Karthikka thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1

Originally posted in Vani Rani Fans Facebook page on 12.08.2014


Good morning everyone. 😃


I wanted to write this short note after reading posts here. The Poongodi-Karthik-Saravanan topic has attracted lots of controversy and heated arguments but I dont want to bring it up again. However I do feel that too much focus has been given to this plot to the extent that other plots have been forgotten or downgraded. I feel that this is not just unfair to the VR team but to the actors who play other roles (leaving Radhikaa out of this). Views were expressed that the serial is deteriorating or becoming another of Sun TV serials which I dont agree with.

There are other plots that are interesting. Unfortunately these plots have been overwhelmed by the PKS saga. Right now for example one of the stories is how Surya and Gowtham, with the guidance of Swamy, are helping to bring their father's business back to the top. A few months ago, viewers were raising the concern why young people in VR were vetti pasanga (other than Rajesh and Selvi), especially Surya and Gaitham. The plot also focuses on an increasingly dominant role for Swamy, which I welcome. I think Prithivee along with Venu Arvind are strong pillars of VR and I look forward to more screen time for them.

Gowtham - Pooja-Kathir : again this is also another plot which has potential. Pooja's character is not universally approved but then again very rarely this happens. Some friends suggested that Vani Bhojan be a partner for Gowtham but I for one dont like Vani Bhojan. So you cant please all the people all the time. I believe Pooja's character needs warming up to and like all characters in Vani Rani, she too has a purpose. I for one want to see where this goes.

Rajesh-Selvi-Shiva. A serial wont be a serial without sensational topics/plots. Shiva is a psycho. We are not supposed to like him. Do people like exist in real life? Yes, they do. and before I forget...Nilambari in Padayappa, anyone?

Finally, Vani Rani is not the same as other serials. The dialogues for one. Pa Raghavan has gems for every single episode - whether to make us laugh or make us think or make us cry. Do you know what a relief it is for me to watch a serial that does not have "Nee nasama pove?" "Nee mannoda pove" "Vaiyire erinju solluren nee urupada matte/nalla irukku matte!!"? I am thinking of doing a collection of quotes, that is how much I appreciate the dialogues. Which is why I dont forward any segment, because there is always something special/unique being said. Yesterday, in 424 for example, in the segment between Rajesh, Selvi and Shiva, at 13.20 Rajesh says something interesting - ahem - - about a certain member of this fanpage.

The commitment shown by director ON Rathnam and his team. Not only characters are introduced, but a lot of thought and care has gone into the shaping of those characters. Their likes, dislikes, positives, negatives...everything that gives life to fictitious characters. No kandravi or kevalam stories - eg everyone thought there will be a miscarriage for Selvi like every other serial but no it was indeed different - that makes our stomachs curdle. No sexual harassment, attempted rape, molestation, degrading of women, making men crass, crude, sexist morons - except Arumugam who bashed Malathi in one episode and has been bashed by the whole world and their wives since. LOL.

Acting. I dare anyone of you to find fault in the acting of the cast. Radhikaa, Venu, Prithiviraj. Junior artistes such as Maha Lakshmi, Rajkumar Manoharan - absolute revelation with the way they expressed themselves.. Rajkumar in the past few episodes has excelled. Guhan Shanmugam - the easy come easy go but don't overstep the limit type of guy, Vicky Krish - the angry bird in pink. 😆.Arun Kumar Rajan, Murali Krish to provide the laughs, which can be difficult since they are not comedians in the strictest sense.

And then there is Radhikaa...lately she has not been in the episodes for longer than a couple of minutes but the minute she comes on she just stands out. She lights up the screen. Seriously this lady is going from strength to strength. All the disappointment, frustration and indifference I felt post-Chitty era has been eradicated by her performances in VR. How many times we must have searched for one twin when the other twin is on the screen, completely forgetting that it is the same person? How many times tears welled up in our eyes when we watched either one of them (or both) suffering? Or we laugh at their reactions? Or we share their anxieties, their fears, their sadness? See, I am talking about them as if they are two different people...and indeed Radhikaa has portrayed them such a way. The way they smile, talk, cry...even when she is Rani pretending to be Vani, we all know that it is Rani...

When the Rs were rocking it in cine world - Radha, Radhikaa, Revathy, Rohini - Revathy was my absolute favourite.

No longer.

So let us enjoy the serial and go with the flow.

Created

Last reply

Replies

8

Views

1.8k

Users

5

Likes

17

Frequent Posters

Karthikka thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
Some people argue that the VR team dragged the PKS story. I refute that. In my view, they did not drag the saga. I would have called it dragging if the serial was about these three people alone. There were other stories to focus on. Frankly, in my view, the majority of people complaining that they were dragging are PS fans. I for one was more interested in other stories - the fall and redemption of Swamy, the battle between Kathir and Vani etc. Secondly, how soon should this saga have been resolved? One month? Two months? Three months? Now, correct me if I am wrong - PK got married in Episode 282. Yesterday's episode was number 425. 143 episodes. Divide by 6 episodes a week - 24 weeks. Divide by 4 weeks - 6 months. They have been married for SIX MONTHS. Is the institution of marriage so trivial that you can get in and get out as if you are entering and leaving departmental store? Nothing to do with traditions or culture but simple human values.

Okay, leaving that aside, the relationship was complex, the circumstances as well. The way I see it, the length of time allowed for the development/highlighting the nuances and the sticky issues of the whole plot - look at it at its wider perspective - it wasnt just the three of them, it was their families too. (I am leaving the parents and Anaconda out of the equation). If I have a reason for the saga to be resolved, it is because personally I cant take the aggression, the persistence bordering on obsession, the hostility, the ganging up... not because it is dragging. Again this is my personal belief.

My reference to Neelambari is not on the creativity issue but to show psychos exist. Serials from all over the world have had stories like these - US, UK, Australia had their fair share of psychos. And we should see where this story is going. Leaving that aside, there are people who are not sitting down to watch a small screen version of Padayappa...but there are many who do.

Do you know what frustrates me? Not PKS/Shiva/Pooja stories...but stories that demean women with cheap and sickening plots. Kumaran's serials. Deivamagal, Thendral, Thirumathi Selvam. (Please have the maturity to accept my constructive criticism and my right to voice an opinion about serials I DO NOT LIKE and not delete my post because of this). Vamsam. Women in these serials are shown as stupid or evil with no morals or values or conscience. Sex is used in a sickening manner and I dare anyone to say otherwise.

PS fans are arguing obsessively that the VR Team promised they will follow the votes polled by the audience. Did they? Didnt they say they will think about it? How is that interpreted to mean that they definitely will do it?

Poga poga theriyum.
Edited by Karthikka - 11 years ago
Satrupa thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
OMG!! This is wat i can say now,
res ll comment by reading another post which posted now following
nithya_IF thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
PKS.. I leave it to how CV's want to handle it..

I agree on Radhika's master piece acting. Must say the best of hers till now. She amazes me every scene, every episode in both of her characters. Rani character is something which I never thought she would fit in and she proved me wrong beyond my imagination.
Karthikka thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
I always wanted to ask : What is CV? For me CV has always been Curriculum Vitae. 😆

Nithya, that is what I am saying...go with the flow. But Oh God, rabid reactions...shudder.
kalki2007 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
Karthikka - Revathy is my favourite actress too
you are right all the R's are good actresses
your views are brielliant and loved the review
my mother in law watch Sun tv - she is fed up now stopped watching - she used to watch ritually now if she has time she watch - i record VR - only one show i watch - too much commercials in the middle - stories are no sense - most of the time villies win - i agree Kumaran serials too - i used to watch Thendral and Deivamagal stopped watching long time ago
VR is the best one all the Radika's serials - all the other ones start good but then started to drag then i stopped watching it in the middle - i am still watching it and likeing it
Poo and Karthick i think it's ok track - how many marry without telling the partner that they had the lover before or even think about that person on and off - they hide here Poo was frank with her feelings and she wanted to give her heart purely to her partner so even if she has tiny feelings for other person that means she is cheating her and her partner - we want fast action not enough patience
Pooja has good qualities and i think deep down she is a good person the only thing is she is not matured enough - so she needs to face lot of problems then it will mold her into adult - her actions shows young girl actions not an adult - even though she talk to her parents and periappa the values - she needs to grow
Samy and Bhoomi in a different direction - Bhoomi needs to prove himself worthy of himself and he loved hard work and will boost the business - good idea if Rani accept Bhoomi - she has someone with her if Kathir shows up with his goons - Rani has way of making others happy
loved your review keep on doing it please👏⭐️🤗
Karthikka thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
I am very disturbed at people saying that a poll was conducted and the majority wanted Poongodi and Saravanan.

After I had given some inside information, silent stalkers took my information, spread it all over the Internet and called VR team cheats and liars because they did not follow the result of the poll.

I now find out that there is a possibility that the poll was not conducted by the VR team or endorsed or authorised by them.\

I am seeking confirmation on this issue.

I am quite perturbed by this. Let me get back.
priyapradeep thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
Nithya even at my home elders are not liking PKS track. They comment saying what's all this nonsense which husband will do all this and they can't agree which is against our society. I told my father in law why can't u agree when bhagyaraj already took andha 7 days movie in those days where he says my lover can be ur wife but wife can't become my wife again... so opinion differs elders may or may not like this track. And your concept of supporting XYZ reasons she may give if saravanan says u have to get married to karthik to prove ur love means she got married itseems. Marriage is just not a word for her to play with. How many of them get married to person whom they love hardly few so u try to say thay eveyone has to quit there marriage life and get back to their love life...
priyapradeep thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
And Nithya if she wanted to purely give her heart to someone whom she loves means she shudnt have given her neck for thaali...

Karthika no need to reconfirm in my locality where is stay in bangalore almost all my neighbours watches vani rani and everyones opinion is karthik pongoodi... very few support saravanan poongoodi who think only love is everything but don't know the marriage family values...
Edited by priyapradeep - 11 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".