There is NO comparison between SC & IPK!!

enchanted. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
It has been almost a month since this show started, and it has been doing such a fantastic job! The TRPs are rising, the actor (not just the leads) are perfect, the sets are amazing, the title track is the best, the cinematography, everything is just going really good so far; however, STILL we are having these posts bringing in a comparison between SC and IPK! I mean come on! The show ended..and it has NOTHING to do with SC! 😡

I liked IPK when it first began, but IMO the storyline, especially the writing ( which is EXTREMELY important) sucked BIG TIME. I'm not meaning to offend anyone, but the story COMPLETELY relied on the lead pair and their "chemistry", and SC is not aiming for that at all! Unlike IPK, in SC every, single character is important and has been given a back story, and even though SaMud are an integral part of the show, every other character, including Yash and Kumari and Vidya Chatur, help in making the show interesting and fun to watch. Therefore, could we PLEASE stop comparing everything to IPK? Please!

I'm sorry, but this has been getting on my nerves since quite a long time now. I hope you understand. Every time we have a good episode or a good scene, or the fact that the lead pair have great chemistry on this show, is compared with Sanaya and Barun, and how "they had amazing chemistry, and so do Gautam and Jenny"..even the title track is compared to Rabba Ve..I mean come on! SC's title track has nothing to do with Rabba Ve (thank god! 😆)..& there is no comparison! On every single IF article, we have people talking about IPK..which is extremely annoying. I understand there are a lot of IPK fans on this forum, but not everybody liked that show, & it was definitely not a universally favorite show, so if everyone started comparing everything to the shows they watch, it would take credit away from SC.

According to me, SC is a much better show, simply because its been written amazingly, and it actually has storylines! ⭐️ So please stop the comparison. Didn't mean to offend, but really wanted to point this out, as non-IPK fans, or atleast me, are finding this constant 'ghasito IPK or SaRun in every article/post' quite annoying!


**PS, I commend everyone who is an ardent IPK fan but realises that this show has nothing to do with them, and therefore never brings them into it 👏.
Edited by enchanted. - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

86

Views

8.8k

Users

57

Likes

460

Frequent Posters

BadtameezBrat thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
totally agree with u.. even m fed up with ds comparison posts... first of all ds is nt ipk2... hw much it was good or bad... sc has nthing to do with it... ipk has already seperate forum so plz discuss n compare thr...

@tm : superb dear... me too wanted to make such kinda post... bt u already said which i wanted to say...

plz request to all...dnt bring ipk in ds forum... all r nt fan of ipk...
ZaYa-Beintehaa thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
lol I was an ipkknd fan but I agree 100% ipkknd had NO storyline :)
Sanju_ thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
so agree with you...it annoys me so much when they keep saying nothing beats IPK and all that...hello! IPK wasn't the universally favorite show...in fact, no show is as such...even I liked the show before the love track started but after that the storyline went haywire and I stopped watching!! the show and the lead couple did nothing to me but I never went to their forum and talked shit about their show but all they do here is compare SC with IPK and talk negatives either about the show or the actors..why are they here in the first place if they have so much problems?? but I truly respect the fans who see beyond their fav show and couple...there are some genuine fans who still love IPK and are enjoying SC too but I would never understand people who always have problems!! anyway if SC isn't filling the hole of IPK and arshi, then that's not a problem coz SC never aimed to fill the hole in IPK's fans hearts.
BadtameezBrat thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
ipk had storyline or nt... dets nt d point... point is.. ds is sc forum... nt ipk... so plz dnt bring ur other fav show actors here...

no harsh feeling with any1... bt plz no more ipk...
Missy-rc thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
I agree. Really don't know why some people are so obsessed with IPKKND? It was a good show but not the best- and like everything else it ran its own course. There are no similarities between the 2 shows or the leads. SaMud are totally different in delivery from Arhi. Please guys give it a rest.
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
Agree wid u

M also an ipk fan, sorry was...I get irritated, I hv moved on

If I c such posts, I cmnt against it, esp if its extreme
charmz517 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#8
@enchanted:

THANK YOU for making this post. I agree with you 100%. I was also an IPKKND fan, but only b/c of the scenes between Arshi (which is pretty much what the show relied on), otherwise, the story line was so dragged and all over the place. By the last few months of IPKKND, I actually became bored of the same story. SC on the other hand is the first show that is NOT dragging (thank God!!!) & I really hope it stays this way.

SC is fully based on a story line and I just love how they are unfolding bits and pieces of everyone's character. It's so beautifully written and directed. 👏 Not to mention, SAMUD are in a TOTALLY different Magical Universe! They exerted chemistry from the very start, before they were even face-to-face.. that is EXTREMELY difficult to do, and till SC, i thought it was impossible too... but SaMud made it happen... LOVE THEM and the entire cast of SC! 👍🏼
452840 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
Love your post, it is really annoying of some people to 24/7 complain.
I am fed up, at least don't ruin it for others.

_BacknForth_ thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#10
Okay guys there is no point in degrading a show in order to show your praise for another.
Everyone has their own opinion. And everyone is allowed to think as they feel fit.

IPK might not have been the best show, but it surely was for many of us cuz we got emotionally connected to it. And nobody has any right to comment on it.
If you didn't like it, you didn't. That's it.

How does SC come into the picture here?

True, I have been very irritated by the comparison posts too.
But we should stop comparing not because you wanna outshine one with respect to the other, but because they have absolutely nothing to be compared about. Two very different shows, with two very different storylines.

I can find a hundred flaws with SC, and so can I with IPK.
But at the end of the day, I watch them both. Cuz I like them both.
Edited by _BacknForth_ - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".