what is the need of this show??? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

38

Views

5.2k

Users

13

Likes

60

Frequent Posters

ltelidevara thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 9 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: Tesla.07

What is the need of this show !!?? Like seriously ??!!

Why are you even here in the first place?? Kindly back off!!

I understand that you would have perhaps watched the entire Mahabharata series and are in no mood to watch this show. But, aren't there people who didn't watch the Mahabarata 2 years ago maybe for some reason and are now eager to watch the story via this show. Please stop acting like BUT HURT fans.


Kindly forgive me as I don't know who you are and you don't know me. But please don't call this show Mahabharat. It is anything but MBH. That is why even the TRPs are low. Star Bharat despite its distortions used to be in top 10.I think the ranking of this horrible show is51.
Tesla.07 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: Arijit007

i am here to hurt fans? 😆 my dear tesla, this show is doing that, not me. it hurts the feelings of pandava fans, krishna fans, draupadi fans and suprisingly the feelings of the karna-kaurava fan base is also hurt by this god-forsaken show. every charecters of this show are NOT WHAT'S THEY ARE SUPPOSE TO BE.

Arey baba!! 😆
I meant butthurt, not but hurt. LOL!!😆
Tesla.07 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: ltelidevara

Kindly forgive me as I don't know who you are and you don't know me. But please don't call this show Mahabharat. It is anything but MBH. That is why even the TRPs are low. Star Bharat despite its distortions used to be in top 10.I think the ranking of this horrible show is51.


I found this show to be pretty decent till now.
Nevertheless everyone's entitled to have an opinion.

Besides if you don't mind, which tracks did you find to be false ?

FlauntPessimism thumbnail
Screen Detective Participant Thumbnail ICC T20 CWC 2024 Match Winner Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 9 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: Tesla.07


I found this show to be pretty decent till now.
Nevertheless everyone's entitled to have an opinion.

Besides if you don't mind, which tracks did you find to be false ?

1. Radha hating Karna in the childhood
2. Karna inviting Vyasa during Duryodhan's birth
3. Karna going all the way to Varnavrat to try and save the Pandavas
4. Karna asking Pandavas not to go for the Dwit Kreeda

There are many more if we start adding, anyhow it is not Mahabharat but a fan fiction on Karna
ltelidevara thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 9 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: Tesla.07


I found this show to be pretty decent till now.
Nevertheless everyone's entitled to have an opinion.

Besides if you don't mind, which tracks did you find to be false ?

To add to Shiprita's list the whole Krishna Karna angle is false. Then Karna saving Drau from Sisupal,And then Karna leaving the battle after the swayamvar as Arjun is in Brahmin attire(In reality he is overpowered by Arjun)Karna saving Kings from Jarasanth ,Karna protesting when Pandavas are given Khandav Prasth and The way Indraprasth happens.Mayasabha without Khandav Dahan Then Drau apology to Karna never happened as in the Eoic in CE She never stopped Karna from hitting Target but he failed, The list is endless. I would have provided you more but I stopped watching seeing the way Karna reacted when Sisupal blamed Krishna. So that's it.
KURT15 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#16
Seeing, the way it has been made, this show was really unnecessary, I agree. This is a fan fiction on Star Bharat with Karna as hero. 😆
FlauntPessimism thumbnail
Screen Detective Participant Thumbnail ICC T20 CWC 2024 Match Winner Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 9 years ago
#17
To add more I must say the mismanagement in the Dhritarashtra's rule. However bad Dury and his immediate family was, Ved Vyas ji never doubted their capabilities as an administrator, in fact he has mentioned that the common public want Dury as their Yuvaraj only because they have not seen the capabilities of Yudi. (Bheeshma's convo with Vidur) This clearly shows that might be Yudi was a better capable administrator, Dury and Dhrit were definitely not bad in the eyes of Hastinapur people.

The barbaric treatment of Sutas is another thing which is not just historically wrong but actually give a wrong image of our past.

And yes the best one was Bheeshma taking the exam of Karna after the completion of his Suta training. I mean come on did Bheeshma had enough time for taking the exam of Sutas on how they drive the rath???😲 And that too he was not recruiting a Sarathi for his army, he was just taking the exam on completion of the studies. And to add to it he was not alone, He was accompanied by Dushshasan who had come only to insult the Sutas.

The childhood friendship of Karna and Arjun, the former insulting Kunti due to no valid reason, Kunti chasing Suryadev for the wrongs he did to her, Priyamvada, Madri a cook

Oh Krishna I have not seen even 20 episodes of this show and have come up with so many, I can imagine the condition of those who follow it regularly. Hats off to them 👏👏
Prtzy thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#18
I don't understand that if people are having problems with fiction, why are they watching this show?? It still says "all the characters here are fictional" before any episode airs... Yes Mahabharat is an Indian Epic but if any maker decides to make a serial as per depicted in original book, it will be quite boring.

Even in StarBharat some fictional things were added because it spices up the drama. In SK, they want to show Karna as a warrior who always thought right things except his unfortunate friendship with Duryodhan. And people do like Karna and this version of Mahabharat( which is even not correct).

So what's the big deal??? Why people are crying about makers showing wrong things. We all know Mahabharat, read it in our books and quite frankly if the same thing is shown in TV, no one will watch that. Hence, no point in criticizing the makers for adding things from their side...They feel Karna as a character has a superb potential to gain sympathy from audience and hence, made a show for them
FlauntPessimism thumbnail
Screen Detective Participant Thumbnail ICC T20 CWC 2024 Match Winner Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 9 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Prtzy

I don't understand that if people are having problems with fiction, why are they watching this show?? It still says "all the characters here are fictional" before any episode airs... Yes Mahabharat is an Indian Epic but if any maker decides to make a serial as per depicted in original book, it will be quite boring.

Even in StarBharat some fictional things were added because it spices up the drama. In SK, they want to show Karna as a warrior who always thought right things except his unfortunate friendship with Duryodhan. And people do like Karna and this version of Mahabharat( which is even not correct).

So what's the big deal??? Why people are crying about makers showing wrong things. We all know Mahabharat, read it in our books and quite frankly if the same thing is shown in TV, no one will watch that. Hence, no point in criticizing the makers for adding things from their side...They feel Karna as a character has a superb potential to gain sympathy from audience and hence, made a show for them



Now this is a different topic. Speaking for myself I would definitely feel bad if my country's past is shown in a wrong light (a civilization which abolished slavery at least a millennium before others could even think of this is being shown as inhumane)

But actually we came up with the fiction part in this story as it was asked as to what wrong have they shown
aanvi98 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: Prtzy

I don't understand that if people are having problems with fiction, why are they watching this show?? It still says "all the characters here are fictional" before any episode airs... Yes Mahabharat is an Indian Epic but if any maker decides to make a serial as per depicted in original book, it will be quite boring.

Even in StarBharat some fictional things were added because it spices up the drama. In SK, they want to show Karna as a warrior who always thought right things except his unfortunate friendship with Duryodhan. And people do like Karna and this version of Mahabharat( which is even not correct).

So what's the big deal??? Why people are crying about makers showing wrong things. We all know Mahabharat, read it in our books and quite frankly if the same thing is shown in TV, no one will watch that. Hence, no point in criticizing the makers for adding things from their side...They feel Karna as a character has a superb potential to gain sympathy from audience and hence, made a show for them

u know, fiction can be bear when there's a small amount of distortions. Past can't be distorted. And none minds fiction, but TILL then when characters r not butchered. And the main thing is many will think this show true blindly, like the new viewers. And again series of distortions taken as REALITY... Tht's pathetic. even fiction have sum extend. when the character is written already, u can't spice it up with ur own story. I wonder why there's no copyright of ved vyas!!! i know it's silly, but yeah, it seriously needs to differentiate fiction, folklore and additions. They should remember it not THEIR written character tht they can break it in many ways... Yes, karna could gain many sypathy, IF he was shown rightly. They r literally degrading the characters my butchering thm up nd adding sum very insulting nd silly sequences. They didn't get the right to change a personality.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".