Sadhna--can`t be a part of lie?????

Page

Next Last

ratikarox

@ratikarox

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

Sadhna claims that she can never be part of a lie.....

In dat case i would like to remind d creatives that in flashback many a times sadhna has lied or "concealed the truth" for some good.....

a) Sadhna pretended to love shlok so that aalekh realises his love & takes a stand....

b) When anmol & anamika were ph frnds....sadhna neva revealed to dem their real identities becoz she wantd dem to understnd each odr betr.......still she hid d truth......

So now y cant sadhna lie or "hide d truth" ....to save ranvir......n ragvir & der child's future.......its senseless.....creatives hv gone nuts......

Quote

Frequent Posters

cooldudette

@cooldudette

Explorer

Posted: 15 years ago

Exactly - also the time when she married alekh against mamaji's wishes, she blatantly lied to mamaji that she married him for money as she wanted to be self sacrificing
she could hurt mamaji then but now she cant see she is hurting everyone this time

seems like she suddenly remembered truth on touching the geetha!!

if she prefers being self sacrificing she could have said she hit the goon to save ranvirji then ranvir will come out and everyone will be happy and she can go to jail instead!!!!

i think creatives are running out of ideas to form a storyline that they make up anything and expect us to swallow it

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

scrpngl

@scrpngl

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

Sadi has not give her statement yet so plz dunt waste ur energy in saying all this Sach-Jhoot..
LOl
all i can say is this k they were not jhoot.. the circumstances were like that k Sadi had to lied..butr nw... infront of that holy book (which is used in court) sadhna shud have to tell the truth only..ok..n yea wese bhi that goon's partner has said the truth..so thanks God sadi is save!!! 😃

Quote

zarmeeno

@zarmeeno

Dazzler

Posted: 15 years ago

And as Rajan ji was saying kay she cannot lie with her hand on the geeta. But the oath u take when u have ur hands on the Geeta is jo kahoon gi sach kahoon gi sack kay siwa kuch nahin kahoon gi. Jo bolo sack bolo par pura mat bolo. Oath is not kay iss say related sara kuch sach sach batoon gi.

Quote

zarmeeno

@zarmeeno

Dazzler

Posted: 15 years ago

Yaar one more thing amazes me kay Sadi is the main link to the case and nobody has asked her andything except for D.S. she has'nt been asked by the police and by the court as well.

Quote

Bini311

@Bini311

Dazzler

Posted: 15 years ago

Well, concealing a truth and telling a lie is two different things....and also the character of Sadhana wouldn't lie by keeping her hands in Geeta....but again this is not consistent with the past....

actually all foursome wouldn't lie with keeping their hands in Geeta....but the overall concept of putting everything on Sadhana is giving unnecessary burden and importance to the character......Sadi is just a human being at the end....it is not fair to be expected so much of her...how come only she is the rational character of the show? Why for once, other characters are given a chance to be self-sacrificing.....Sorry to rant, but I am so disappointed with this track.

Edited by Bini311 - 15 years ago

Quote

Nancy

@_Nancy_

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

Didn't she hide about Alekh's from her mamaji before her marriage. Mamaji & his family did'nt know Alekh is mentaly sick.Sadhna hide this from everyone.So how come she is not helping Ranvir this time.What ever Ranvir did is to protect her & she forget that.If Ranvir was not there did she thought what would happen to her.Selfish girl,in this situation it's prove, she lies only if it's good for her. Also when they revealed the truth about dewali night,remember she told everyone they are going out to buy ice cream, & she bought Alekh home from mamaji's house.If this not a lie than tell me what it is. creatives we watch the show & also we listen dialogues, so please think & do what is meaningfull.

Edited by Nancy Jr - 15 years ago

Quote

Khalidah

@KhaLidaH

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

putting ur hand on holly book and lying is a totally a different issue then just tell a lie.

Quote

Saniha

@SaniaKaSidShukl

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: ratikarox
Sadhna claims that she can never be part of a lie.....

In dat case i would like to remind d creatives that in flashback many a times sadhna has lied or "concealed the truth" for some good.....

a) Sadhna pretended to love shlok so that aalekh realises his love & takes a stand....

b) When anmol & anamika were ph frnds....sadhna neva revealed to dem their real identities becoz she wantd dem to understnd each odr betr.......still she hid d truth......

So now y cant sadhna lie or "hide d truth" ....to save ranvir......n ragvir & der child's future.......its senseless.....creatives hv gone nuts......

Well Said i agree with u

Quote

Sweet-Violet

@Sweet-Violet

Rocker

Posted: 15 years ago

#10

Sadhana shouldn't lie after taking an oath. Otherwise it would give a wrong message to the audience. Sadhana is an integral character of the show and she is made to prove herself time to time.
Alekh and his family have become emotionally weak and lost a sense of right and wrong. Just to save Rnaveer, they are ready to blame an innocent person(even though he is a goon).
I think Ranveer will support Sadhana and ask her not to lie in the court. I wish Ragini would think beyond herself and support Sadhana.

Edited by --Anu-- - 15 years ago

Quote

1 2 3

Sadhna--can`t be a part of lie?????

Related Topics

Explore Topics