Originally posted by: smrth
Hgg,
Assessment on two fronts. Kumud's character sketch- its plausibility. And VC's response. Since we are debating later, I will try to relate this with the elapsed script.
You say- VC should do more for her, like what he has done for Dukh baa. What would he do now? A la Sahas rai, he should get Pramaad arrested and rectify the misjudgement as DV is involved. You are right HGG, he should and he will. Why! He may even 'murder' him for all rage it may provoke in him- his most precious child. But Hgg, do they know DV is involved?? Not only DV- a raging extramarital affair for that matter!
At this point only information they have is this. 'He is taking alcohol'. And his sentence before he passed out," Kumud You are all 'Drama". So can he order her back on 'alcohol' charges? Notice, Kumud's noncommittal, no promise ( 'wily' cvs😲 ) is keeping actual seriousness 'hidden' from him.😲 Even Dukhbaa is not sharing whatever extra information she has had ( and even she does not have it all). So on what premise would he interfere at this point? Only alcohol? Hgg, as you know, viewer's 360 D view is sometimes misleading. But I have more faith in your analytical power. If possible see the episode once more, 'objectively' as a plausible narrative.
As for first part; Kumud's character sketch, it still has plausibility. But where it is lacking is in Saras's.🤢
smrth...
chuck the DV or affair part or arrests for now...
purely on today's epi...the least thing to be done...
1) probe more...and ask...
- you have a Son In Law who lied to you (going out for soft drinks), disappeared in the evening at 4 pm and who came late at night dead drunk!
- all the market news that you discounted are suddenly all true...what else have you heard? should you confirm with kumud?
- when you asked your daughter if all was well...she lied to your face...this from a daughter who shared everything with you...why?
- and the sentence...what did he mean?...why?...
2) probe more...and ask...
- when you tell your daughter to promise that she will not lie and always tell when she is in trouble and she does not promise but hesitates...why?...this from a daughter who shared everything with you
3) probe more...and ask...
- when it suddenly hits you that you screwed up and married her off to someone who is obviously not right...
- you would want to know everything!
You don't need to wait for a broken jaw or something due to DV before you ask her what's wrong!
He's the 'enlightened' father!!!
The last thing not to do is what he did today...that ok it was my fault...so let her be... I have lost the right to question her too!...let's all go to sleep...
This was totally out of character...It was all very pat ...show some superficial remorse and grief...once some bit of crying done...then all say we leave it to kumud...and cut to the next stage of the story shown in the pre-cap...
Edited by hotdogg - 12 years ago