Popularity OR Singing contest?????!!!!!!! - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

1.3k

Users

11

Frequent Posters

JJESH thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#11
I'm not bashing anyone..I'm not against Mauli..I'm not fighting against her..but I'm always in favor of talent...it does not matter whether it is Mauli, Shrestha, Anita or Sarika. Every single song is always sings better by the orginal singers..there can not be any stupid argument about that..comparison between Shrestha and Runa Liala is just stupid...do you mean that Mauli sang Mayya mayya better than Maryam Toller???

They are all trainee...nobody is perfect..they can not sing their original songs..because they don't have any...how can you say something like.."Nobody wants to hear Dama Dum from Shesthra (sp?) when Runa and Abida can sing much better and with lot more gusto than her (or may be same) they have already done it..she is mere copy"........

Then why do you people go to orchrestra? Why do people buy Mp3 records of songs sang by varoius artists other than the original singers? Why do you listen to remix???

Edited by jhumapan - 18 years ago
amarendu thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: jhumapan

Looks like ZEE already has decided to make Mauli as winner...no matter how bad she sings....this is just so such unfortunate incident....all coward mentors....seems like Mauli has brain washed very well...She knew that IT IS JUST A CLEAR BIASED judgment...if she is already the "Shakira" of India then she does not need to win this competetion in a shameless way...this is just sheer hipocracy.....This program is loosing it's charm slowy...How can a program like Sa Re Ga Ma Pa comprise with Music? This is becoming a dictatorship program. ...

Zee is just doing this to maintain it's high TRP...because Mauli means dance and performance and focusing camera from bottom to top slowly and high TRP. If Zee continues to do so then people will turn TV on Friday-Saturday night to watch Amul Star voice of India not Sa re ga ma pa.

Now, all other contestants will be very scraed to perform when Mauli is there..because, it does not matter how well they perform Mauli will win always. It will be always partial. Somehow they want to help Mauli to reach final..because after that we all stupid janta will fall for her "performance" and vote for like what we did with Qazi..Right from the begining this year all mahagurus are repeating same mistakes. .Sarika, Anita, Shestha..and Zee is not doing anything about it..

HR asked Richa and forced her to say that she was not satisfied with the decision..why he didn't do that when Shestha was out??

👏👏Totally agree. The winner is already fixed, and we are actually being taken for a ride. If some photo-copier comment (rather declare) that Mauli is India's Shakira, who else should win a competition where there is Shakira????

The above highlighted portion (in black) hits it on the head. This is what I am trying to point out. Just for being politically correct, you cannot blame anyone here in this forum. This should be debated.

If some day you find a politicians amassing oodles of money, siding with the criminals, doing wrong things - you are better off saying nothing, or saying politically correct manner for whatever reasons (elders, seniors, respected, etc.)! Hope my analogy goes through.

Anuradha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: amarendu

There you go again. I PM-ed at length to Anu regarding this. IF moderators should have an internal debate about the future of this forum. I do not want to write it again, but seriously, do some serious re-thinking about the rule. A clean forum is fine, but a meek forum is not! Hope I get it across.



I think we have had round of discussion regarding the same.. If you have any problem, you are free to PM the dev team members.. Even questioning regarding the functioning of development team in the forum is against the rules..
Anuradha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: Sylik

I'm sorry but there should be freedom of speech. If you are not happy with the decision please lay it out. No rule can stop you from feeling how you feel.



You have the freedom of speech but we ask you only to properly utilize the freedom of speech given to you.. Attacking the contestants, mentors and other fellow members was never, is not and will never be encouraged in this forum..

Any further discussion on this will not be encouraged on this thread.. You have any queries, you can always PM the dev team members..

SRGMP Dev Team
Edited by Anu.Rad - 18 years ago
amarendu thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: Anu.Rad



I think we have had round of discussion regarding the same.. If you have any problem, you are free to PM the dev team members.. Even questioning regarding the functioning of development team in the forum is against the rules..

Yes, rules rule everywhere😃....we have to be law-abiding forum members, otherwise we will be thrown out. There's no competition to Microsoft you see! If there is one, fellow members, please let me know.

JJESH thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#16
I never meant to attack anymore on personal ground..I thought my argument was for the music and justice and I still believe that.
amarendu thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: jhumapan

I never meant to attack anymore on personal ground..I thought my argument was for the music and justice and I still believe that.

Agree with you. Honest members are being penalised....for the sake of cleanliness!

**Viewbie Note - The member is being warned for continously questioning about the functioning of the dev team and also passing sarcastic comments against them even after asking not to do so numerous number of times**

Edited by Anu.Rad - 18 years ago
zapman thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: amarendu

There you go again. I PM-ed at length to Anu regarding this. IF moderators should have an internal debate about the future of this forum. I do not want to write it again, but seriously, do some serious re-thinking about the rule. A clean forum is fine, but a meek forum is not! Hope I get it across.

I agree completely.....What I had written wasn't even so terrible (check your PM)!

Seems like you have to match the moderators biases, otherwise, you get this kind of warning!!

Barnali thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#19
Sorry Anu i am again opening the topic to make this post as i felt everyone who made posts against the dev team hav just not understood what Kothra was saying. 😊

Members we are not saying u cannot criticise anyone. Sure do so. but please use proper language. See that while doing so u are not making any personall attack on them.Thats what was done in this topic by few.

Also please when u are posting some issue do chk next few pages. its possible that someone had already posted on it and members are discussing it. so instead of starting a new topic on the same issue why not add your views to the already opened topic. 😊

We are doing this for your benefit.😊 This is being done just to keep the section look more tidy and systematic. we all consider the section as our second home so why not follow some basic rules that we usually follow in our home 😳

Even after this if anyone feels they need more explanation can always send us a PM and get it cleared. we'll be happy to help u out. 😃


Edited by Barnali - 18 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".