FruitToasty thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#1
It's not the first time Kunal has been thrown under the bus to glorify other characters, writer has always lowered his character to show other characters in good light...
Extremely disappointed with the revelation/confrontation scene today, this can be understood that the motive of this was to show how Ishaan will stand up for Mauli, so for Ishaan writer ruined not only Kunal but Mauli too #NewFavoriteIsInTheTown

The point here is that not only Kunal but ANY man would not behave like they showed him behave in today's episode especially a man who was afraid of losing his wife 2 days ago, today I felt Kunal is trying to score points, that's not his character, he wouldn't do that, he doesn't know that he is having a memory loss...

Wouldn't he be more concerned that his marriage is ending? This Kunal is not looking for any other woman, this doesn't make any sense..

Then comes Mauli who was standing there crying and looking guilty, for what? So Ishaan can speak for her because apparently the strong woman is nothing but a damsel in distress who needs Ishaan to save her?

From episode 1 episode 190, every development in Kunal and Mauli's characters has been compromised for one poorly written scene to give one character everything...

We have seen so many confrontation scenes between these two, It's just unbelievable that the most important confrontation would be ruined like this..


PS : Shakti Arora take a bow, I always praise his acting because he is truly one of the finest actors I have seen but this time I have to praise your fortitude for sticking up to this story line and still giving your best. He added the pain and hurt in Kunal's character through his acting, if I listen to the dialogues without watching the scene, it's nothing like Kunal calling out his wife for an affair, even Rajdeep got better dialogues according to his character when he found out that Nandini had an affair with Kunal...


Created

Last reply

Replies

91

Views

6.3k

Users

18

Likes

530

Frequent Posters

Nandy141 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#2
I am sorry .. I am not able to get your point .. I have read in a previous post of yours where you have quoted that you are not able to connect with Mahaan Ishaan and now he is behaving like a normal human being who wants to defend his lover. You seem to have a problem with that ?
Why shouldn't Mauli be silent .. She might be confused on what she should do now . Ishaan is reacting on behalf of her . What's wrong in that ?

So your problem is Ishaan here and it's so evident .
Kunal is a grey character . He is butchered . Even Rajdeep was butchered so many times to defend Nandini .. that's how a show works ultimately.
One character will be destroyed. One character will shine . One character will remain neutral the way Radhika Ji is
looseseal thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#3
No offence, but this is actually quite consistent with Kunal's character. its not the first tile he was teying to score points:
- this is the same man who went behind his pregnate wife in the hope to find an evidence of pregnancy being fake.
-this is the same man who was dragging his wife in front of his mistress, to show her a CD of when she was drunk. Just so he cab show her her place. He did this when she was already broken by his cheating
- this is thea man who said he came for his kid and Mouli kept him away. When he was the one who fabricated the "evidences" just so he could get out of his marriage and being a father

All this, he was trying to prove a point. Making him and his lover the victim. Others are awful and he makes sure that he lets them know how awful.they are. And if there are no real evidence for it then then.he wil lscore points by getting fake ones. The CD, the doctors half heard phone call
...


I have said many times, Kunal's character took a, big dive on Mouli's birthday episode. The butchering was so sudden and was very obvious. But the thing is he never apologised or ade up for it. If a character is consistantly awful, it becomes their trait. and thats what is happening with Kunal. Now when he acts awful, it doesnt feel like butchering at all. He has GROWN to become a awful person.
Edited by looseseal - 6 years ago
Indira1211 thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail 7th Anniversary Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#4
When writers write a character..they give him or her personality traits according to that characters role in the story ...e.g. the villain will always have an abundance of negative traits and his or her role will be responsible for all the bad things happening in the show...Well in silsila they've decided to make Shakti a grey character..he's not the good guy and he never was. Good men don't do to their wives what he did to Mauli. The show is ending now I think it's about time that it was accepted that Kunal is a grey character, he may have one or Two nice qualities but overall he's been a pampered spoilt brat ...like we saw today ..who got almost everything he wanted in life...he's disrespectful and rude ...look at the way he behaved with pramila today and his rudeness to Ishaan ...he's distrustful and he puts his happiness above everyone's others. This is the Kunal of Silsila ..he's not been butchered,.hes been written to be like this ,.there are lots of people like this in the world ..So he is a realistic character.. So trying to say he's been butchered etc to make the other characters look good really makes no sense ...because the good characters are good ...they've been written to be good ...Mauli, Ishaan and radhika are the good decent characters in the show and their actions wil always be selfless where they put the needs of others above their own and they always try to not hurt others by their actions..They can't be made to look good ...they are written to be good .
FruitToasty thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Nandy141

I am sorry .. I am not able to get your point .. I have read in a previous post of yours where you have quoted that you are not able to connect with Mahaan Ishaan and now he is behaving like a normal human being who wants to defend his lover. You seem to have a problem with that ?

Why shouldn't Mauli be silent .. She might be confused on what she should do now . Ishaan is reacting on behalf of her . What's wrong in that ?

So your problem is Ishaan here and it's so evident .
Kunal is a grey character . He is butchered . Even Rajdeep was butchered so many times to defend Nandini .. that's how a show works ultimately.
One character will be destroyed. One character will shine . One character will remain neutral the way Radhika Ji is


Ishaan can defend his lover, where did I say that I have a problem with it?

The problem is Mauli's reaction when exactly has been Mauli the one to take crap from people around her, especially around Kunal, she always gave back as good as she got, the Mauli, I know doesn't need anyone to defend her, doesn't mean Ishaan won't do it, it's completely normal for Ishaan to defend Mauli but it's not normal for Mauli to listen to Kunal and not say anything, did you see she was crying and was guilty like Kunal was crying and was guilty during Kunan EMA revelation? I just don't get the reason Mauli would react that way, so this does not concern Ishaan, I am talking about Mauli's character

Grey characters are butchered for other characters to shine? I wasn't aware of this, I always thought a character acts according to his character graph not according to graph of other characters, everyone is an individual after all, so I guess it's completely normal that Kunal was butchered for Ishaan
FruitToasty thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: looseseal

No offence, but this is actually quite consistent with Kunal's character. its not the first tile he was teying to score points:

- this is the same man who went behind his pregnate wife in the hope to find an evidence of pregnancy being fake.
-this is the same man who was dragging his wife in front of his mistress, to show her a CD of when she was drunk. Just so he cab show her her place. He did this when she was already broken by his cheating
- this is thea man who said he came for his kid and Mouli kept him away. When he was the one who fabricated the "evidences" just so he could get out of his marriage and being a father

All this, he was trying to prove a point. Making him and his lover the victim. Others are awful and he makes sure that he lets them know how awful.they are. And if there are no real evidence for it then then.he wil lscore points by getting fake ones. The CD, the doctors half heard phone call
...


I have said many times, Kunal's character took a, big dive on Mouli's birthday episode. The butchering was so sudden and was very obvious. But the thing is he never apologised or ade up for it. If a character is consistantly awful, it becomes their trait. and thats what is happening with Kunal. Now when he acts awful, it doesnt feel like butchering at all. He has GROWN to become a awful person.


It's anything but consistent...
Two days ago they showed a conversation between him and Mauli about pregnancy, now watch that scene and Kunal's dialogues in this scene..
Very lazy and inconsistent writing
FruitToasty thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Indira1211

When writers write a character..they give him or her personality traits according to that characters role in the story ...e.g. the villain will always have an abundance of negative traits and his or her role will be responsible for all the bad things happening in the show...Well in silsila they've decided to make Shakti a grey character..he's not the good guy and he never was. Good men don't do to their wives what he did to Mauli. The show is ending now I think it's about time that it was accepted that Kunal is a grey character, he may have one or Two nice qualities but overall he's been a pampered spoilt brat ...like we saw today ..who got almost everything he wanted in life...he's disrespectful and rude ...look at the way he behaved with pramila today and his rudeness to Ishaan ...he's distrustful and he puts his happiness above everyone's others. This is the Kunal of Silsila ..he's not been butchered,.hes been written to be like this ,.there are lots of people like this in the world ..So he is a realistic character.. So trying to say he's been butchered etc to make the other characters look good really makes no sense ...because the good characters are good ...they've been written to be good ...Mauli, Ishaan and radhika are the good decent characters in the show and their actions wil always be selfless where they put the needs of others above their own and they always try to not hurt others by their actions..They can't be made to look good ...they are written to be good .


Grey doesn't mean Bad


Indira1211 thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail 7th Anniversary Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: FruitToasty


Ishaan can defend his lover, where did I say that I have a problem with it?

The problem is Mauli's reaction when exactly has been Mauli the one to take crap from people around her, especially around Kunal, she always gave back as good as she got, the Mauli, I know doesn't need anyone to defend her, doesn't mean Ishaan won't do it, it's completely normal for Ishaan to defend Mauli but it's not normal for Mauli to listen to Kunal and not say anything, did you see she was crying and was guilty like Kunal was crying and was guilty during Kunan EMA revelation? I just don't get the reason Mauli would react that way, so this does not concern Ishaan, I am talking about Mauli's character

Grey characters are butchered for other characters to shine? I wasn't aware of this, I always thought a character acts according to his character graph not according to graph of other characters, everyone is an individual after all, so I guess it's completely normal that Kunal was butchered for Ishaan

you need to understand that Mauli and all of us here know that the Kunal in front of her is sick..he's got s mental disorder...called amnesia...she's not going to shout at him. She's scared it can trigger off a stroke ..which can kill him. So she and Ishaan are not going to tell him anything..because they are worried about his health.
FruitToasty thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Indira1211

you need to understand that Mauli and all of us here know that the Kunal in front of her is sick..he's got s mental disorder...called amnesia...she's not going to shout at him. She's scared it can trigger off a stroke ..which can kill him. So she and Ishaan are not going to tell him anything..because they are worried about his health.


Oh come on
Kunal was in a way more delicate situation when he asked Mauli about Nandini's name, remember what she did? She was irritated and took Nandini's name, when Kunal asked her to wear a saree and it reminded her of Ema, she again snapped at him, that's how Mauli is, she won't take shit sitting down and crying for no reason.
looseseal thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: FruitToasty


It's anything but consistent...
Two days ago they showed a conversation between him and Mauli about pregnancy, now watch that scene and Kunal's dialogues in this scene..
Very lazy and inconsistent writing



Consistantly awful.doesnt mean being angry and awful every second of the day.

And what was so great about that scene? How was he supposed to react when he thought his wife couldnt get pregnate? Curse her for being infertile? And thats the.standard?

But look at every of his decisions and his responses when he think he is not getting what he wants. Look how he doesnt think twive before tossing away his wife, his mothers, his child, his.basic decency just to get what he wants.
When.has he ever made a compromise? He couldnt even.do.it for his.kid, his mistress.had do beg him to go to the child. Seriously...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".