For voting to a talent avoid nationality

I read in IF postings that Amanat got the least indian vote, out of four contestants and got 3rd position after merging international vote, I felt very bad for him . He has prooved his talent by singing,mohd rafi'song,hariharan,kishor kumar, sonu nigam pop song, bhojpuri song ,mukesh's, mannadey even lataji and parveen sultanaji's song etc, etc and prooved his versatility [that too singing indian songs] and in my view he is the best singer among all the three boys. [other's have been singing only in particular tonal zone .[and also their mentor make them to sing only in particular tonal zone and those who tried to sing other zonal were flopped badly] The public shd take note of this point and vote sincerly on the talent and performence not on their nationality. [I D has prooved that his dono contestant can sing all the tonal zones and these two amanat and poonam have also sang excellently]

.His nationality shd not be an issue. He is an aam aadmi from pakistan . Because it is public voting we take the rights to whom we like to vote and favouring them. talent shd be appreciated irresepective any country/nationality he belongs to.

I dont think his nationality is a problem, hes in the top four and maybe top three doesnt that say enough already, he is singing good, and if he keeps singing good, he will be safe.

please don't bring up such issue... one of them has to be in bottom, and being in Top 3 means a lot, only votes from pakistan can't make him in Top 3... once again, i would say its not an issue at all!!!
he has been in among top 3 almost all the time!!!

And also this topic should be in the spoilers section...

why is it so every time a pakistani singer in low position we cry about his nationality..when they are in top we feel that we are secular..so if amanat win than only india can prove its a secular country .If raja/aneek win than we are not secular we did not vote for amanat because he is pakistani. .what this hypocracy...if aneek or raja win we should feel guilty..people will vote for raja or aneek becasue their FAN feels that they are better singer not because they are indian...aam janta is not music pundit they like what they feel close to their heart..folk musician does not have much sur or taal but they are popular because because they are close to heart..please dont vote for amanat just because he is not indian vote for him only if you think he is the singer you like.

Originally posted by: hirni

why is it so every time a pakistani singer in low position we cry about his nationality..when they are in top we feel that we are secular..so if amanat win than only india can prove its a secular country .If raja/aneek win than we are not secular we did not vote for amanat because he is pakistani. .what this hypocracy...if aneek or raja win we should feel guilty..people will vote for raja or aneek becasue their FAN feels that they are better singer not because they are indian...aam janta is not music pundit they like what they feel close to their heart..folk musician does not have much sur or taal but they are popular because because they are close to heart..please dont vote for amanat just because he is not indian vote for him only if you think he is the singer you like.

Very well said my friend.If they were thinking of nationality Amanat would have gone long back to pakistan.Pl Indians loved his singing and he is where he is because they appreciated him.and voted for him.dont bring all those theories.

it is your imagination about nationality of a singer.
no one here is talking abou nationality.

Please lets avoid this nationality discrimination discussion. This has been already made clear by the Dev Team not to do so.

Why think of these contestants as Indians and Pakistani's. Why not just plain and simple contestants. If really this had been an issue in the mind of Indian public then today Amanat would not have reached this stage. He would have been eliminated long back.

Topic closed.


SRGMP Dev Team.