Does Sadhna deserve the consequences? think deep

Page

Next Last

teddysweety

@teddysweety

Navigator

Posted: 15 years ago

Your family member protected you from goons and the goon was seriously injured/died.
What would you do?

Stick to the truth even if it leads to that family member's demise? - Sadhna
Or stick by your family member?

Now I'm no saint but I do value the truth but in this case I choose family. Family is most important and if you're not on their side then who will be?

I know morally Sadhna's correct by sticking to the truth but I would not follow in her foot steps.
I know Alekh's rude to her and doesn't deserve her love but could you really blame him for hating her? Her statement might be responsible for his brother's future.

If Alekh would be in her shoes, I believe Alekh would pick family also and expects the same from his life partner as his family is her family and vice versa. Don't you think Alekh would stick by Sadhna's family?

I felt bad for Sadhna when Alekh treated her bad for no reason but their rift now will be justified for me and it sux bc i never wanted the show to take this track.

Long rant.. i know... but boils down to a three questions.

What would you do if you were in Sadhna's position?
Is Alekh justified for being furious with Sadhna?
Would Alekh stick by Sadhna's family if instead of Ranvir it was .. Vinu?

What do you guys think?

Quote

Frequent Posters

Sweet-Violet

@Sweet-Violet

Rocker

Posted: 15 years ago

Sadhana may chose to stick by the truth for whatever reason but Alekh is definitely wrong. How can he forget that Sadhana gave him selfless love and changed his life for good. He was a mentally unstable person and his mother was suffering. Vasu never bothered to notice how Alekh was behaving with Sadhana after he started becoming normal.
Rajvansh family does not deserve Sadhana at all and it would be their own misfortune if she leaves. Its better for her to leave the house than living under the same roof and getting cold vibes from these thankless people.

Edited by --Anu-- - 15 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Simran Shriya

@-ParidhiHolic-

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 15 years ago

well ur topic i understnad but alekh shud not forgot all the sacrifices done by sadhna for welfare of only alekh.alekh was abnormal but sadhna doesn't left his hand she continue tie her pure knot with alekh as a perfect wife.it may be that sadi may wrong but if alekh had pour down all love and concentrated on sadhna,then we don't have to face this time for any reasone.ispite of all this he always use tot give bad feelings to wards sadhna.he has best feelings towards ranveer,ragini,vasu and all but he forgot sadi even he remebered mamaji but not sadhna....

Quote

priya

@pankhi

Dazzler

Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: teddysweety
Your family member protected you from goons and the goon was seriously injured/died.
What would you do?

Stick to the truth even if it leads to that family member's demise? - Sadhna
Or stick by your family member?

Now I'm no saint but I do value the truth but in this case I choose family. Family is most important and if you're not on their side then who will be?

I know morally Sadhna's correct by sticking to the truth but I would not follow in her foot steps.
I know Alekh's rude to her and doesn't deserve her love but could you really blame him for hating her? Her statement might be responsible for his brother's future.

If Alekh would be in her shoes, I believe Alekh would pick family also and expects the same from his life partner as his family is her family and vice versa. Don't you think Alekh would stick by Sadhna's family?

I felt bad for Sadhna when Alekh treated her bad for no reason but their rift now will be justified for me and it sux bc i never wanted the show to take this track.

Long rant.. i know... but boils down to a three questions.

What would you do if you were in Sadhna's position?
Is Alekh justified for being furious with Sadhna?
Would Alekh stick by Sadhna's family if instead of Ranvir it was .. Vinu?

What do you guys think?

I will stick wid my family. And try 2 protect d family member.

Yes. Aalekh is not only SADHNA's hubby. He is also a son, brother, jija and a human being also. For every man ther family's happiness should come first.

Ofcourse. I have full trust on my AALEKH. aur AALEKH ji ne ye jail track mein prove bhi kiya hai ki unke liye family jyada important hai. Koi goon nahi.

Quote

Simran Shriya

@-ParidhiHolic-

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 15 years ago

maine yahi mana tha ki bas alekh sadi ko supprot kare par he failed in his life exam

Quote

222864

Suspended

Posted: 15 years ago

Q. What would you do if you were in Sadhna's position?

Ans: I would certainly tell the truth. I dont think the truth should harm Ranvir so much. TRUTH is above all and everything. Specially on Oath, infront of the pesence of GOD ALMIGHTLY... if there one speaks a lie...HOW IMMORAL can that person be? IMMORAL TO THE CORE.

Q. Is Alekh justified for being furious with Sadhna?
Ans: Alekh is absolutely horrific being furious with Sadhna. Bahut toh sacchai sacchai karta tha yeh ... jab apni baari ayi to sacchai choot gaya? Uffffff..... I am not demeaing him, but God help me, I dont find another suitable word but 'HYPOCRACY' in this case. He used to give LECTURES on truth. That whatever happens, whatever the price, whatever the situation....ONE MUST ALWAYS STAND WITH TRUTH. Aur ab sahab ko jhoot chor ke kuch nazar nahi aata... arre jao jao Alekh Sahab...meri Sadhna ko tumhare jaise insaan ki koi zaroorat nahi. WOH TO TUMHE ZARRORAT THA MERI SADHNA KA. Arre, sharam karo sharam karo... ek niwala to mu mein nahi le sakte the...

Q, Would Alekh stick by Sadhna's family if instead of Ranvir it was .. Vinu?
Ans: Alekh is so intensely SELFISH and UNGRATEFUL. Abtak kisi bhi character ko ITNA selfish nahi dikhaya gaya hai kahinbhi... arre aur kuch nahi to SHARAM to honi chahiye thi .... chi chi chi =( ....

Mere Sadhna ke saath na inshaafi kar ke kya yeh log khush rahenge... TOOFAN AYGA ...ANDHI HOGI ... ZALZALA HOGA.... HAR DIN HAZAR SAAL KE BARABAAR HOGA ... ROAD PE AA JAYENGE, SAB PAGAL HO JAYENGE =( .... 😡

Edited by LoneStranger - 15 years ago

Quote

Simran Shriya

@-ParidhiHolic-

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: LoneStranger
Q. What would you do if you were in Sadhna's position?
Ans: I would certainly tell the truth. I dont think the truth should harm Ranvir so much. TRUTH is above all and everything. Specially on Oath, infront of the pesence of GOD ALMIGHTLY... if there one speaks a lie...HOW IMMORAL can that person be? IMMORAL TO THE CORE.

Q. Is Alekh justified for being furious with Sadhna?
Ans: Alekh is absolutely horrific being furious with Sadhna. Bahut toh sacchai sacchai karta tha yeh ... jab apni baari ayi to sacchai choot gaya? Uffffff..... I am not demeaing him, but God help me, I dont find another suitable word but 'HYPOCRACY' in this case. He used to give LECTURES on truth. That whatever happens, whatever the price, whatever the situation....ONE MUST ALWAYS STAND WITH TRUTH. Aur ab sahab ko jhoot chor ke kuch nazar nahi aata... arre jao jao Alekh Sahab...meri Sadhna ko tumhare jaise insaan ki koi zaroorat nahi. WOH TO TUMHE ZARRORAT THA MERI SADHNA KA. Arre, sharam karo sharam karo... ek niwala to mu mein nahi le sakte the...

Q, Would Alekh stick by Sadhna's family if instead of Ranvir it was .. Vinu?
Ans: Alekh is so intensely SELFISH and UNGRATEFUL. Abtak kisi bhi character ko ITNA selfish nahi dikhaya gaya hai kahinbhi... arre aur kuch nahi to SHARAM to honi chahiye thi .... chi chi chi =( ....

Mere Sadhna ke saath na inshaafi kar ke kya yeh log khush rahenge... TOOFAN AYGA ...ANDHI HOGI ... ZALZALA HOGA.... HAR DIN HAZAR SAAL KE BARABAAR HOGA ... ROAD PE AA JAYENGE, SAB PAGAL HO JAYENGE =( .... 😡

i fully support ur al answers hw allu shud b so selfihs sadi gave her unconditional to him but he forgot all shiit shame on him plzz my sweet allu dont kick away sadi yar and yeah hw one can by taking god's oath infront of all tell lie hw it is not possible

Quote

swati

@Mishka42

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

if iwere in sadhna position i would stick for family member, because

he is innoscent!!!!!!

he did this for me!!!!!!!

truth is important but not more then family , also the injured person is a gunna not any innoscent person so he deserve what he did!!!!!!!!!!

Quote

lisasandra

@lisasandra

Dazzler

Posted: 15 years ago

i am agree with swatikr 12. Alek,s POV, he is right.

Quote

vasundhara

@dharaa

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 15 years ago

#10

well if i was in Sadhna's place i would have thought about my family first then about others.
in every situation family comes first, and its not that Sadhna had to lie completely about the incident, she had to just hide the truth that Ranvir hit the good with the rod when he was unconscious, and there is a HUGE difference between lying and hiding the truth...no one stopped sadhna from telling the truth but she should have thought about Ranvir more than any other thing and she should have hid the half truth...He was the one one who saved her from the goon, and she being Ranvir's bhabhi should have thought of Ranvir more than the goon, i know truth is important, but hiding the truth can save many lives then that is not wrong.
And according to me Aalekh's reaction is normal. Aalekh loves Ranvir a LOT and Ranvir is behind the bar for saving Sadhna from the goon, so its Sadhna's duty and her responsibility to save Ranvir this time. f i was in Aalekh's place i would have done the same thing.

Quote

1 2 3 4 5 ... 8

Does Sadhna deserve the consequences? think deep

Related Topics

Explore Topics