my note as a MBBS doctor - change the system EDIT - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

48

Views

30.6k

Users

14

Likes

180

Frequent Posters

-Purva- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 4 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#41
I for one am not so sure of the role of MCI and IMA in bringing about a level-playing field.

MCI as we've seen has become a hotbed of corruption and has allowed fake medical colleges to emerge in every by-lane. Today even a pan-wallah can open a medical college all thanks to MCI. This aspect of corruption was even highlighted on the show. The two independent heads of the institution admitting that they failed to curb the rampant corruption and therefore preferred to resign.

The IMA is even worse. It operates like a private club with all members seeking to cover each other rather than fight the rot in their system. It is these members who've happened private hospitals and nursing homes with inadequate facilities. It is these doctors who use their unsuspecting patients as guinea pigs, giving them untested medicines and use them as research lab rats.

When we have good honest doctors, they have thrived without the support or need of these two institutions. A good doctor doesn't need these paraphernalia. He'll go out and do what is best for the patient, not what would help him buy his next set of golf-clubs.
charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#42
@Totally agree the current medical bodies have become a joke more so after their reaction to SJ's episode and asking AK for an apology.

But then it doesnt take away the fact that we need a stricter body which can be an efficient watchdog and bring the culprits of malpractices to justice. We need reforms and an independent body free of any influences with a fairly trasparent selection procedure. Though many high profile honest doctors are part of both IMA and IMC like Dr Shetty but still corruption and other negligence is rampant. I feel we need reforms on the consititution of such bodies to send a strong message.

Edited by charminggenie - 13 years ago
-Purva- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 4 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#43
How many bodies to check corruption can we set. If each body is overseeing the other and there are yet more watchdog bodies, we might finally achieve the impossible - Have two clerks per head monitoring the actions of every medical student who passes out.

If you go the website of IMA - the first page is by that body calling for a strike by all doctors against the attempt by parliament to set up just such a watchdog organization :)

http://www.ima-india.org/
charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#44
Shessh great whats with our country and strikes , I thought our constitution states that doctors be barred from conducting strikes as it affects the healthcare services.

Agree we dont need more paper work or another bureaucratic body but we need an overhaul of the governing body of medical practices in India be it IMA or IMC. Especially if they have the power to suspend a doctor from practicing if he is found guilty.All I want to see is these bodies being run by honest and dedicated doctors who can monitor and actually do the job properly.Right now no doctor is scared of them and carry out their malpractices without any fear coz of corruption at these bodies, this is y i want to see constitutional changes initiated by govt in these bodies.
-Purva- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 4 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#45
Can I blame my favorite whipping post for the strikes - please? I believe Gandhi is responsible for all these strikes. In no other part of the world would you hear of bandhs and strikes as in India.

It was Gandhi who first taught India the power of strikes and hartals and look what's happening today - every second person is on a stop work hartal.

You stop a man from from peeing on the road, next thing - hartal.

You stop someone from driving on the wrong side, that's it - strike.

You stopped a student from cheating in the exams, good watch now - bandh.
akash08 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#46

Originally posted by: natasha-remix

i am an indian doctor.

my journey so far:-

i spent over 10 lac rupees for my education just to get thru with my mbbs degree. WHY?

because of reservation i had to take up seat in a private medical college. my parents took loans and payed my fee.

so why dont i study more and do postgraduation to increase qualification?


if i go for MD-- i will spend atleast 1 more year preparing for my enterance.. and there too due to a lack of seats.. it willl be difficult...

while I am fully sympathetic to this idiocy of reservation for the vote bank and I wish one day I will see this abolished in our country (I know if hundreds of deaths could not abolish it.. I am only day dreaming.. nothing is more important to our corrput leaders than vote bank)!!
However.. not getting through a government medical college - you can not blame it to reservation only!! You have to just admit that you were not good enough or simply did not try hard enough!! There are lakhs of general candidate students get admission every year and it is not that difficult to mug up Biology!!
Edited by akash08 - 13 years ago
bhavis thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: Chitrashi

Can I blame my favorite whipping post for the strikes - please? I believe Gandhi is responsible for all these strikes. In no other part of the world would you hear of bandhs and strikes as in India.

It was Gandhi who first taught India the power of strikes and hartals and look what's happening today - every second person is on a stop work hartal.

You stop a man from from peeing on the road, next thing - hartal.

You stop someone from driving on the wrong side, that's it - strike.

You stopped a student from cheating in the exams, good watch now - bandh.


We have back to work legislation that controls strike. Else even in western countries strikes are there.
natasha-remix thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: akash08

while I am fully sympathetic to this idiocy of reservation for the vote bank and I wish one day I will see this abolished in our country (I know if hundreds of deaths could not abolish it.. I am only day dreaming.. nothing is more important to our corrput leaders than vote bank)!!

However.. not getting through a government medical college - you can not blame it to reservation only!! You have to just admit that you were not good enough or simply did not try hard enough!! There are lakhs of general candidate students get admission every year and it is not that difficult to mug up Biology!!

my score was high enough to get me in if less seats were reserved. that is what i am implying.

i also did consistently well in med school

please go onto www.muhsnashik.com and check the UG final year rank list for the year 2011.

my name is in the top 10 in the state.

my point is that inspite of doing so well in my 10th 12th and medical college.. i am still finding it hard to cope up with the pressure and the limited number of seats.



Edited by natasha-remix - 13 years ago
IisBliss thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#49
🤢

Originally posted by: akash08

while I am fully sympathetic to this idiocy of reservation for the vote bank and I wish one day I will see this abolished in our country (I know if hundreds of deaths could not abolish it.. I am only day dreaming.. nothing is more important to our corrput leaders than vote bank)!!

However.. not getting through a government medical college - you can not blame it to reservation only!! You have to just admit that you were not good enough or simply did not try hard enough!! There are lakhs of general candidate students get admission every year and it is not that difficult to mug up Biology!!


😲🤢🤢


Edited by IisBliss - 13 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".