Is Ishita right or wrong ?????-POv n Analysis - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

57

Views

4k

Users

20

Likes

88

Frequent Posters

MysticMoon thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#41
Being a nice person , the steps Ishita has taken related to Shagun is justified in way of humanity but she should have called Raman once or informed her before taking such a big step , but then , she was in such a situation where a person can't calculate everything so properly , mistakes are natural here , moreover , she might have feared Raman's reaction on knowing that Ishita got Shagun in that condition...

anyways , cvs should have thought before introducing this twist
JUHI.HI thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#42
well i dont feel ishu did anything wrng...bt ya taking shagun to bedroom ws wrng bt she wasnt left wid any option cz d bhalla's werent evn listening to her... HATS off to ishu...its nt easy fr any wife to get her hubby's ex to her house...it takes a lot guts to do dat!!!!👏
RheaSh thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#43
There can be ample discussions on whether Ishita could avoid Shagun taking to Bhalla house. Realistically she had many options to avoid it and bringing Shagun to their bed was just way too much. No one questioning her for saving Shagun, Raman did it during the riot time in April and recently from Mr.Tyagi in Ashok's house. But the way Ishita did it was hard to swallow. Ishita was firm in her decision but didn't try to understand Bhallas POV.

Even when Toshiji and Raman told her about their views she kept on defending herself. When she sat on stool in front of the mirror, her reaction was felt like a helpless person and she was in pain that no one tried to understand her. But did she try to understand their POV? This not for the first time, she's doing so quite often of late. It could easily give mixed signals; either she was too complacent about her marriage or she did not value it much.Raman might very well feel like the marriage was still just a contract to get Ruhi from her side,the same way Ishita felt during the Adi accident case.
Lata_ishra thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#44
I completely agree with u and support her bcoz whatever she did was of humanity not her mahaanta...
FieryLioness thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#45
she was not wrong in helping Shagun but
the only thing where she went wrong is, not telling it Raman be4...
situation was not that hyped that she didn't make it to call Raman...
else I dnt think she did anything wrong by helping Shagun...
chweetu thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#46
hey nice post n true ishu should hv informed raman bt i dont get what trouble wl ishra face due to this?is their relation so weak ki shagun wl stolefy raman by one night stand in his bedroom? Does shagun has dat effect on raman till now ?
Nichuss thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: --mancityfan--

Well

Ishita is wrong

Because she did not even inform him and this has happened for third time

She should know entire family hates Shagun more after Ruhi fiasco

And as they say timing is important

And just because iraman jumped into the well ishita also has to jump into same well


ishita taking shagun directly to bhalla house was wrong... she tried her options...

wen all door closed she tuk her to in laws house...

timing and situation is the villain here not the characters...

its all normal reactions... ntg to overreact😊
Nichuss thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: Gkathria

She was absolutely correct! I understand why all the others are upset too, I also know that anyone else in the Bhalla family would have done the same and in that situation even Ishu would have felt a little hurt so this is a completely normal reaction 😊


yup... ths wht i too felt... jsut normal family reactions n dramas
Nichuss thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#49

Originally posted by: Vaibhi.

Being a nice person , the steps Ishita has taken related to Shagun is justified in way of humanity but she should have called Raman once or informed her before taking such a big step ,

i already told in some post back... :) sometime situation makes us act dumb... we wont
realise wht to do at that crtical time... its normal human procedure...

if raman was told... it would have been... better...n shagun could have been shifted to some hotels or hostels...

cvs thght if tey do so... thr wont any spice may be... 🤣 so made us frustrated of ishu nt telling raman...




but then , she was in such a situation where a person can't calculate everything so properly , mistakes are natural here , moreover , she might have feared Raman's reaction on knowing that Ishita got Shagun in that condition...

yaaa that can be also a reason... she wasnt ready for another round of fighting 😛


anyways , cvs should have thought before introducing this twist

Nichuss thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: JUHI.HI

well i dont feel ishu did anything wrng...bt ya taking shagun to bedroom ws wrng bt she wasnt left wid any option cz d bhalla's werent evn listening to her... HATS off to ishu...its nt easy fr any wife to get her hubby's ex to her house...it takes a lot guts to do dat!!!!👏



i dnt knw..whtr she was herself happy with her own karma... 🤣

because she was so upset while looking thru mirror..seeing shagun in bed...

wht ever... she did as shagun was woman... not as raman's ex...😛



Originally posted by: Lata_ishra

I completely agree with u and support her bcoz whatever she did was of humanity not her mahaanta...


yup... it wasnt Mahaanta at all... mahantaa.. was some epsds back... raman picking fainted shagun n running out... wen ishu ,,romi was standing shocked seeing raman with ex... 🤣


Originally posted by: FieryLioness

she was not wrong in helping Shagun but
the only thing where she went wrong is, not telling it Raman be4...
situation was not that hyped that she didn't make it to call Raman...
else I dnt think she did anything wrong by helping Shagun...


missed calling raman is the only mistake i too found in this whole fiasco...
but as some one above said... she would have feared raman's scolding..
or may be her reflex action of calling raman didnt worked at the shocked situation...

this is just a normal human mistake...



Originally posted by: chweetu

hey nice post n true ishu should hv informed raman bt i dont get what trouble wl ishra face due to this?is their relation so weak ki shagun wl stolefy raman by one night stand in his bedroom? Does shagun has dat effect on raman till now ?



wht is th outcome f this drama... we have to wait n watch... i too have no idea ... whr this track is goin... 🤔

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".