Created

Last reply

Replies

43

Views

3.9k

Users

17

Likes

92

Frequent Posters

springkissed thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: AttractiveAdya

Hey Shai. 🤗

To be honest, there are some points on which I agree with you completely and some on which I disagree.

Points I agree on:
Ruks needs to interact with other buddies. Her interaction being limited to RV is completely unrealistic. I would also like to see her interact with Kiya, Piddi, KD, Avantika, Avi and at times with Omi too.
By the way, just to point out she interacts with JJ too.
With Panchi. I really cant say because I am Just NOT comfortable with Panchi's character right now, to say the least.
Her character developement needs to be shown too.

Points I disagree on :
I think Ruks having a problem in english is fine and shown well , since she comes from a village. From what I understand this is shown to show she is strong in her views and firm with her decisions , rather than to gain sympathy. Basically I dont think its required to feel sympathetic towards her.

My POV plain and simple.

-Adya.


Adya..🤗
First, thank you for agreeing with some of my points as I feel they are legit points that cvs should ponder over..
and second, I think I will just quote -3raser- here because she already gave an excellent answer before,

"From the precaps, I thought that English being a problem for her would send out a good message and also bring an interesting track.

But I don't enjoy watching the track because I don't KNOW who RUKMINI IS! We got to know barely anything about her and that is WHY I possibly don't seem to understand or empathize with her. Also for the character to develop it's necessary that you see their interactions with other people and that's why I think she needs to get out of the "Just Ranveer" Zone and go with the gang. "


Initially, I was really impressed seeing the realistic elements in rukmini's character, but as time went on, I was utterly turned off. I absolutely don't mind her being strong in her views and firm with her decisions, but, somehow that firmness doesn't incite enough interest from my side. As vishu said, we need to KNOW who rukmini is! who is she? a girl that has a hard time speaking english because she is from a village? Is that all that is to her? I need to know more about her character to even like her. TBP has always created characters that are able to stand on their own when needed, and still maintain people's interests, be it Rv, samar, KD, kiya, avi, panchi, piddhi or any other characters. but, I feel like if I take Rv out of the equation, I am going to have absolutely no interest in seeing her. The emotion that her character incites from me doesn't have to be of sympathy, It can be any other emotion. I feel like a character always needs to incite some kind of unique emotion from the viewers that makes the viewers feel connected to them. It is a matter of connection, that just can't be ignored. As she is a part of the buddy project, I want to see more of her uniqueness. I want to know more things, like does she have a hard time when she tries to make friends? something that makes me go ahhh, I can relate to this girl. It's more of a click. Furthermore, I don't want ranveer coming every turn of the way as her knight in shining armor, we need to see her and like her for herself first. But, for now, as mais said, I'm not feeling the x-factor that other characters of TBP always had and I don't want to entirely blame the actress, but there is definitely something that is missing. and, I think I blame that little something on the lack of rukmini's character development. I want to know and love her as rukmini in the future and since I can't do it now therefore I'm pointing out the faults I see.

woosh..I seriously envy your ability to wrap up in few sentences now..lol;)
Hope I'm making sense!:)
Edited by coolpixie - 12 years ago
RapChick101 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: coolpixie



<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">Adya..🤗</font>
<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">First, thank you for agreeing with some of my points as I feel they are legit points that cvs should ponder over..</font>
<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">and second, I think I will just quote -3raser- here because she already gave an excellent answer before,</font>

<font size="2" face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">"From the precaps, I thought that English being a problem for her would send out a good message and also bring an interesting track.</font>
<font size="2"><font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">
But I don't enjoy watching the track because I don't KNOW who RUKMINI IS! We got to know barely anything about her and that is WHY I possibly don't seem to understand or empathize with her. Also for the character to develop it's necessary that you see their interactions with other people and that's why I think she needs to get out of the "Just Ranveer" Zone and go with the gang."
</font>
</font>

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">Initially, I was really impressed seeing the realistic elements in rukmini's character, but as time went on, I was utterly turned off. I absolutely don't mind her being strong in her views and firm with her decisions, but, somehow that firmness doesn't incite enough interest from my side. As vishu said, we need to KNOW who rukmini is! who is she? a girl that has a hard time speaking english because she is from a village? Is that all that is to her? I need to know more about her character to even like her. TBP has always created characters that are able to stand on their own when needed, and still maintain people's interests, be it Rv, samar, KD, kiya, avi, panchi, piddhi or any other characters. but, I feel like if I take Rv out of the equation, I am going to have absolutely no interest in seeing her. The emotion that her character incites from me doesn't have to be of sympathy, It can be any other emotion. I feel like a character always needs to incite some kind of unique emotion from the viewers that makes the viewers feel connected to them. It is a matter of connection, that just can't be ignored. As she is a part of the buddy project, I want to see more of her uniqueness. I want to know more things, like does she have a hard time when she tries to make friends? something that makes me go ahhh, I can relate to this girl. It's more of a click. Furthermore, I don't want ranveer coming every turn of the way as her knight in shining armor, we need to see her and like her for herself first. But, for now, as mais said, I'm not feeling the x-factor that other characters of TBP always had and I don't want to entirely blame the actress, but there is definitely something that is missing. and, I think I blame that little something on the lack of rukmini's character development. I want to know and love her as rukmini in the future and since I can't do it now therefore I'm pointing out the faults I see.</font>

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif" size="2">woosh..I seriously envy your ability to wrap up in few sentences now..lol;)</font>
<font size="2" face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">Hope I'm making sense!:)</font>



I agree Shai.
As I said earlier, I agree that she really has to come out of her Only friends with RV.
And yes, we do need to know who Rukmini is. We need to understand Ruks and for that we clearly need to disclose her her complete identity.

My disagreement was with the sympathy point only.

Thanks Shai. 🤗
I dont really know how I manage to do something so efficient. 🤣
RapChick101 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#23
All in all I feel its kinda early for people to dislike her. Without knowing how can anyone judge her?
Just what I think. Others don't need to go by it.
springkissed thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: AttractiveAdya

All in all I feel its kinda early for people to dislike her. Without knowing how can anyone judge her?
Just what I think. Others don't need to go by it.


Exactly, we don't know anything for which to judge her by. That is the core of the problem! I want to feel at least something towards her character, not just annoyance at not feeling connected to her because of knowing absolutely nothing about her. I think she has failed to make that lasting impression on alot of the viewers, so if those faults are not fixed now, then people will truly start to dislike and disregard her character. and, once you start to dislike a character, it's hard to like them back again. As we are in the TBP forum, we should be more aware about that than anyone else, as people still hold grudges towards relationships and faults from long before.

I don't mean to be harsh, but this is what I feel.
Edited by coolpixie - 12 years ago
--Akshu-- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#25
Ok agree with u n Adya that e should let give her a chance n not judge so fast!but the CV's better do that fast before every1 starts disliking her
..DamonCrazy.. thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#26
This is so out of topic, but Akshu...your last sig<3<3
springkissed thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: --Akshu--

Ok agree with u n Adya that e should let give her a chance n not judge so fast!but the CV's better do that fast before every1 starts disliking her


True, I don't want my confused feelings to go into a complete dislike mode for her. I honestly want to like her, as she is now a part of the TBP season 2. I wish cvs do provide better character development, and more opportunities for her character to interact and flourish.
..DamonCrazy.. thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: coolpixie


True, I don't want my confused feelings to go into a complete dislike mode for her. I honestly want to like her, as she is now a part of the TBP season 2. I wish cvs do provide better character development, and more opportunities for her character to interact and flourish.

I agree 100% with the interaction part. Except for the occasional Rukmini-JJ scenes, which I love, all her scenes are only VeeNi scenes. I know ki CVs probably want to concentrate on the Buddies more, but like Avi, Omi & Tika, atleast a little of her individuality can be shown.

springkissed thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: ..DamonCrazy..

I agree 100% with the interaction part. Except for the occasional Rukmini-JJ scenes, which I love, all her scenes are only VeeNi scenes. I know ki CVs probably want to concentrate on the Buddies more, but like Avi, Omi & Tika, atleast a little of her individuality can be shown.


Her individuality is the key, the key that doesn't involve ranveer. I want see her and her only to truly like and accept her. If cvs want, veeni can develop side along, but that individuality has to be there. our buddies are sure fire together, but it's their individuality that makes us absolutely love and adore them.
Edited by coolpixie - 12 years ago
RapChick101 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: coolpixie



<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">Exactly, we don't know anything for which to judge her by. That is the core of the problem! I want to feel at least something towards her character, not just annoyance at not feeling connected to her because of knowing absolutely nothing about her. I think she has failed to make that lasting impression on alot of the viewers, so if those faults are not fixed now, then people will truly start to dislike and disregard her character. and, once you start to dislike a character, it's hard to like them back again. As we are in the TBP forum, we should be more aware about that than anyone else, as people still hold grudges towards relationships and faults from long before.</font>

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">I don't mean to be harsh, but this is what I feel.</font>



Agree
Your not harsh at all. And I do agree. ;)

P.S what I wrote wasnt for you. ;) ;P

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".