What's your opinion for this week's show - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

38

Views

2.4k

Users

27

Frequent Posters

mermaid_QT thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: chatbuster


seems to also take any criticism of his participants too personally. looks like he has a big chip on his shoulder, much like another lil four-footer napolean. 😉



😆😆😆

Originally posted by: chatbuster


for a 2nd week, i thought the show standard was pretty bad. i liked junaid the most, harpeet a close second and desh gaurav third best. i did find junaid's singing nasal but there was pathos in his singing. maybe it's more the song but whatever, he grabbed my attention. i found desh gaurav's voice soothing though harpreet was perhaps technically more brilliant. the girls, including poonam, were just so-so in terms of their singing.

on content i felt that both HR and asha had valid points- HR had the career advice, whereas she was more about grooming the talent. made sense from their perspective, though HR's would probably have to take a back-seat in a talent hunt. also, he needs to work on his style imo. as long as u have a judge, gotta respect their opinion. cant cut them off mid-sentence like he did with asha. seems to also take any criticism of his participants too personally. looks like he has a big chip on his shoulder, much like another lil four-footer napolean. 😉

overall, mediocre show.



i agree. I liked Junaid, harpreet, DG Musarrat and Poonam. The rest were ordinary. I liked harpreet the most. (oh wow, just found out he got green :) ) Most girls better stop squeaking and being pitchy, else it will be required for me to watch their performance in mute. Guys were better hands down. Ponam was good.
(CB's molly part was edited in quote, she looked nice IMO me today, much better than last time in fact)
I have hopes from the girl Bhappida chose for his new paduwan, ans also,
Himmy's Assami guy .

Edited by mermaid_QT - 18 years ago
mary2007 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#22
it was good, but lotssssssss of drama.... y HR screams so much... i feel so sorry for sd and Shekar
I_me thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#23
I liked the singing part of the second week - Mussarat was really good and I liked him from day 1. Enjoyed Mauli's singing too. Dunno if she will be good in other genres, but as of now, she is quite good and sings confidently. Liked Saberi Bhattacharya's song and her singing in in saturday's episode. The advices and arguments of the mentor(s) were useful too but it can be done in a proper way too, screaming part turned me off.
ydp1 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#24
Mauli:Not sure if she could sing other than that genre...She's good w that type but dont think she can pull off Shreya,Alka,Lata,etc. songs...

Mussarat:I think he will run out of Rahet Fateh Ali Khan songs...
Wonder what he will do when they have days dedicated to say d 80s,Sanjay Leela Bhansali,Subhash Ghai,Patriotic Songs,Bangra Songs,Indi Pop,Upbeat Songs,Love Songs,Songs by d late greats...u get d picture...


Harpreet:I kept hearing lil champ Sameer...even til now...

Poonam:She's really good,not to be underestimated at all!

Wish I could comment more but all I remember is Himesh screaming like a lunatic...
sareg thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#25
quickies
Himesh: I hate that he feels it required to sing everytime he has to elaborate a point, I feel he is self promoting, actually more of my dislike might be b'cos he sings and I dont like to hear him sing. He made some very valid points about establishing a genre first and then being versatile later, but I think we are not out to find a single genre singer here. If Ghulam Ali saab would have been present, maybe he would have taken exception to the RFAK comment by Himesh. Second time he has made a comment about a recognized singer.

Mussarat: I am not sure if he got saved by his second rendition of oldie song, the drama Himesh pulled today might have saved him.
Junaid was good today
Poonam was the best
not sure I thought Saberi was the one to leave, dont know why Amrita got the boot
Mauli has a lot of hype to her and she is proceeding in the path of Himani with the Richa Sharma/Sunidhi type songs and she is no Himani

Got to hear a different Himesh this time, Vishal was needling him and he got flustered, Shekhar is out there it seems to just look pretty. ID is the placater. missed Shaan I think the pretty boy host may not be able to rein in the egoistical mentors

Loved Ashaji's comment, I am the judge here, I can ask some repeat performances and nobody can say anything to me, not sure if it was intended towards Bappida or Himesh
*Jaya* thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#26
OK - I got ot watch the show only when ASVOI was going for breaks... and unfortunately, I think I could see only the worst parts of the show 😆

Mussarrat was shouting on the top of his voice in his song I dont know if singing a RFAK song means shouting though, RFAK would be too disheartened to see this 😭 and what was that Roti drama - For Gods sake, write some better scripts for these guys 😡

I also got to see the over-hyped Mauli Dave's performance... In short - she was bad! 😡 One - she seems to attempt only one genre of songs, and even fails in that! She had a very heavy nasal twang even yesterday (and I think that was not an Arabic song 😳), and whatever happened to any control on sur??🤔 I read that she got through to the next round! Just wondering, if the eliminated contestant was worse than her! 😕

I also caught up with the last part of Saberi's rendition of 'Ab jo kiye ho daata'.. I think, she chose a good song to match her voice and could do some justice to the song.. but not sure of how she performed in the higher and more soulful notes of the song, as did not listen to the complete song!
Prenz~13 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#27
Excessive drama in last weeks episode... 😛
HR is sure providing loads of entertainment.. 😆
Mauli was kinda disappointing after the initial hype..but shes not dat bad... 😳
Junaid Sheikh was awesum n Poonam was d surprise package 😃 ..she was gr88!! 😃
I guess dere'll be more wars between VS n HR if d producers try 2 cash in on dis "fight". 😛
Aditya was sooo cutee!!! 😳 😳 m falling for him completely!! 😳 😳 hes nt a bad host..Shaan was awesum ,but Aditya is sure doing a gud job..hes still new and i guess it'll take sum time to get into that host grind completely..but hes dun a gr8 job so far!! 👏 😳
Lastly, I loved Ashaji's comments..d entire.."main judge hoon..aur mujhe koi kuch nahin keh sakta" was gr88!!! 👏 😆 way to go Ashaji!! her decision to make Mussarat sing again was d best one, coz i feel Mussarat was much better in his second performance compared to d first...he was nowhere as gud as Rahet Fateh Ali Khans original song..
snowflake0555 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 18 years ago
#28
Overall the show was pretty good. The performences were better than last weeks...but not good good.

I liked Poonam's and Harpreet's performences. Poonam has a sweet nice voice. And OMG I was too busy looking at how tiny she is LOL! 😆 Harpreet's O Majji Re was great!

Mauli was OK. Didn't really liked her performence on Sat, but I think she covered that up yesterday. Liked her performence and facial expressions though. 😆

I actually liked Mussarat's singing. I don't think he is bad and he was a lot of potential. I think more likely he will improove...

Saaberi was OK. Same with Junaid.

The eliminations were fair.

The HR, Vishal, Asha, Mussarat thing...well let's just say HR was very entertaining. I was literally laughing the whole time watching him scream his head off. It was rude of him to interupt Ashaji but still...errr and Vishal asking for Mussarat to be put in his gharana

In conclusion, pretty OK episode...8/10 😛

Ohh and Aditya's performence was great as always LOL...he was lookin' soooooooooooooo cute! Couldn't stop looking at him lol... 😳 😆
Neetusxm thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#29
too much drama...
himesh is irritating... and too full of himself..
mauli is playin only on safe grounds
musharaf...needs to get out of nusrat fateh ali khan genre...

action packed episode...i was hooked.. 😆

neetu
sareg thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: Neetusxm

too much drama...
himesh is irritating... and too full of himself..
mauli is playin only on safe grounds
musharaf...needs to get out of nusrat fateh ali khan genre...

action packed episode...i was hooked.. 😆

neetu

sure, G.W. Bush also thinks so😆😆😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".