who's independent???? - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

125

Views

5.9k

Users

23

Likes

268

Frequent Posters

ShadowImbue thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#41
I though same but while thinking about same point for longer time I came to a conclusion that Randhir was never financially Independent... nor was Sanyukta but difference between RD and Sanyu's character is...Sanyu doesn't want to be financially dependent on her parents as for her they're indifferent of her existence,choices and happiness...Randhir considered same about Renuka but still he was financially dependent on Renuka...If they showed him creating huge issue of Sanyukta paying his fees that would be contradictory to his character...as RD is a person who has emotional approach towards life and never prioritize financial independence...also being financially dependent doesn't make a person weak...as we are dependent on our parents till we earn for ourselves not merely girls but boys are also dependent...love one's are their to support each other every way...Financial Independence is not a criteria for Woman Empowerment...though Women Empowerment makes women financially independent..
Edited by ShadowImbue - 11 years ago
TUKI.MICKY thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: Helooohybye

and when she was taking help you people were shouting where is her indepedence now when she trying to take her life in her hands why she is being indepedent and yay about that rely thing then everyone has that self ego never be dependent on anyone but own ...not even your lover at the first when rd said he will pay the fees sanyukta happily left ysa out of her hand and thats it nothing is required more at that time anyone pays the fees it will benefit both but this tyme its her won battle let for once her fight

The major problem is jab Sanyukta ko strong n independent dikhani chaaiye like fighting against her family n Chomu CVs showed her dependant n weak... N now they're trying to show her handling her own life by arranging 1 lak 60 thousands on her own in a single day which is next to impossible... It's not being independent, it's unrealistic...
Wrackspurt thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: mimie3003


Honestly...I would have done the same too..But don't you think that Sanyukta's self-dependence has been quite inconsistent?
And not talking about this issue alone..
P.S- I am certainly not a Sanyukta hater.

I am definitely not branding you as a Sanyukta hater 😳...if you are saying that Sanyu was behaving like that weak gal who cannot fight her battles during that engagement breaking epi...i would say that was a very huge decision...leaving your family, rather walking away from your family forever is a major step...how many of us have that guts to do that actually? i guess very few...and for that if there is no support behind you sometimes we think twice and decide to back away...i am not saying that Sanyu should forever cry aloud self-dependence but whats the harm for always trying to be that? ...it does not mean she will always remain strong...she after all is a human...flawed...like Randhir, she too has her weaknesses... 😛
Wrackspurt thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: -Isabella-

Agree Paro but here they are talking about arranging 1 lakh 60 thousands in a single day which was next to impossible for any student wheather girl or boy... N there is nothing to feel ashmed to ask help from near ones...

All i am saying is there is no harm in trying alone first ...let her try out and then off course if nothing works out, she will have to ask for help 😳
Moony87 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: -Isabella-

The major problem is jab Sanyukta ko strong n independent dikhani chaaiye like fighting against her family n Chomu CVs showed her dependant n weak... N now they're trying to show her handling her own life by arranging 1 lak 60 thousands on her own in a single day which is next to impossible... It's not being independent, it's unrealistic...


Bells.. Kya khaa ke aayee re.. again spoke my mind.. 👏
Edited by Moony87 - 11 years ago
Wrackspurt thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#46

Originally posted by: ShadowImbue

I though same but while thinking about same point for longer time I came to a conclusion that Randhir was never financially Independent... nor was Sanyukta but difference between RD and Sanyu's character is...Sanyu doesn't want to be financially dependent on her parents as for her they're indifferent of her existence,choices and happiness...Randhir considered same about Renuka but still he was financially dependent on Renuka...If they showed him creating huge issue of Sanyukta paying his fees that would be contradictory to his character...as RD is a person who has emotional approach towards life and never prioritize financial independence...also being financially dependent doesn't make a person weak...as we are dependent on our parents till we earn for ourselves not merely girls but boys are also dependent...love one's are their to support each other every way...Financial Independence is not a criteria for Woman Empowerment...though Women Empowerment makes women financially independent..

@red--- absolutely...i agree with you on this 👍🏼
ChaiBiskoot thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#47
dat girl is crazy ... she went to him during her father's factory issue.. wen she broke down.. etc etc..
it was 'ME' wen they had to pay the fees for colej and again it is 'ME' wen she has to pay for her hostel..

go live on the streets sanyukta for a day.. let me see how u come back to Randhir crying your eyes out..

Independent,my foot..
Moony87 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#48
Paro... Bells call you that.. So hope you don't mind me calling you that
See independent hona doesn't mean you chuck out realities.. I agree main hoti to main bhi try karti before taking help.. The point again is reality.. Being a student you cannot miraculously arrange 1lack 60 thousand on your own in any freaking case..

Trust me this doesn't show empowerment.. This shows foolishness.. Plus they are supposed to be sandhir.. Together fixing stuff.. They are a team.. YSA mein she shined alone coz there was a real chance ( of getting quick money)

Here you can't justify this I'll do it stuff.. It's a huge amount and I personally would appreciate that they show sandhir work together.. That's how couples are.. You don't let each other work alone thinking that it's my battle it's my battle.. Its our battle then..

Anyway.. Guess this will not make sense.. 😊
Edited by Moony87 - 11 years ago
HotFuzz thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#49
The issue is more in the execution of todays episode. I kind of got confused as to what was happening. Constant U turn of the character is killing the essence
I liked the fact that Sanyukta rejected her moms help👍🏼 because her mom was helping because she thinks is not doing the right thing.
But sanyukta should not have listened to her mom as she was doing the right thing 😕...OK for parents respect lets ignore😆
Sandhirs conversation on bench was good .They spoke like a normal couple and the way sanyukta said that she chose to run away from house and she has no right to complain. sanyukta said she needs to sustain and Randhir said he will support her ..Perfect 😳
Randhir here said that he will do something and bring money for her and she was ok with it
The notice period or warning they were giving to vacate was annoying..They should have kept it once but it was shown like 3 or 4 times and was irritating😡.peon botha hai phir admin call karta hai aur peon bolta hai
They should stop contradictory dialogues like sanyu saying i don't want FITE rules to be broken because of me. We all know Rules were broken many times.😆
When they gave one hour notice period Sanyu was so desperate that for a sceond she even thought of asking Randhir to hack but again she came back to her senses😆
The peon checks the room and he gets a call that sanyukta need not vacate and she thinks it could be RD and goes and asks him how he got so much money to pay her fees and hope he did not hack the website.
Randhir tells Vardhan for which sanyu says i don't need Vardhan sirs help and if she really want to take help she could have taken Randhirs help.
So if I look at above points Sanyu really did not mind Randhirs help.
But the execution is so crap that it kinda made it look otherwise.
Few things they need to completely ban 😆
Contradictory dialogues
Parth stressing about sanyukta's self independent degree (it kind of looks forced to me)
Sanyukta U turn dialogues
This is my POV 😳
mimie3003 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: -Isabella-


The major problem is jab Sanyukta ko strong n independent dikhani chaaiye like fighting against her family n Chomu CVs showed her dependant n weak... N now they're trying to show her handling her own life by arranging 1 lak 60 thousands on her own in a single day which is next to impossible... It's not being independent, it's unrealistic...



Yes yes! That's exactly what I meant.
Sanyukta is a work of fiction and the ones who have made her are to be blamed totally for this issue. I like the fact that she wishes to be independent but this current track is seriously not getting into my head.

As Paromita pointed out,she wants to do it by herself at first..I appreciate that totally. But sometimes working together can help.Asking Randhir to back out totally and arranging more than a lakh in a few days is. unrealistic. A little bit of help wouldn't do any harm.
or probably the CVs are creating the ground for a future ego clash..:/

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".