Is Ishita right or wrong ?????-POv n Analysis - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

57

Views

4k

Users

20

Likes

88

Frequent Posters

Nichuss thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: sobha

As a human she was right but as a WIFE she was wrong... 😕


in which way she is wrong us wife...

bringing ex to bed room...? think ex as drunk lady... was she worng..?

if so... then raman equally wrong in protecting shagun during rakhi epsd...

y u we were supporting him...

he hide it frm ishu too...

wasnt it wrong of hubby?
Nichuss thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: SAKIV-RAM

survival crisis.
she want to prove she is a living being.
Others prove their existance by doing some good or interacting with others.Shagun can't do first and second no one want to interact with her.
Shagun and her batch my messing others lives and feeling they are important in their life.\

But my only doubt is how the heck could she stop a court marriage.
Most of the runaways do marriage in court itself.While whole family of bride and groom won't be acepting but how single shagun is stopping.
One way I know is proving one of them married before while other proving one is not of marriage age but I am not finding any way here.

same pinch yaar... this is wat bugging me tooo... wht made courtmaariage stopped

shagun suddenly so intelligent *my foot*😡😈

hope something... logical will b thr...

without seeing the epsd... im nt commenting more on it...

i dont want to do the same mistak by bashing ishu on this shagun drama 🤣

SAKIVIAM thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#23
I borrowed little charecter from RAM and decided not to speak till it is finished.I usually wont react for any thing .EQ is less.
Let's what is in flow.
BTW UNNNAMED is updated
attubaby thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#24
Ishu helpin shagun was neva a problem or issue...in circumstances she wz facin, d best place where everybody feels comfortable nd safe z home...coz home is ours nd we have rt on it...i found nothin wrong in helpin her nd bringin her home...
However, Ishi z nt a single anymore...she has commitments nd responsibilities for her in-laws...despite knowin al d wrong-doings of Shagun, she dint gv a second thought to how Raman gonna feel wen he z gonna c d same person he loved to eternity in his past...on d same bed...if humanity is to be taken care of, then one has to consider the sensitivity of the whole situation too...dis z also humanity no..then y put her in ur room nd makin ur hubby get out n sleep in hall..whole issue, problem nd irritation lie there..

Furthermore, rather than justifyin d act, showin sm understadin towards Raman's emotions cd have repaired d damage to sm extent...nd did u luk at d tym wen raman opened the door...wat audacity she showed...it was so not ishu..nd it was relaly disturbin...basically d whole sequence was nt handled well by CVs..


Just hope dey show how she z understadin Raman's POV too...dis situatn needs a perfect closure..otherwise no sense😕
Edited by attubaby - 10 years ago
kayan thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: Nichuss


when the drunk women is senseless f nt knwing wht she doing..

how can ishu make her sleep on couch...

the drunk lady can fall... from there... .. which can end in other problems...like hand breaking etc...

bed atleast will be safe... for 70%

dat they she left raman sleeping on the floor she cud have left her on d floor also😆
Nichuss thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: mnr123

Hmm hv a different POV on this issue n m not saying she is bad wrong or mahaan or anything. There r times in our lives we act impulsively n do not look at the bigger picture. N ishita is known to act like that in situations shown before.
I m not saying she is not wrong, she is. And she should show remorse n should apologize to Bhallas about getting Shagun.

one moment there... aftr effects of morning is still not aired... so hw can we say she wont apologise or not😛 * wait for todays epsd * n will comment on that...

When her parents were sent to jail she said that we r middleclass people n only thing we earn our whole lives is Honour in society n once that is lost its a huge loss. Same applies to Bhallas , she not only rubbed their wounds by getting Shagun in that house without informing anyone but also made her family susceptible to social ridicule. By putting her souten in her Bed she has let out her own Bedroom secrets in open, it will not take people like Simi or Param blurt out to outside world that Ramans ex was sleeping in his bed.
She also here gambled with her husbands n her own marriage's honour n reputation.


if u didnt forget... the bedroom secret is already out during pervy track... i mean first pervy out of house... where raman ask publicly in front of all family...

we dont share any husband wife relation... how pervy came to know... 😛 so that is invalide point to say ishu is wrong


Ya I agree when we do something humanitarian we should not think about what society thinks of us. But in real world its still a big deal.

isnt it a lesson to do in real life... leaving a drunk helpless woman in road is wrong... atleast taking to some women hostel or something should b done in future in real life.. incase if u met with...😳 i found it a gud social message...

Being humanitarian is great no doubt about it but u have to look into bigger picture too. She hurt Bhallas without informing them about Shaguns arrival, she hurt Raman by putting Shagun in his bed. Goodness should not mean that u end up hurting a huge chunk of other people? Would that help anyways if majority of people r unhappy with ur decisions which u think is Good.

same point...explained above.. still wasnt ishu hurt... seeing shagun on bed... or ishita dont have heart or feelings... only bhallas n raman have... :P😛

What r d odds that Raman wud not have listened to her if she wud hv called him? He might hv asked her to put Shagun in a decent Hotel. N please guys dont give me BS that women these days cant stay in hotel coz its unsafe. I have travelled some places in the world alone n backpacked into Youth hostels alone and have also stayed in decent hotels in India too all alone for my job. So Ishita cud have got Shagun out of her inebriated state n made her stay in hotel for 1 night n she cudve figured out what to do next day accordingly.

this is the only mistake ishu did... to be said... and which is point to think.. as i said in vikas comment...

sometimes including me... all act dumb n stupid... situation arises...

for example... something happen in our family... which is bad n big... r u will b thinking rightly...????

normally people wont think straightly... if thinks straight... she/ he must b superficial 😆

I agree this turn was taken by cvs for drama purposes but it seriously looks forced n out f character for Ishitas part. I understand d whole concept f Trp vs Logic but I cant take this stupidity under the guise of arrogance on makers part. U hv promoted a show to b real then be real n act real for a change.

im still not able to find wht ths logical... behind this... so no comments...
may get an answer by further upcoming episodes...

Y cant cvs show n make a Real show for a change ? Is it too much to ask, if it is our TV industry will then never come out of its stagnancy. Was YHM not accepted as a real show in the beginning? What changed suddenly?

it is real now tooo... we all are jsut overreacting not finding the reason or may b the epsds r nt of viewere expectation...

in which angle u found it illogical i dnt knw... watch freshly as yhm...not as ishra... u will find the epsd... reaonoable... i watched as a normal viewer... n found these pointss...
even though ishralicious is less... epsd are real...n true to the sense...😳


I just hope cvs get Ishitas character back on track n end this illogical track of insensitive portrayal f Ishita

😊

No comments... because... i dnt find any character deviation



iooopsss itss so long... 😲
Nichuss thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: kayan

dat they she left raman sleeping on the floor she cud have left her on d floor also😆



ha ha ha ha ha

athidevo bhava... is indian custom... so hw can we make guest sleep in floor...lolss...

family sleeping floor is different ...ha ha ha...*just joking*

u r right...shagun could have been left in floor...

still its ishra bedroom
--Megha-- thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#28
@ Nichuss no comments then coz I cant drill my thoughts in ur head u think differently n I think differently 😆
Nichuss thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: SAKIV-RAM

I borrowed little charecter from RAM and decided not to speak till it is finished.I usually wont react for any thing .EQ is less.
Let's what is in flow.
BTW UNNNAMED is updated




👍🏼same here... lets see whts happening n react...

i will read n comment... goin for outting in some minutes... 😉
pomegranate thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#30
Ishita brought shagun home on humanitarian grounds. if I were her, my priority would be keep her safe for the night, not to make her comfortable. I would have left her on the couch not my husband's bed.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".