Kalika- is she really that bad? Post-pg.1 & discussion pg. 38 - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

293

Views

22.8k

Users

34

Likes

766

Frequent Posters

SC-IPK1-Wwisher thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#41
I was very happy to read your post coz you raised valid points which were playing in my mind.
I agree with you fully that Saras betrayed her ONLY ONCE . Saras had refused to get married ...he did not refuse Kumud but the marriage as an institution . Kumud took it personally and challenged him to come over and refuse the proposal. But they fell in love.That cannot be called betrayal .

Another point is Kumud hides the truth or has habit of pushing facts under the carpet. When Guman told many a times that she will make sure this marriage does not happen . Why did she not tell her Bapu or Badi Ma ? Guman's threats were serious and could not have been taken lightly. But as you mentioned she took it up as a challenge .
Just like now, she has taken a challenge to reform Pramad and make her marriage work.
In her defiance, she makes decisions and when they go wrong she blames Saras.

>>>>> " Why should Saras pay for his and her mistakes both? " .

You are right here . Why she is blaming Saras for the challenges she has taken ? Why can't she ask and blame her Bapu too for taking hasty decision of her marriage ? But Kumud, ignores her Bapu's mistake . Why ? ...coz she loves him .
This makes me think that does she really loves Saras ? If yes , then why she is not even willing to give a thought to understand and believe Saras ? Knowing the full truth by now and hope she has connected Guman's warning with it too . But no Kumud loves to blame and cry .
Madam...Love is understanding one another and not blaming .

>>>> " Basically, Saras is a nice guy and so he is the one taking all the blame. "

😊😊😊

>>>>>Why is this condoned and watched by us all? .

My reply to that is Gautam Rode's expressions and his brilliant acting as Saras.😊


>>>>>Thanks for reading and liking the post. I equally appreciate your thoughts as well. Today, she tells her family how she is still that strong confident girl Blah...Blah... Personally, I just fast forwarded, can't get myself to listen to all that unrealistic stuff. Does she even say, that she has Saras as a 24/7 bodyguard. Any woman who has such a person can tackle all her life problems. To me Kumud is an unrealistic person, she continues lying to her family and blaming Saras for all their wrong doing. She knows she will be dead, is Saras is not around. Mon. again, she cannot save herself, hubby and her mangalsutra, without Saras.

When will these VC family members hold themselves responsible for their current state and stop blaming others. Kumari had an affair and Saras paid for her wrong doing as well. Does Kumud even appreciate that?
annete thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#42
challenges ,challenges,challenges... cultural challenges, gender challenges, age challenges, perception challenges ... like some one said tv history is dotted with long running serials that are not critically acclaimed but provide viewers with a star they want in their homes for a long time and with whom they feel really comfortable
..Zainab.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#43
/first of all great post! Very well written👍🏼
However I might disagree with u in some places
The way the character of kumud has been depicted 🤓
Will contradict her attitude now if she quits her marriage thinki about it
All of a sudden the women who didnt want to see the guys
Who broke her heart twice will now leave her marriage for him
It just doesn't make sense!🤔

Yea when we go to talk bout how much kumud is going through
Why does she have tolerate all the crap if her sasural
Is because that's how the directors are following the show
They are trying to make a point
That despite kumud desparately wanting to forgive Saras 🥺
She dips not going to because of the ego and respect she possess
And in my opinion she is doing the right thing
If a man can break ur heart twice then wats the compatibility that now
He's going to stay with her!
Indeed this show is an old story in which a girl in a village somehow makes it to the point where she gets educated and speaks and stands up
For what she believes is right!
She's still a village girl and still does have those tints of tolerating every crap of her sasural no matter what!👎🏼


Now up to TRPs then I think the television audience takes
A really long time trying to get used a whole new saga
Which leads to the show makers changing it up
To the cliche version everyone's likes to gain trps
Nd I highly doubt just by her going back to Saras will change anything!
Loved to hear more of ur thoughts in the future!👍🏼
..Zainab.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#44
To add I feel like Saras technically broke her heart twice🥺!
annete thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#45
...
Edited by annete - 12 years ago
rosame thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#46



>>>>>Thanks for reading and liking the post. I equally appreciate your thoughts as well. Today, she tells her family how she is still that strong confident girl Blah...Blah... Personally, I just fast forwarded, can't get myself to listen to all that unrealistic stuff. Does she even say, that she has Saras as a 24/7 bodyguard. Any woman who has such a person can tackle all her life problems. To me Kumud is an unrealistic person, she continues lying to her family and blaming Saras for all their wrong doing. She knows she will be dead, is Saras is not around. Mon. again, she cannot save herself, hubby and her mangalsutra, without Saras.

When will these VC family members hold themselves responsible for their current state and stop blaming others. Kumari had an affair and Saras paid for her wrong doing as well. Does Kumud even appreciate that?


Kumud should stand up and now reveal the truth that it was Saras who helped Kumari, Saras who helped her in her sasural and now again he is going to rescue her and Pramd from the goons . Truth should be out .

SC-IPK1-Wwisher thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: littles12

/first of all great post! Very well written👍🏼

>>>thank you. And appreciate you writing your thoughts as well.

However I might disagree with u in some places
>> not a problem at all. Good to discuss differences.

The way the character of kumud has been depicted 🤓
Will contradict her attitude now if she quits her marriage thinki about it
>>>> never do I mention she quit. I think she has not been shown to handle the domestic violence in the right manner. To me her current image is contradictory to what was projected to us. The makers have spent too much time with this weak image of her. She could not save her own life ( 3 attempts by now), without a 24/7 bodyguard Saras. Real woman are not so fortunate.

All of a sudden the women who didnt want to see the guys
Who broke her heart twice will now leave her marriage for him
It just doesn't make sense!🤔

>>> agree, she can take her own time. However, I do not think she personally was rejected twice. The first time, Saras had not even seen her, his Dad had sent the proposal. Even the second time, the rejection was not deliberate. He was not in his senses.
Guman had warned Kumud many times about his peculiar behavior, however, Kumud always challenged her ( like now she has taken up this challenge to be with Pramad, even though Pramad does not want her as his wife). Kumud knew Saras weakness very well. She could have given some thought and tried to find out if anything was wrong with him via. Sunny or Danny, especially when she knew he was upset and had nothing to do with his Dad. Though, she loved him she was really not there for him through his crisis.



Yea when we go to talk bout how much kumud is going through
Why does she have tolerate all the crap if her sasural
Is because that's how the directors are following the show
They are trying to make a point
>>>>> not in a way that is expected from reputed makers. If they are going to put forth problems like the regular sas- bahu stuff there is nothing that sets them apart. From the beginning, the viewers of this show are not the regular sas- bahu show viewers, so difficult to put up with certain parts of the story.

That despite kumud desparately wanting to forgive Saras 🥺
She dips not going to because of the ego and respect she possess
>>>> her ego has cost her a lot in life, and it will continue.

And in my opinion she is doing the right thing
If a man can break ur heart twice then wats the compatibility that now
He's going to stay with her!
>>> true, as described above I do not think he broke it twice. She has had ego, honesty and patience issues. I will not be surprised if such women have their heart broken multiple times in real life.


Indeed this show is an old story in which a girl in a village somehow makes it to the point where she gets educated and speaks and stands up
For what she believes is right!
She's still a village girl and still does have those tints of tolerating every crap of her sasural no matter what!
>>>> there have been flaws with the adaptation of the story to the current age. I have seen contradicting personalities of Kumud. At times, I have been confused if I am watching the old story, or adaptation.

Now up to TRPs then I think the television audience takes
A really long time trying to get used a whole new saga
Which leads to the show makers changing it up
To the cliche version everyone's likes to gain trps
Nd I highly doubt just by her going back to Saras will change anything!
Loved to hear more of ur thoughts in the future!👍🏼

>>TRPs are important to keep the show running and I agree there is a need for certain changes to be made. Unfortunately, the current track is not my cup of tea, and the way I deal with it by fast forwarding the parts, I do not approve of. At this time lots of unrealistic things happening. The earlier part of the story was realistic and attracted me to this show. Gautam Rode, continues to be the shows attraction for me. If he was not around, I would have quit by now.



My answers black font ( normal). Hope I managed to answers all the points you have raised.
Edited by SC_wellwisher - 12 years ago
SC-IPK1-Wwisher thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: rosame




>>>>>Thanks for reading and liking the post. I equally appreciate your thoughts as well. Today, she tells her family how she is still that strong confident girl Blah...Blah... Personally, I just fast forwarded, can't get myself to listen to all that unrealistic stuff. Does she even say, that she has Saras as a 24/7 bodyguard. Any woman who has such a person can tackle all her life problems. To me Kumud is an unrealistic person, she continues lying to her family and blaming Saras for all their wrong doing. She knows she will be dead, is Saras is not around. Mon. again, she cannot save herself, hubby and her mangalsutra, without Saras.

When will these VC family members hold themselves responsible for their current state and stop blaming others. Kumari had an affair and Saras paid for her wrong doing as well. Does Kumud even appreciate that?



Kumud should stand up and now reveal the truth that it was Saras who helped Kumari, Saras who helped her in her sasural and now again he is going to rescue her and Pramd from the goons . Truth should be out .


>>>> high time. I demand some honesty from her now. Does she not think, that telling all this will reduce some of Saras stress. Poor guy thinks he has hurt her and her family so bad.
SC-IPK1-Wwisher thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#49

Originally posted by: littles12

To add I feel like Saras technically broke her heart twice🥺!


>>> I disagree here, and have discussed it in your other response.
kaieteur thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#50
MY PERSONAL TAKE WOULD BE --PLS TAKE THIS SHOW OFF THE AIR --IT IS GOING NOWHERE, AND THE MORALS ARE DOWNRIGHT BAD, FOR ANY WOMAN, KUMUD WANTS TO BE A MARTYR, SHE IS ALONE, LIFE IS PRECIOUS, LET THE BAD HUSBAND REALISE HIS MISTAKE AND TRANSFORM HIMSELF THEY DONT LOVE EACH OTHER -- THIS IS A BAD DEAL GONE WRONG MR BHANSALI --- LET IT GO -- THE ACTORS ARE WASTING THEIR TALENTS ON THIS SHOW!!!!😡😡😡😡

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".