what is the need of this show???

Page

Next Last

Arijit

@Arijit007

Sparkler

Posted: 10 years ago

hi guys, this topic is a rant after seeing couple of episodes of this show. sorry, show? it's a recycling center!!! when karna and the other younger generation mb charecters were young in this show then things were mostly ok, exept few blunders. when they are older, seems like the makers are recycling the scenes of their previous creation, starbharat. this show was made to show new perspective on the charecter of karn, on this subject, they are not good. and now, this.

Quote

Frequent Posters

merrydock

@merrydock

Voyager

+ 6

Posted: 10 years ago

you are right, this is a recycled version of starbharat. and i really don't see the concept of showing the mahabharata from karn's prospective. and if they are they should stay true to it, karn was no reformer. he was driven by ambition and his rivalry with Arjun. he chose to side with duryodhana even though the knew he was evil. if karn did ever interact with lord krishna, he would have never been able to choose duryodhan, he would understand immediately the it was lord krishna who was the one who would bring about change and reform.

what they are showing currently, that karn is conned into siding with duryodhan and pledging undying devotion to him, because he things duryodhan will help him bring about change, is only making karn look even more stupid.

i not saying karn was a bad or evil person, but he did make the wrong choices, he chose the wrong people to make friends with. he harps about standing against injustice, but it was because of his support that duryodhana was able to perpetrate injustice after injustice on the pandavas.

evil becomes powerful when good men do nothing. and that was karn's sin.

they should have stayed true to the mahabharata, by showing that karn chose to align himself with duryodhana because duryodhan honored him with the crown of Ange. that he stood by duryodhana in all his misdeeds, because karn was benefiting from it by getting recognition as a warrior, which fueled his rivalry with arjun, and his ambition to be known as the foremost warrior. he was not driven by any reformation ideas or social change. karn as a sooth only wanted the right to carry a weapon and challenge other kshatriyas.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

shivvy_24

@shivvy_24

Beginner

Posted: 10 years ago

What really disappoints me is that they arent showing the kaurav side and karnas side of the story well. Not showing any build up of friendship between karn and duryodhan. Instead they are just involving karn more with the pandavs and krishna. For example the war between krishna and jarasandh, they just included karn in it. But they are not showing the important things like how karn and duryodhans friendship built up and more importantly, karnas story itself.

Quote

Brahmaputra

@Brahmaputra

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

Even sets and ornaments are recycled ones, better not to say about characters.😆 A handful of good actors are wasting their career doing this stupid show. I really feel bad for Pankhuri. She might have signed the contract seeing Draupadi but SidT's Draupadi is just a combo of Manthara and Satyabhama in right amounts, nowhere Draupadi.

Quote

FlauntPesimism

@FlauntPessimism

Viewbie

+ 10

Posted: 10 years ago

I had though that it would be Mahabharat from Karna's perspective, but instead this seems more like a Fan Fiction/Historical Fiction that if Karna was present in all important episodes of Mahabharat. They have made Dury indebted to Karna even for his birth😭😭.Once this is done, nothing I mean nothing that Dury does for Karna could have caused the latter to feel indebted to Dury😕.

Worst thing of this Mahabharat is that in making Karna the hero they have made mockery of the actual hero of Mahabharat (Bheeshm).

I really hope that this does not cause an enmity between Karna and Bheeshm in heaven 😛😛😛

Quote

Arijit

@Arijit007

Sparkler

Posted: 10 years ago

well, the real hero of mahabharat is not bhishma, but you can write your own version of mb from his perspective. that's the beury of mahabharata, every charecters of this epic has a story. karna also has a backstory, but the cv's and the makers are not showing it, and anyway this show is not a mytho show, it's a mythological ficton

Quote

crazygul

@crazygul

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

sanjay khan maharathi karna far far better !

Quote

aanvi

@aanvi98

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: Arijit007
hi guys, this topic is a rant after seeing couple of episodes of this show. sorry, show? it's a recycling center!!! when karna and the other younger generation mb charecters were young in this show then things were mostly ok, exept few blunders. when they are older, seems like the makers are recycling the scenes of their previous creation, starbharat. this show was made to show new perspective on the charecter of karn, on this subject, they are not good. and now, this.

wow Jyeshth!!!👏 anth mein gada prahar kar hi lia!!!😆 u r ABSOLUTELY right. this is not SPK. this is recycle bharat. be it BGMs, set, jewelleries, actors(keechak nd ghatokchak of SB) or scripts. this have become just a circus. but thank god it's circus, cuz if it had been serious then instead of LOLing over, we would've been throwing bhramastra...😆

Quote

Tesla.07

@Tesla.07

Inactive

Posted: 9 years ago

What is the need of this show !!?? Like seriously ??!!

Why are you even here in the first place?? Kindly back off!!

I understand that you would have perhaps watched the entire Mahabharata series and are in no mood to watch this show. But, aren't there people who didn't watch the Mahabarata 2 years ago maybe for some reason and are now eager to watch the story via this show. Please stop acting like BUT HURT fans.

Edited by Tesla.07 - 9 years ago

Quote

Arijit

@Arijit007

Sparkler

Posted: 9 years ago

#10

i am here to hurt fans? 😆 my dear tesla, this show is doing that, not me. it hurts the feelings of pandava fans, krishna fans, draupadi fans and suprisingly the feelings of the karna-kaurava fan base is also hurt by this god-forsaken show. every charecters of this show are NOT WHAT'S THEY ARE SUPPOSE TO BE.

Edited by Arijit007 - 9 years ago

Quote

1 2 3 4

what is the need of this show???

Related Topics

Explore Topics