika is NO victim

CVs shud just stop painting her as one...that ludicrous track where she married Ashok to "save" Shagun and MIHIR...ruined it all



Aka, Mihir has been busy with work, except for the time he spent with superman and the acting classes. He was not making time for Mihika, she just happened to bump into him, so she took the opportunity to talk to him. She gave him a lecture just like Ishita did. She is Bhalla's neighbour and Ishita's sister. So she is bound to be around.

Mihir wanted Rinki to be at Bhallas coz he did not want her to be alone with Shagun around. Mihir is already sorry for the drunk and whatever episode. Rinki did not wait to hear him out. If Rinki goes to Bhalla house, she is bound to bump into Mihika. At the end of the day she cant wish Mihika away, she needs to talk it out with Mihir only.

And agian Mihika did a lot of stupid things but she did it for Mihir and was unhappy all the while. She has got punished for it. She is not trying to break Mihir's marriage, neither is Mihir thinking about it.
music24n7 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#38

Luk who is Saying Shagun????

She is taunting Mihika,...what she has done her whole life...
She herself keep running behind her ex-husband
Mihika plz fight back all these ppl giving u gyaan
gravshrav23 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: music24n7

Luk who is Saying Shagun????

She is taunting Mihika,...what she has done her whole life...
She herself keep running behind her ex-husband
Mihika plz fight back all these ppl giving u gyaan


Have you heard of this saying?

"Band ghadi bhi din mein do baar sahi time batati hai"

Shagun is a wreck thru and thru..and yet...she DOES speak SENSE...though it is v v rare...

like when Sujata ran off with Ruhi in order to show her how much her Ishima loves her, Shagun was the ONLY one who asked Sujata the right qs - koi aise hi kisi ke bacche ko utha ke le jata hai?

Sujata, in barely 2-3 days had become over friendly with Ishita and the Bhalllas, going out of her way to do things for Ishu...and no one bothered questioning her...

how weird

as if its so normal to kidnap a child from school and get her parents worried to death
music24n7 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#40

Originally posted by: gravity23


Have you heard of this saying?

"Band ghadi bhi din mein do baar sahi time batati hai"

Shagun is a wreck thru and thru..and yet...she DOES speak SENSE...though it is v v rare...

like when Sujata ran off with Ruhi in order to show her how much her Ishima loves her, Shagun was the ONLY one who asked Sujata the right qs - koi aise hi kisi ke bacche ko utha ke le jata hai?

Sujata, in barely 2-3 days had become over friendly with Ishita and the Bhalllas, going out of her way to do things for Ishu...and no one bothered questioning her...

how weird

as if its so normal to kidnap a child from school and get her parents worried to death

Since sujata helped them...
No one will ever raise questions

Related Topics

Ye Hai Mohabbatein Thumbnail

Posted by: Im_sherlock

5 months ago

IshRa OS: Unspoken Desires.

On the show, we all know how Raman tried to give hints to Ishita about his feelings and desires, by keeping a box of condoms in her drawer. An...

Expand ▼
Ye Hai Mohabbatein Thumbnail

Posted by: ChanChanMan

4 years ago

YHM DT #8 (Strictly Reserved for IshRa/DivAn)

I dare you to post a thing about anyone other than DivAn.

Expand ▼
Ye Hai Mohabbatein Thumbnail

Posted by: Devanshi14

5 months ago

FF: IshRa ISHQ !!

Chapter # 01 Title: “Pehli Baar Ishq Hua” Raman and Ishita had been married for months now—contractually, yes—but slowly, silently, love had...

Expand ▼
Ye Hai Mohabbatein Thumbnail

Posted by: Im_sherlock

5 months ago

ISHRA OS:- Tumhare bina main adhoora hoon.

It was one of those rare calm nights in Delhi, the kind that carried a soft breeze, the scent of blooming mogra, and a strange kind of silence...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".