There is NO comparison between SC & IPK!! - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

86

Views

8.8k

Users

57

Likes

460

Frequent Posters

Nkapoor3 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#21
Guys don't be harsh! Both shows are love stories! So what if fans of ippknd mention their show sometimes?
Tinkerbell5 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#22
Everyone who knows me on Indian Forum can vouch for the fact that I was a die hard fan of IPK but even I am tired of the comparisons.

IPK is different and Saraswatichandra is different - the only thing they have in common is that they are both love stories.

So just let IPK go and embrace Saraswatichandra😆
-X-x-X- thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: -barunoholic-

i HARDLY SEE ANY COMPARISION POST..FIRST

SECOND,THIS FORUM HAS MAX IPKKND FANS...so better dont spoil their mood



So according to you the TM shouldn't voice her opinions in fear of offending the IPK fans? :/
The IPK members have got to realise that yes they as a majority like IPK but that doesn't mean they can rule every damn place and bring that show in wherever possible! There are people in this forum who haven't watched IPK or chose not and came here for something new... Y'know maybe to discuss Saraswatichandra? I have seen a lot of these posts and about you, I don't know whether you actually haven't seen it or you chose not to but this person does have a point! Keep IPK stuff in its own forum, don't drag it to every possible place even if it has no relevance.
-bornalee- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: enchanted.

It has been almost a month since this show started, and it has been doing such a fantastic job! The TRPs are rising, the actor (not just the leads) are perfect, the sets are amazing, the title track is the best, the cinematography, everything is just going really good so far; however, STILL we are having these posts bringing in a comparison between SC and IPK! I mean come on! The show ended..and it has NOTHING to do with SC! 😡


I liked IPK when it first began, but IMO the storyline, especially the writing ( which is EXTREMELY important) sucked BIG TIME. I'm not meaning to offend anyone, but the story COMPLETELY relied on the lead pair and their "chemistry", and SC is not aiming for that at all! Unlike IPK, in SC every, single character is important and has been given a back story, and even though SaMud are an integral part of the show, every other character, including Yash and Kumari and Vidya Chatur, help in making the show interesting and fun to watch. Therefore, could we PLEASE stop comparing everything to IPK? Please!

I'm sorry, but this has been getting on my nerves since quite a long time now. I hope you understand. Every time we have a good episode or a good scene, or the fact that the lead pair have great chemistry on this show, is compared with Sanaya and Barun, and how "they had amazing chemistry, and so do Gautam and Jenny"..even the title track is compared to Rabba Ve..I mean come on! SC's title track has nothing to do with Rabba Ve (thank god! 😆)..& there is no comparison! On every single IF article, we have people talking about IPK..which is extremely annoying. I understand there are a lot of IPK fans on this forum, but not everybody liked that show, & it was definitely not a universally favorite show, so if everyone started comparing everything to the shows they watch, it would take credit away from SC.

According to me, SC is a much better show, simply because its been written amazingly, and it actually has storylines! ⭐️ So please stop the comparison. Didn't mean to offend, but really wanted to point this out, as non-IPK fans, or atleast me, are finding this constant 'ghasito IPK or SaRun in every article/post' quite annoying!


**PS, I commend everyone who is an ardent IPK fan but realises that this show has nothing to do with them, and therefore never brings them into it 👏.


@bold copletely agree wid u..
i never liked IPK..n SC is way tooo better thn IPK..atleast till now..
n "kuch na kahe" is much more better than rabba ve.(sorry ipk fans its my personal opinion)
even its d best title song ever..👏
grapegirl thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#25
FINALLY someone made this post, yay!

I completely agree with you 100% about the annoying IPKKND references.😡 Yeah that show was good in the beginning, but it completely went down the drain, I mean chemistry of the leads don't just make a show, you have to have important secondary characters. IPKKND completely destroyed the secondary characters, that half of them actually had no lines and decided to leave the show.

Saraswatichandra is epic, I mean take todays episode saras and kumud screentime together was like 30 seconds, and it was amazing redardless. I love Kumud's dad, and the buaji is growing on me, I love kumari and everyone, the show is just so well rounded and put together. And come on the show has been on air for what, 3 weeks?...and looks at the TRPs!

Ah and I see you're a once upon a time fan, I love hook!!!

p.s. ooo sorry i didn't mean to bash, got a bit carried away😕
Edited by grapegirl - 12 years ago
.shinchan. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: -X-x-X-



So according to you the TM shouldn't voice her opinions in fear of offending the IPK fans? :/
The IPK members have got to realise that yes they as a majority like IPK but that doesn't mean they can rule every damn place and bring that show in wherever possible! There are people in this forum who haven't watched IPK or chose not and came here for something new... Y'know maybe to discuss Saraswatichandra? I have seen a lot of these posts and about you, I don't know whether you actually haven't seen it or you chose not to but this person does have a point! Keep IPK stuff in its own forum, don't drag it to every possible place even if it has no relevance.


I hardly see any comparision post..okk...I am frm IPK forum..I have many frnds here bt they never bring IPK here in any post..I m using IPK here for the first tym..
n if few ppl r doin this,then dont tag the whole IPK fandom ..
We ppl r enjoying SC as much as u ppl r enjoying..
so I guess insecuirities lie in u

ps- i hv to go rude bt no option was left
mcdreamy. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#27
Couldn't have put it any better! THANK YOU so much for this much needed post :) I don't normally comment on topics here just read them lol and tbh seeing so many comparisons to IPK had really been getting to me now especially since I follow QH too and we have enough comparisons there too but hey I can cut them some slack there cos it's the same production house (even though I still don't support those comparisons either!) but it's really bizarre to see comparisons between SC and IPK too cos there is absolutely NOTHING to compare! The PH, actors and storylines are all completely different, just the same channels and I understand IPK fans love the show but that doesn't mean your gonna compare shows which are poles apart! So please STOP THAT NOW :)

And I don't understand why some people are saying that the TM has called for a fight :S she hasn't bashed anyone and if people are mature enough then they will understand that not everyone is a fan of IPK .. I can understand that some fans are emotionally attached to the show and SaRun/ArHi and I can completely relate to that, since I'm very much attached to DMG and AR/KaJen even though the show is LONG over but I don't go around comparing DMG to every other show on tv cos frankly that just gets annoying for the fans of that show!

So please be considerate and stop these pointless comparisons and just enjoy the show :)

Once again thanks to the TM for this much needed topic <3
Edited by GoldenSkies - 12 years ago
V_Sgeet thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#28
completely agree with the TM!😃
moon.river thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#29
Thank you for posting this. It was getting annoying. They have their own forum to share and discuss their 'comparison' but they just had to come here and spam with IPK. Whenever I check in to this forum, there's always someone mentioning the oh-so-greatness of IPK. I wasn't a huge fan of the show but it was nothing epic or unique. Those kind of stories have been shown plenty of times. And if IPK fans don't want to hear anything bad about their show, why come to SC forum and talk bad about SC and expect us to be fine with it? Sheesh.
SharayuP thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#30
PEACE😃
Edited by sharaya - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".