Sudha Chandran and others...

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

shumna

@shumna

Explorer

Posted: 14 years ago

#11

Binny is adorable for the part....Pihu as the beauty without values and gauri, beautiful from inside is the theme I think. Binny fits the role perfectlty and I can't imagine anyone else being able to do justice to that role. So for me its binny for the part.

The height difference makes the pair look more attractive and real.....perfect looking couples tend to make the drama's look more unrealistic.

Quote

evasumi

@evasumi

Rocker

+ 6

Posted: 14 years ago

#12

Laila and Genifan:

I think You two are too criticle of the cast of the show.

Every time I encounter your posts you always have to say some negative stuff about the actors.

One needs acting lessons and one needs to correct the posture....

Let me ask you one thing are you guys some kind of director or some kind of body language critics that you have audacity to critisize in such language that it hurts people even to read it!!!

Binny Sharma is doing a phenomenal job as Gauri and that proved with the award she got as the new comer.. So hope that has made you eat your own words about her.

Samta Sagar is a great actress and a performer and you have no idea what caliber she has. So I think without knowing the caliber of an actor it is not right to give adverse comments about them in such a diminishing way...

You can evaluate the character but to make adverse comments for the actor is against the IF rules

Edited by evasumi - 14 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Asandhimitra

@LadyMacbeth

Achiever

+ 5

Posted: 14 years ago

#13

Originally posted by: evasumi
Laila and Genifan:

I think You two are too criticle of the cast of the show.

Every time I encounter your post you always have to say some negative stuff about the actors.

One needs acting lessons and one needs to correct the posture....

Let me ask you one thing are you guys are some kind of director or some kind of body language critics that you have audacity to critisize in such language that it hurts peole even to read it!!!

Binny Sharma is doing a phenomenal job as Gauri and that proved with the award she got as the new comer.. So hope that has made you eat your own words about her.

Samta Sagar is a great actress and a performer and you have no idea what caliber she has. So I think without knowing the caliber of an actor it is not right to give adverse comments about them in such a diminishing way...

You can evaluate the character but to make adverse comments for the actor is against the IF rules

Absolutely agree with every thing you said .Well-said. I'm amazed that some people still has the audacity when their every words beat dust. Binny proved what a mind blowing actress she is. And, Samta Sagar is well-known for her superb acting. She never sits in home for a day, new offers are always heaped on her lap. And, Binny has created wide spread stirring by her veteran-like acting.

Quote

Rjorge

@Rjorge

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: nycsweetie

i agree with ur post

Quote

ramas

@ramas

Alumni

+ 5

Posted: 14 years ago

#15

Originally posted by: genifan
Additis expressions are never forced but its how she has to deliver it pihu is not at all easy to play and there is vast difference between pihu and any other character on this show
binny is uncomparable to Additis talent

Binny is unbearable to watch she is new comer and dont know anything about acting but what about her body language and mannerisms they are horrible binny should try to stand and walk like a girl if not act, which none expects either. looking at the person in front of you and reciting sentences is not called acting binny is all set to ruin this show with her talent and acting skills there is not a single scene in which she has got into her character

replacing diector is easy but how many will they replace is worth watching

binny getting a show will never work for did in coming years

zee tv shouldnt have compromised on the lead of such a promising show

zeetv and did sucks

why are you comparing 2 actresses which is not allowed by IF rules Plz .be aware of that. sangini dev Team

Quote

Rjorge

@Rjorge

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

#16

Laila, genifan, nycsweetie and Jonaki,

After reading your posts, I am very concerned about the future of India Forums .. if bunch of critical and unhappy members like you regularly participate in discussions conducted by the intelligent members of the forum .... how can that forum survive .. I saved your posts in this thread without comments just so you do not alter or erase your nasty posts as I intend to report you to the moderators as you did not follow the forum rules by indulging into bashing and attacking the artists personally.

My perception after reading your posts is that members like you should be banned from IF because you will always be critical of these hard working artists ... your ban from the forum will save members like me from reading your ridiculously analyzed senseless critical posts ... please note that members like me prefer to encourage the talented artists by being positive about their work as I know they perform in the manner they are asked by the director of the show.

For your information:

Samta Sagar who was addressed by you as the "lady who plays Gauri's mother" .. in personal life Samta ji is a dignified beautiful lady and holds a Masters degree in Philosophy and her father was a renowned writer, she is very humble, sweet, down to earth and helpful individual and is a great poetess... professionally she is a very seasoned and highly sought after actress ... according to you she needs acting classes ... well if that was the case she would not be working in Sangini and would not be a part of the industry for the past 20+ years and not only that she works in soap operas she has also done theater, and only the talented ones can do both ... in America, where I am coming from, she is very popular and loved by Indians living in America for her work ... I got the above information about her after reading her interview published in a prestigious American paper ... I bet after this you have nothing bad to say about Samta ji.

Kunika Lal is the actress who plays the role of nani ... she is one of the most talented actresses in the industry ... if after Sudha ji anyone could play the role of nani it would be Kunika ji and for your information majority of viewers don't care how tall or short she is.

Binny Sharma she is not only beautiful but is a very sweet person, I have only read good things about her from the media articles..being a very new entry to the industry she has proved to be among the best ... not only that she is a graceful dancer, there is no doubt that she is a magical actress...the way she projects comfort in the scenes she plays in the presence of senior actors is just remarkable .... her recent award said it all about her talent.

I am sorry to say but you do not know where these talented artists are coming from so back off and do your research prior to bad mouthing these talented artists and keep your critical senseless and baseless views to yourself as I refuse to share them.

Edited by Rjorge - 14 years ago

Quote

Rjorge

@Rjorge

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

#17

Originally posted by: ramas
why are you comparing 2 actresses which is not allowed by IF rules Plz .be aware of that. sangini dev Team

Thanks ramas ...

Quote

Laila Banu

@Laila2009

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

#18

Originally posted by: evasumi
Laila and Genifan:

I think You two are too criticle of the cast of the show.

Every time I encounter your posts you always have to say some negative stuff about the actors.

One needs acting lessons and one needs to correct the posture....

Let me ask you one thing are you guys some kind of director or some kind of body language critics that you have audacity to critisize in such language that it hurts people even to read it!!!

Binny Sharma is doing a phenomenal job as Gauri and that proved with the award she got as the new comer.. So hope that has made you eat your own words about her.

Samta Sagar is a great actress and a performer and you have no idea what caliber she has. So I think without knowing the caliber of an actor it is not right to give adverse comments about them in such a diminishing way...

You can evaluate the character but to make adverse comments for the actor is against the IF rules

First, I didn't see anything negative in my post. I spoke frankly about the show - my likes and my dislikes which do not match with yours. And yes, I do have experience in the field of acting and directing but even without it a person can see things that are amiss with a typical India show.

So you are hurt by the comments, Eva? Goodness what are you and others going to do when you read critical analysis of your favorite movies, shows and articles about favorite stars? Will you shut down all modes of communication and assign yourselves the roles of dictorships and mind control authorities? 😕 You think by shutting me down you've saved your show and all things about it?

And so what if Binny won a Zeetv award? As if this is an award that measures acting talent - it's not like the Oscars, the Bafta or something you get from Cannes. It's popularitiy competition and by no means has any real basis on the acting skills. She was bound to win for the "new face" - it's not even an award that looks at acting. As for the other actress, no, I am not impressed. Not in the slightest.

It seems to me you are not very tolerant of any viewpoint unless it favors the show, and my "adverse" comments are not of your liking hence the reason you feel comfortable using "IF rules" to protect your favourite stars. You can't deny it. I do read the posts here.

Quote

Laila Banu

@Laila2009

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

#19

Originally posted by: Rjorge
Laila, genifan, nycsweetie and Jonaki,

After reading your posts, I am very concerned about the future of India Forums .. if bunch of critical and unhappy members like you regularly participate in discussions conducted by the intelligent members of the forum .... how can that forum survive .. I saved your posts in this thread without comments just so you do not alter or erase your nasty posts as I intend to report you to the moderators as you did not follow the forum rules by indulging into bashing and attacking the artists personally.

My perception after reading your posts is that members like you should be banned from IF because you will always be critical of these hard working artists ... your ban from the forum will save members like me from reading your ridiculously analyzed senseless critical posts ... please note that members like me prefer to encourage the talented artists by being positive about their work as I know they perform in the manner they are asked by the director of the show.

For your information:

Samta Sagar who was addressed by you as the "lady who plays Gauri's mother" .. in personal life Samta ji is a dignified beautiful lady and holds a Masters degree in Philosophy and her father was a renowned writer, she is very humble, sweet, down to earth and helpful individual and is a great poetess... professionally she is a very seasoned and highly sought after actress ... according to you she needs acting classes ... well if that was the case she would not be working in Sangini and would not be a part of the industry for the past 20+ years and not only that she works in soap operas she has also done theater, and only the talented ones can do both ... in America, where I am coming from, she is very popular and loved by Indians living in America for her work ... I got the above information about her after reading her interview published in a prestigious American paper ... I bet after this you have nothing bad to say about Samta ji.

Kunika Lal is the actress who plays the role of nani ... she is one of the most talented actresses in the industry ... if after Sudha ji anyone could play the role of nani it would be Kunika ji and for your information majority of viewers don't care how tall or short she is.

Binny Sharma she is not only beautiful but is a very sweet person, I have only read good things about her from the media articles..being a very new entry to the industry she has proved to be among the best ... not only that she is a graceful dancer, there is no doubt that she is a magical actress...the way she projects comfort in the scenes she plays in the presence of senior actors is just remarkable .... her recent award said it all about her talent.

I am sorry to say but you do not know where these talented artists are coming from so back off and do your research prior to bad mouthing these talented artists and keep your critical senseless and baseless views to yourself as I refuse to share them.

Heavens, I've seen some posts expressing intolerance but I rate yourse with the highest - five stars. Asking for people to be banned for expressing an alternative viewpoint on a show? And then asking those who "like" the posts to be banned as well? Just a note, I do have people who love my posts and email me regularly both here and on facebook. You can check my wall to find out. Moreover, you refer to others as "intelligent" which implies what about us? That only posts of your liking on or those that favor the show are worthy of being read and posted her? Yikes, that actually comes across as very arrogant.

I don't mind encouraging anyone, but I am not going to lie or pretend either. I have studied acting and directing and I do have friends (and relatives in this field). One of our close family friends happened to be the late Dr. Rahi Masoom Reza.

I do point out when I see something well-written, performed and directed. I do have contacts in this field as well. But even without these, a good post that critically examines a show or an actor etc, should never be banned even if it is of a show that I love or like.

As for your attempts to defend the actors in question. I would like to remind me that the actress who plays Gauri's mother was actually heavily criticised by the director himself and this article was published on India forums. Second, the attempts you've made are your opinions of the stars of the show These snippets offer me nothing regarding their acting. It includes nothing on their schooling, the school of thought on their acting, whose style they prefer, what they bring to a character etc. For example, where did they study, what techiques (such as Method, Stanislavski System etc). Watch Bravo's Inside the Actor's Studio for more.

Every actor wants to grow and a great actor is willing to hear EVERYTHING not just the comments that favor them and I do write what they're doing right and what I see them doing wrong. If anything. And believe me, if you are going to be one, you want to read EVERYTHING good and bad. As for not liking my posts - don't read them.

I don't read the ones I don't like either😃.

Quote

evasumi

@evasumi

Rocker

+ 6

Posted: 14 years ago

#20

@ Laila...

I did not mind your comment on the show or the character but only at the personal remarks on the actors and that is agianst the IF rules...

Who am I to shut you down.. This is an open forum and you are as much liberty to say things as I can.. I was just amazed the way you said all those personal remarks about the actors..

And great that you have experience in the directorship and in the body language but that does not give you any rights to use diminishing words to describe another people's skill..

this the the quote from your post..

"Plus the woman who plays Gauri's mother really needs to take some acting classes. She looks like she has gas everytime she looks distressed. Plus her lines are delievered in this monotone and flat sound."

Would you consider this writing as a decent one???? if you do than what can I say ... I am just speechless and wordless...

Edited by evasumi - 14 years ago