Sadhna--can`t be a part of lie????? - Page 3

Originally posted by: Bini311

Well, concealing a truth and telling a lie is two different things....and also the character of Sadhana wouldn't lie by keeping her hands in Geeta....but again this is not consistent with the past....

actually all foursome wouldn't lie with keeping their hands in Geeta....but the overall concept of putting everything on Sadhana is giving unnecessary burden and importance to the character......Sadi is just a human being at the end....it is not fair to be expected so much of her...how come only she is the rational character of the show? Why for once, other characters are given a chance to be self-sacrificing.....Sorry to rant, but I am so disappointed with this track.

Originally posted by: Nancy Jr

so why she does'nt take the blame on herself now,whatever Ranvir does only because to save her.And also Ranvir always help her.

Unfortunately Sadhana taking ablame for killing or hitting the goon would become a lil bit too much of a contradiction, given the fact that everyone knows ranvir hit him to protect her..either way..however the story evolves..lieing to save some one, when you are under oath itself is perjury..and I am not sure she would do that especially under oath... but the thing is..everytime she lied for something good..something good did happen right? this time..if she lies...she might become great in every ones eyes, for saving Ranvir..but her conscious and her shanskar will not let her do that...😕 I think its a bit of stretch to expect her to lie under oath..given how her character is shaped up to be.

All the facts are out.The second goon mentioned that Ranvir hit the guy with the rod after he was unconscious.That itself is sufficient to send him to jail.Sadhana will def tell the truth even though its not bad if the hitting with the rod thing hadn't happened.So either way this would affect Ranvir..The only way for him to get out would be if the judge or jury decides to release him on some sympathy or some humanitarian cause which is highly unlikely.

This track is twisted and is messed up in such a way I wonder how they are going to solve it without making laughable.

Originally posted by: Bini311

Well, concealing a truth and telling a lie is two different things....and also the character of Sadhana wouldn't lie by keeping her hands in Geeta....but again this is not consistent with the past....

actually all foursome wouldn't lie with keeping their hands in Geeta....but the overall concept of putting everything on Sadhana is giving unnecessary burden and importance to the character......Sadi is just a human being at the end....it is not fair to be expected so much of her...how come only she is the rational character of the show? Why for once, other characters are given a chance to be self-sacrificing.....Sorry to rant, but I am so disappointed with this track.

Lol Bini,we should realize it by now that everything affects Sadhana,every track that happens creates havoc/sadness or anything in Sadhana's life and this is no different.Actually I would be really surprised if a character gets a track for itself in Bidaai even in the future that is if Bidaai lasts that long!!!

exacltly, sadhna ha lied many times.........n if that was cirumstances , this is also circumstances................she can do this for a innoscent ......

i love the character of sadhna..bt in this case i think the situation is being dragged..the sadhna we know loves her family to go to ne extent..and for her,her family and sister come before nethng else..this track is a stupid turn of events by the creatives..sadhna would not hesitate to save ranvir for nethn..

Originally posted by: KhaLidaH

putting ur hand on holly book and lying is a totally a different issue then just tell a lie.