Ishaan has no backbone. - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

23

Views

4k

Users

17

Likes

126

Frequent Posters

sanchita1410 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#11
Even I also think that. Till yesterday I always took pity on Ishaan but I think now this is enough for me. I know he loves his family a lot and dont want any fight among family members. But I think being a husband he should speak when it's the matter of her self dignity even if he is a good boy of family means agayakari boy.
charity10 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#12

I feel, it is not fair to say Ishaan has no backbone. He certainly does. The very fact that he accepts Suhana with all her frills and fancies is testimony to the fact, that Ishaan is very sure of himself and what he wants from his lot in life. I like that about him. He may not be intune with the latest clothes and fashion fads, but he is bang on when understanding Suhana and his family members. He has his heart in the right place.

Suhana was absolutely right in bringing a cake for Deepak.

But if you look at it, RB was already upset because Suhana is digging deeper than she is supposed to. So she couldn't control herself and slapped Suhana. Everyone else, understood the boundaries that were set, but our Suhana, has no boundaries. She is adorably unique. What can Ishaan really do in this context. RB is like a mother figure to him. At the same time he understood that Suhana will be very hurt. So his hesitation is absolutely understandable.

One of the reasons why SGP is successful is that it doesn't gloat nor undetermine the importance of/in relationships. They are normal and therefore, can't have dramatic solutions. They need to be handled with care and tackled with a lot of understanding.

myvoice thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#13
I don't really find fault with anyone's actions here....
I think Ishaan understands Radha bua's sentiments better...that her slappin suhaana was an instantaneous reaction caused due to loss of control over her emotions, and I think everyone were too shocked to react, I feel Ishaan was in a helpless situation, for one he didn't knw why Radha was hurt so much, but he understood tat there was a deeper reason why she reacted the way she did. But, sayin Ishaan has no backbone is going a little overboard don't you think?

Radha bua does care for her son, but ya she refusing to look at his face or preventing him from interacting with others seem little harsh....her slapping suhaana was due to loss of control from her part, she is goin through a lot right now and I don't think it is right to be judgmental of her actions. I would want to give her some time and space but, I hope she would soon come to terms with accepting her son in due time.

Suhaana was not at fault I agree, all she wanted was to see Deepak happy and she had a right to question Ishaan abt not defending her, I think any woman would after being slapped by someone in front of the entire family.....it would be interestin to see how she brings the mother and son together.

EDIT: I feel really sad for Deepak and I don't want to blame Radha bua alone for this, I feel the rest of the family members like the brothers and bhabhis also must be blamed from blindly staying away from him. Suhaana was the only one who didn't want to blindly pay heed to everyone askin her to stay away from him. I was little irked to knw how everyone including Ishaan didn't bother to even attempt to talk to Deepak or getting to knw about him better.
Edited by myvoice - 15 years ago
FreeBird03 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#14
i don't think ishaan has no backbone.. he has stood up to suhana many a times..so he can definitely speak when he needs to..maybe everything happened so suddenly that he wasn't able to react to it.. but i totally agree with what anu said...i mean fine he didn't react but he shud have gone after suhana immediately..that was a bit weird..he knows how suhana is..how hurt she must have been...n how angry she was..still he only went after rano asked her to! weird..n i was disappointed by ishaan there to say the least...

i just don't feel sorry or anything for radha bua anymore..fine i can understand that whatever she experienced was horrible ...and probably that pain can never go...but life is all about moving on... n she has such a nice obedient and intelligent son...she cud have lived happily with her son..but...

truly u can only be happy if u want to...else u can never be happy...it all depends on u...

I feel so bad for deepak..poor guy...fine radha bua doesn't want to see his face..but why she gets angry when deepak is happy....what kind of a mother she is? she can't see her son enjoying or just being happy...that's weird... 😕 if he is talking to suhana or enjoying with meethi..why she doesn't like it? poor poor guy....

n i don't like the way family members react to this whole thing either...fine they all love radha bua... but why can't they talk to deepak? ishaan said hum sab deepak se bahut pyaar karte hai! Really Ishaan!! mujhe to dikhai nahi deta 🥱 No one even wished him happy birthday even after knowing its his birthday...arey birthday to hi tha...aisa kya pahad toot pada tha....Weird!

N suhana wasn't wrong at all..i am totally with her on this! Go Suhana!

PS: fantastic epi overall... looking forward to next week!
the way they showed meethi's reaction was soo cute! kids start crying immediately when such things happen..lol..they don't understand anything..n she was later crying that she didn't even get to eat the cake..hehe..awww meethi is so cute :)
Edited by ManaliS - 15 years ago
myvoice thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: ManaliS

i don't think ishaan has no backbone.. he has stood up to suhana many a times..so he can definitely speak when he needs to..maybe everything happened so suddenly that he wasn't able to react to it.. but i totally agree with what anu said...i mean fine he didn't react but he shud have gone after suhana immediately..that was a bit weird..he knows how suhana is..how hurt she must have been...n how angry she was..still he only went after rano asked her to! weird..n i was disappointed by ishaan there to say the least...

i just don't feel sorry or anything for radha bua anymore..fine i can understand that whatever she experienced was horrible ...and probably that pain can never go...but life is all about moving on... n she has such a nice obedient and intelligent son...she cud have lived happily with her son..but...

truly u can only be happy if u want to...else u can never be happy...it all depends on u...

I feel so bad for deepak..poor guy...fine radha bua doesn't want to see his face..but why she gets angry when deepak is happy....what kind of a mother she is? she can't see her son enjoying or just being happy...that's weird... 😕 if he is talking to suhana or enjoying with meethi..why she doesn't like it? poor poor guy....

n i don't like the way family members react to this whole thing either...fine they all love radha bua... but why can't they talk to deepak? ishaan said hum sab deepak se bahut pyaar karte hai! Really Ishaan!! mujhe to dikhai nahi deta 🥱 No one even wished him happy birthday even after knowing its his birthday...arey birthday to hi tha...aisa kya pahad toot pada tha....Weird!

N suhana wasn't wrong at all..i am totally with her on this! Go Suhana!

PS: fantastic epi overall... looking forward to next week!
the way they showed meethi's reaction was soo cute! kids start crying immediately when such things happen..lol..they don't understand anything..n she was later crying that she didn't even get to eat the cake..hehe..awww meethi is so cute :)



@bold ya very true and meethi is really cute....tat scene was nicely done...I think Ishaan didn't approve of suhaana celebratin deepak's birthday in front of everyone despite him tellin her not to interfere between deepak and Radha bua....I think he looked more guilty of suhaana's actions which invoked such a reaction from Radha bua...hence, he didn't think of going after her until Rano reminds him tat suhaana would needd his support.I am not really defending him, but I feel that is how Ishaan's character is.
Yashh... thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#16
well i totally agree with u
Ishaan being her so-called official husband shud huv said something.he cant sit quietly wen his wife has been slapped fr no reason.true Radha bua is a bit over-reacting hiow can she leave her son away like dat.Ok fienb she has some probs but why is she making other family also not talk to him???........................this is wrong
wellll......really hope he says something atleast on monday
nidzo thumbnail
Groupbie Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#17

I thought about what you said for a while before I rsponded to it, because you are right in a way.....we could say that because she's an Elder she ended up slapping Suhana.....HOWEVER I feel that Radha Bua has had a bias towards Suhana since she overheard Suhana speaking with her father and that has affected the way Radha Bua views Suhana in the family. If it wasn't for Badi Ma, Radha Bua would have said and done alot more to Suhana than what she has done.......
AND also, Radha Bua as the Elder should be able to see that Suhana is doing this because she wants to see Deepak as part fo the family. If RAdha Bua had addressed the issue BEFORE with Suhana (like Badi Ma said earlier - why don't you talk to Suhana about it) then it would have been different if Suhana had continued pushing and then she had gotten slapped.....
But Radha bua never talked with Suhana to let her know that she doesn't want anyone talking about Deepak and she would rather her stay away from Deepak. She didn't necessarily have to provide an explanation however she did need to TALK to suhana before she lashed out the way she did and Slap her instead. I think that was very rude, especially as Badi Ma had already told Radha Bua that if Suhana asking questions was bothering her then she neeeds to make Suhana understand.

Absolutley. Radha Bua has a bias against Suhana due to couple obvious reasons but I was just responding in context with the question whether Ishaan was at fault or not.
Radha Bua has alot of explaining to do to everyone regarding Deepak in that family (excluding older members ofcourse).
Edited by nidzo - 15 years ago
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: charity10

I feel, it is not fair to say Ishaan has no backbone. He certainly does. The very fact that he accepts Suhana with all her frills and fancies is testimony to the fact, that Ishaan is very sure of himself and what he wants from his lot in life. I like that about him. He may not be intune with the latest clothes and fashion fads, but he is bang on when understanding Suhana and his family members. He has his heart in the right place.

Suhana was absolutely right in bringing a cake for Deepak.

But if you look at it, RB was already upset because Suhana is digging deeper than she is supposed to. So she couldn't control herself and slapped Suhana. Everyone else, understood the boundaries that were set, but our Suhana, has no boundaries. She is adorably unique. What can Ishaan really do in this context. RB is like a mother figure to him. At the same time he understood that Suhana will be very hurt. So his hesitation is absolutely understandable.

One of the reasons why SGP is successful is that it doesn't gloat nor undetermine the importance of/in relationships. They are normal and therefore, can't have dramatic solutions. They need to be handled with care and tackled with a lot of understanding.



Beautifully said👏👏👏.....I agree with the bolded bits especially.....and the bit in blue is so true....that is what indeed makes SGP special.
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: myvoice



EDIT: I feel really sad for Deepak and I don't want to blame Radha bua alone for this, I feel the rest of the family members like the brothers and bhabhis also must be blamed from blindly staying away from him. Suhaana was the only one who didn't want to blindly pay heed to everyone askin her to stay away from him. I was little irked to knw how everyone including Ishaan didn't bother to even attempt to talk to Deepak or getting to knw about him better.



I'm also disappointed in the way the rest of the family especially the younger generation behaves with Deepak....they claim that they love him too but the way they too treat him like an outcast in a way....the way all their faces fall the moment they see him....it's too much.....Deepak is treated like a leper in some ways....it's terrible to watch.....when Suhana brought the cake, the attitude was more like, 'ab cake aa hi gaya hai toh let's be happy about the occasion, we don't have much choice'...but otherwise toh they were doing everything in a mega awkward and forced manner that made me feel very bad for Deepak....
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: ManaliS

i don't think ishaan has no backbone.. he has stood up to suhana many a times..so he can definitely speak when he needs to..maybe everything happened so suddenly that he wasn't able to react to it.. but i totally agree with what anu said...i mean fine he didn't react but he shud have gone after suhana immediately..that was a bit weird..he knows how suhana is..how hurt she must have been...n how angry she was..still he only went after rano asked her to! weird..n i was disappointed by ishaan there to say the least...

i just don't feel sorry or anything for radha bua anymore..fine i can understand that whatever she experienced was horrible ...and probably that pain can never go...but life is all about moving on... n she has such a nice obedient and intelligent son...she cud have lived happily with her son..but...

truly u can only be happy if u want to...else u can never be happy...it all depends on u...

I feel so bad for deepak..poor guy...fine radha bua doesn't want to see his face..but why she gets angry when deepak is happy....what kind of a mother she is? she can't see her son enjoying or just being happy...that's weird... 😕 if he is talking to suhana or enjoying with meethi..why she doesn't like it? poor poor guy....


n i don't like the way family members react to this whole thing either...fine they all love radha bua... but why can't they talk to deepak? ishaan said hum sab deepak se bahut pyaar karte hai! Really Ishaan!! mujhe to dikhai nahi deta 🥱 No one even wished him happy birthday even after knowing its his birthday...arey birthday to hi tha...aisa kya pahad toot pada tha....Weird!

N suhana wasn't wrong at all..i am totally with her on this! Go Suhana!

PS: fantastic epi overall... looking forward to next week!
the way they showed meethi's reaction was soo cute! kids start crying immediately when such things happen..lol..they don't understand anything..n she was later crying that she didn't even get to eat the cake..hehe..awww meethi is so cute :)



@bold: Ditto yaar Manali....I was quite disappointed and annoyed with Ishaan there too....I don't feel too sympathetic towards for him not even going after Suhana after she left....just standing there with this reluctant/unhappy expression on his face....even in the precap he's standing off to the side like he just doesn't want to deal with anything.....well he'll have to....I hope he tackles this better in the coming epis....

And yes overall the family is being damn weird about Deepak.....it doesn't add up even if they are worried about upsetting RB by talking to him.....this is all too much....ek happy b'day bolne mein sach mein kya pahaad toot jaata?....the guy deserves atleast some more affection and love from his cousins and aunts. If not for Dadaji and Badi Maa, bechare ka pata nahin kya ho :S

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".