himesh VS sonu - Page 4

Well I notice now the new judges also have started saying "Mind Blowing, Fantastic" 😉

But they are right. The kids are getting better and better. I am also confused where they found so much talent. 😕

I really love the kids and I do not know why fight about the judges. 😕

i dont like both
but sonu has a great voice 😃

Originally posted by: miss.babli

i dont like both
but sonu has a great voice 😃

Forget the judges just look at the contestants. They are getting better.😉

Yeh kya SRGMP guzar jaane ki baad bhi HR ka bhoot idhar mandra raha hain?
Koi usko dhang se dafnado bhai? Bahut dar lagta hain, oooooooooooooo sunke🤢

Himesh Ji has never got the opportunity to become a judge, he has been a mentor. I have my reservation about mentors being called as judges.

In contrast , Sonu Nigam has the experience of being a judge in II2 and is now doing the same in Li' Champ -7.

sonu.. is the best judge after vishal shekhar

Originally posted by: Summer3

On this issue of comparison of judges we must also understand the competition format is different. In the SRGMP 07, the Producers wanted the Gharana leaders to argue and create a controversy and fight hard to justify their comments. Himeshji was the only one who really went out all the way. It was not a competition to go around and nicely say "Yes" "Yes" and smile with all people and be popular. In 05, ID staged a walk out and so did Vinit. In 07, Bappida did the same.

Please try to think out of the box. Do not be taken in by what you see on the screens as these are all preplanned just like a "wrestling match". Purpose was to raise the TRP in order to make more money for Zee.😉 that is why when I see all the drama and controversy I just laugh eventhough those around me all seem to be inflamed.😆😆

Even now the conroversy continues and I too continue to laugh.😆

But for Lil Champs Sonuji and Sureshji are in the same camp. The producers do not want to confuse the young kid and get them psychologically affected. It could be a legal problem too. Sonuji has been associated with SRGMP for many years and we should welcome him with open arms. Himeshji was only following the scipt where he had to raise some dust.😉

Though I agree with u that most of the controversy/drama was scripted by zee and enacted by himesh,I still feel that himesh carried his 'himeshness' too far.The drama might have been scripted ,but the self promotion & attitude of superiority which (i feel) he displayed was certainly not scripted in by Zee.I'm sure that was Himesh's own addition.In both C-05 and C-07 Himesh never wld praise any rival Gharan's candidate openly,however well they sang.There was also a restriction to his praise of of anyone except Vinit.

Whereas ppl like ID and VS praised rival singers more openly too.And I think Sonu is alos very staright forwrd with his comments and praises.His critisim doesn't destroy the confidence of the singer,he gives constructive critism .He also comes across as less biased/not biased(in II and in the shows where he has been a judge)........ just my two cents 😊

Originally posted by: abru07

Sonu Nigam is better than ANY other judge and I would prefer him ANY day. I don't want to comment on himesh's music career but as a judge I don't like him, he is either too hyper or aggressive. He doesn't portray the qualities of a 'judge'.
Sonu is the persona of the best judge; try comparing their comments about contestants. I mean sonu actually tells the singers their shortcomings by pointing them out and shows them the right way to sing without bashing their feelings, and promoting the show by calling out "his fans". Newcomers get to learn a lot from him..
Whereas himesh is so superficial and weird...He would always say "mind blowing, fantastic, superb, awesome"..

wait actually it was "fantastic, awesome, superb, mind blowing" yep that was the right order.. 😆

i totally agree.. haha

im new here.. ;p

i prefer Sonu Nigam because he's soooo encouraging.. 😉 😳
Himesh only judges the contestants by adjectives.. haha 😆

ok the result is out the poll is over Sonu Nigam wins now peace peace bachchon 😆 peace.Shaant ho jao.