There is NO comparison between SC & IPK!! - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

86

Views

8.8k

Users

57

Likes

460

Frequent Posters

-X-x-X- thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: -barunoholic-



I hardly see any comparision post..okk...I am frm IPK forum..I have many frnds here bt they never bring IPK here in any post..I m using IPK here for the first tym..
n if few ppl r doin this,then dont tag the whole IPK fandom ..
We ppl r enjoying SC as much as u ppl r enjoying..
so I guess insecuirities lie in u

ps- i hv to go rude bt no option was left



LOOOL first things first, clear out what insecurities? Sorry to disappoint you but I am not so eager about these shows that they can create 'insecurities' within me. The only reason I grouped the entire fandom together is because I've seen it time and again, not only on this forum. Naturally people are gonna stereotype if a lot of members do this :) Now it's at your discretion whether you want to reply back to me or not, I won't find it rude if you choose not to :)
Edited by -X-x-X- - 12 years ago
mcdreamy. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: -barunoholic-



I hardly see any comparision post..okk...I am frm IPK forum..I have many frnds here bt they never bring IPK here in any post..I m using IPK here for the first tym..
n if few ppl r doin this,then dont tag the whole IPK fandom ..
We ppl r enjoying SC as much as u ppl r enjoying..
so I guess insecuirities lie in u

ps- i hv to go rude bt no option was left



LOL 😆 well either you're just playing blind or you are genuinely unaware of these comparisons! No one is stupid to make such a lengthy post without any particular reason .. This post was called for due to all these comparisons so they're obv happening otherwise we wouldn't bother to comment! And there's no need to get all defensive cos no one has bashed IPK .. We just asked for a simple thing to not compare the two shows and if you're not one of the people who are comparing then great! No need to get worried. Hopefully the people who are comparing will understand and stop!
-B.N.K- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#33


SC is the best show i hv come across with in indian telly .. i was a ipk fan n i loved that show n cried for it.. but what ever is gone is dead n will never come back again ... talking about it n my new home is like making it dirty n all .. me n my frns never did something like that i never let them...

n i agree with u tm but ur post is not doing any good... if u want to stop something or change something ur the one should start that ... ur post is a eye opener but it also doing the same... comparing n offending other... stop talking about it ... the hv to forget abt ipk .. coz our SC is that good 😊
myviewprem thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#34
i have no clue of a show called IPK. Which channel was that on?
Anyways we cannot compare current serial storylines with an 18th century novel. I had SC(part1) as a text and know the story well. So story is not surprise element for me or many Indians. Its just execution. SC story is simple and moral oriented story and cannot be compared with current serial stories. This story is a classic like Kalidasa Shakuntala etc. Its just to be seen how well director shows that classic story.
What i read in book is different from the serial in SC. There Kumud and Saras never fight. Kumud treats him with care and respect from beginning. In book Saras writes a rejection letter but Kumud replies so nicely that they start writing often and finally Saras decides to go and meet the girl who writes him so maturely. Here i did not like them fighting and Kumud humiliating him. I would have preferred if that part had been shown instead of fighting and falling in love like modern stories.
Edited by myviewprem - 12 years ago
.shinchan. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: GoldenSkies



LOL 😆 well either you're just playing blind or you are genuinely unaware of these comparisons! No one is stupid to make such a lengthy post without any particular reason .. This post was called for due to all these comparisons so they're obv happening otherwise we wouldn't bother to comment! And there's no need to get all defensive cos no one has bashed IPK .. We just asked for a simple thing to not compare the two shows and if you're not one of the people who are comparing then great! No need to get worried. Hopefully the people who are comparing will understand and stop!


if ppl r making posts outof this forum..thn whts ur problem😕
ofcourse u r nt bashing IPK..bt u r targetting IPK fandom..n thts why m going defensive else I gv 2 hoots to such useless posts which will only increase fights
-B.N.K- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: Tishana

Agree wid u

M also an ipk fan, sorry was...I get irritated, I hv moved on

If I c such posts, I cmnt against it, esp if its extreme


i complained about it n there is a post from our MOD ... but its still going here ... i gave up thinking that time will change it...😊


.shinchan. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: -X-x-X-



LOOOL first things first, clear out what insecurities? Sorry to disappoint you but I am not so eager about these shows that they can create 'insecurities' within me. The only reason I grouped the entire fandom together is because I've seen it time and again, not only on this forum. Naturally people are gonna stereotype if a lot of members do this :) Now it's at your discretion whether you want to reply back to me or by, I won't find it rude if you choose not to :)


"insecuirities" makes u all to comment here.. else this post cn b avoided..
-bornalee- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#38

Originally posted by: myviewprem

i have no clue of a show called IPK. Which channel was that on?

Anyways we cannot compare current serial storylines with an 18th century novel. I had SC(part1) as a text and know the story well. So story is not surprise element for me or many Indians. Its just execution. SC story is simple and moral oriented story and cannot be compared with current serial stories. This story is a classic like Kalidasa Shakuntala etc. Its just to be seen how well director shows that classic story.


agree wid u..i hv not read d story or watched d flim(LOL) yet.but i started watching this show becz d way makers r presenting it..its a simple normal lovestory..we hv loads of lovestories in indian telly ..but d way SLB is presenting it..its commendable 👏👏 haan its diff thing k now m hooked to d show bcz of SaMud/JenAM also😳😆
b4 SC i had never watched any present GEC s drama except form channel V shows..i never planned to watch SC also..but d way all d important charecters were introduced in d first epi itself..i was like wowww..ek hi din mein itna sab.n upar se "kuch na kahe" title track..all these factors made me watch this show n now m glad that i watched its first epi😊
Edited by -bornalee- - 12 years ago
Janeyre thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#39
it annoys me a lot when ppl compare ipk with sc...that show was popular but i m fed up of this...that show already ended...sc is more interesting n very different from other shows...why they have to say that i didn't like ny show after ipk finished n now i m liking sc...SC is the best show and i love the soothing n melodious title track...n far better than rabba ve... Gautam n jenny at their best! SC rocks😉
-X-x-X- thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#40

Originally posted by: -barunoholic-



"insecuirities" makes u all to comment here.. else this post cn b avoided..



Please do tell me EXACTLY WHAT INSECURITIES?
Insecure that this show won't do well? HELL NO I AIN'T EVEN BOTHERED! I watch this for timepass so I don't give a crap about how well it's doing on the TRP chart. Insecure about the the chemistry between the leads? Well obviously I'm liking that and so I'm watching so please do tell WHAT INSECURITIES? I'm curious to know since this has been your response twice now. The only reason I replied to this post was because I agreed with the TM and your comment that she 'better not spoil their mood' because they are supposedly the majority. I couldn't digest that comment, why should she not make a post against this, just because the mighty IPK'ians are gonna be offended? What the fish!
Edited by -X-x-X- - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".