Does Sadhna deserve the consequences? think deep - Page 4

Originally posted by: teddysweety

Your family member protected you from goons and the goon was seriously injured/died.
What would you do?

Stick to the truth even if it leads to that family member's demise? - Sadhna
Or stick by your family member?

Now I'm no saint but I do value the truth but in this case I choose family. Family is most important and if you're not on their side then who will be?

I know morally Sadhna's correct by sticking to the truth but I would not follow in her foot steps.
I know Alekh's rude to her and doesn't deserve her love but could you really blame him for hating her? Her statement might be responsible for his brother's future.

If Alekh would be in her shoes, I believe Alekh would pick family also and expects the same from his life partner as his family is her family and vice versa. Don't you think Alekh would stick by Sadhna's family?

I felt bad for Sadhna when Alekh treated her bad for no reason but their rift now will be justified for me and it sux bc i never wanted the show to take this track.

Long rant.. i know... but boils down to a three questions.

What would you do if you were in Sadhna's position?
Is Alekh justified for being furious with Sadhna?
Would Alekh stick by Sadhna's family if instead of Ranvir it was .. Vinu?

What do you guys think?

i dun think her truth/lie will affect ranvir bec. therez one more eye witness to the case..but if I was the only eyewitness, i wud have def. saved Ranvir..there r many things in life which r beyond truth n lies...If it was Alekh in Ranvir's place then? we must also consider tht ranvir is not a criminal..he did this in a fit of anger...any decent man in his position wud have done the same...not beating him with the rod though :D


I'll not answer abt Alekh bec. he's still a mental patient for me whoz recovering ! he's unpredictable....like i said if Alekh was there in Ranvir's place, the court wud have probably excused him on the grounds of his mental condition..his attitude towards Sadhna is completely unjustified !

Originally posted by: pankhi

I m sorry but i m not agree wid u. Agar aisa hi hoga toh fir AALEKH ji aur dusare characters mein fark hi kya rahega. Aur waise bhi SADI ki jo bhi condition hai uske liye aap AALEKH ko point out nahi kar sakte hai. Kyunki AALEKH se shaadi ka faisla unka pna tha. kisi ne bhi unhe force nahi kiya tha. Na MAMA ji ne , na MAMI ji ne, na RAGI ne, na NANI ji ne aur na hi MALTI ne. Ye faisla unka sirf apna tha. Aur rahi baat SHLOK ki toh kar leti shaadi kisne mana kiya tha. AALEKH ji bhi toh yahi chaahte the. AALEKH ji ko iyna bura keh rahe ho aap unhone toh SADI ko mauk abhi diya ek better life partner chunane ka.

There is a saying "Neki kar dariya mein dal" that holds so true for Sadhana. As far as Alekh Sir is concerned what can I say about him when he is trusting Naveen more than his own wife. Hope he gets a taste of his own medicine very soon. And how much he values family relations and all.....well who is responsible for his current condition......something to think about. He used to be locked-up in the outhouse and was a violent person.... look at him now, what a drastic change.

Well... since I've been in India ... I always ... find surprising things everywhere.

Originally posted by: scrpngl

yeah..truth is truth..n thats what Sadi will say in court!! 😆 sach hi kahegi or sach to sab ko hi bura lagta hai LOL 😉 😆

Originally posted by: LoneStranger

Well... since I've been in India ... I always ... find surprising things everywhere.

Apart from everything ... its really surprising that hiding the truth from court in actually encouraged in a white light!

I mean ... It shouldnt shock me ... I can see ... when I look around ... uff..

Anyways ... If Ranvir is really innocent...no need to run away from truth. And its the COURT to decide who is innocent or not. Why cant we respect the court and the legal system.

Already very discouraged to see the Inspector getting through without any kind of penalty or punishment to try and get some ransom out of Ranvir.... whats going on really!... havoc!

When will our nation start respecting our laws. Law and order is s much neccessary here. I will leave India again soon ... but ... next time I come back ... can it be expected that attitude of the common man will change atleast? ... I dont know.... =(

Oh well again ... all got their POV and liking over this. But one thing is absolutely clear and should be clear to all...MY SADHNA IS BLEMISHLESS AND FOREVER WILL BE =) ... she dont deserve any bad consequences.

Originally posted by: teddysweety

I believe that in any other situation, the entire family would support Sadi, but that's because they're family and family sticks up for each other. Sadi should help her sister and Ranvir.

As for Alekh, he never learnt what love is; he missed out on the developmental stages. He never went through the crushes, the longing. I honestly started believing that he doesn't love Sadi after he got better; that she isn't his ideal woman. I stopped watching the show then and read the updates instead. I think Sadi, to Alekh, is just a caretaker, which sux. But even then, I believe he would help Sadhna since she helped him get better. It's just that Sadi's harming his brother and that's betrayal.

P.S. I love how opinions in this forum are at the two extremes and are being discussed in a healthy manner. 👏

Alekh has become an emotionless and impassive person after he came to know CM's true colors. He is only performing his duties towards his family as an elder son and elder brother. He has not shown a single concern for the guy in coma and his family. He was totally unmoved by their condition when Sadhana and Ranveer were talking about them in the prison. Any normal human being with some emotions would at-least show some concern but not him. See the difference. That's why he will not understand Sadhana and kick her out of his life. He has become incapable of giving her any love.

i would hav definetly supported my family member not just becoz he is from our family. but when somebody has done so much for u , aapko aise insaan ko support karna hai jisne aapki madad karte waqt ek baar bhi nahi socha ki vo sahi hai ya galat . aur jab ek aadmi sahi hai to def one should support family member .

Originally posted by: sushmitadutta

i would hav definetly supported my family member not just becoz he is from our family. but when somebody has done so much for u , aapko aise insaan ko support karna hai jisne aapki madad karte waqt ek baar bhi nahi socha ki vo sahi hai ya galat . aur jab ek aadmi sahi hai to def one should support family member .

i just want 2 ask one ques . ki kya sadhna tab bhi vahi karti jo vo karne wali hai(statement against ranvir) agar ranvir ki jagah alekh hota. tab bhi kya vo truth ka support karti.

i think alekh is right on his side. why will he tolerate so much neglegence against his bro who had done so much for him & sadhna without asking something

Originally posted by: teddysweety

i also believe that the ideal woman protects her family from harm

Yes, Sadhana is an ideal woman who will protect her family like always even though they treat her like an used toy.

Originally posted by: teddysweety

It's not about Sadi lying under oath though. If such question is asked, she should answer correctly. But otherwise, she should protect her family.
If it was Sadi's son, wouldn't she do that? I believe she would.

This question does even arise now as the truth is already out....thanks to the other goon. It was clear that Sadhana would try her best to help Ranveer but she wont be able to lie after taking an oath as per her character. If she does that then her character would be reduced to an ordinary one.