Clarification from your reporter - Page 16

Originally posted by: shadyhtown

I have also given you my reasons. And it is my personal opinion that this change hasn't beed good. I think I have the right to that opinion.

shady, today u may not like one mod and the next day someone may like the same mod... so, can we have one mod for each member?

Originally posted by: shadyhtown

I have also given you my reasons. And it is my personal opinion that this change hasn't beed good. I think I have the right to that opinion.

Oh of course you are entitled to your opinion..... but then, your opinion need not always be the RIGHT one, thats all I say.

Sometimes, you can be wrong too..... like you are, in your analysis of the Mohini incident. But then, I dont blame you either.

When you decide to only look at one point of view and assume that the other party is guilty before being tried, you will end up with results akin to that.

Originally posted by: shadyhtown

Priya - with these questions, you force me to be direct, and so I will.

I had hopes that Vijay would bring some change. He assured me he would, and I was satisfied with that response and waited. I kept quiet for 2 days and let time run its course.

Then when I asked Vijay about why certain members were banned - he gave me an answer which I don't believe. I don't believe it because it happened only with 5-6 specific members, on a specific date, right after a particular Goodbye thread. And it only happened with the people who were planning on leaving the forum.

That is too much coincidence for me - and no, I don't believe the explanation was honest. I would have kept quiet if I had gotten an honest answer, even if the reason for blocking was unjustified.

Shady, the speculations of your mind cannot be reality.

And you do not know about the rest of the Forum, just SRGMP section.

As I told you above, you think it is coincidence, so be it.... you are entitled to your thoughts, but then, it is not neccessary that you are right. Just explore the possibility that there is a chance that you can be wrong too, after all, you are human and to err is human.

Originally posted by: adi_0112

Shady..how can u even conclude a case when you have not spoken to the person involved?

Doesn't a case entail the statements of both the parties? Are you aware of what transpired after these so called witnesses left? are u aware of someother witnesses that I can produce who will tell u a different story are u aware whatbtranspired for 3 dasys after that on Pm's are you aware of what all also happened after that?

How can you conclude without being aware of these fact?

A case hjas witnesses from from sides..I do not see any witnesses from the other side..

Can u trell me why..this is only a one sided story?

Adi - I have interacted with Mohini, who told me she didn't do anything of the sort. I have proof in the form of the posts, like I said.

I have also interacted with Bhaskar. From what he told me, and what the other 3 members told me, it was clear that Bhaskar was not honest. The specific message that Mohini allegedly told him on PM, Bhaskar said she told him on the forum. But the other 3 neutral members can guarantee that she did not say that on the forum at the time Bhaskar said she did.

For more details, you can PM me and I will forward you what Bhaskar told me, because I don't want to bring the Viewbie's name up in this thread.

Sorry again for being direct - but all your questions leave me with no choice.

Originally posted by: s.priya

Oh of course you are entitled to your opinion..... but then, your opinion need not always be the RIGHT one, thats all I say.

Sometimes, you can be wrong too..... like you are, in your analysis of the Mohini incident. But then, I dont blame you either.

When you decide to only look at one point of view and assume that the other party is guilty before being tried, you will end up with results akin to that.

Priya - I was not the only one unhappy with Ms. BB. Other members were too, as you can see. So we all are wrong, and only the dev team is right. Yes?

Originally posted by: shadyhtown

Priya - I was not the only one unhappy with Ms. BB. Other members were too, as you can see. So we all are wrong, and only the dev team is right. Yes?

How do you decide who is good and who is not good??? And the other member on the thread felt Ms. BB is not speaking in friendly tone and she compared MY friendly tone with that of Ms. BB. Now we all know in this section, during your last survey, how much and more was spoken about US. Rita said she is new to the forum and she will independently make up her mind.

And in so far as you being wrong and DEV TEAM is right - OH well, I wont be so drastic. All I say is you may be wrong and another MEMBER of IF may be right. Wrong and Right can co exist. And wrong and right are always perceptions of the mind and nothing is ever always wrong or always right.

Originally posted by: shadyhtown

Priya - I was not the only one unhappy with Ms. BB. Other members were too, as you can see. So we all are wrong, and only the dev team is right. Yes?

Right or wrong I may not be the right person to decide. But one thing is sure here Shady. Unless the Dev Team say and go by exactly what you all ask us to we are wrong. Whatever we may say or do we are wrong.

Vijay yesterday replied to all your queries. But you feel he was not telling the truth. We show you PM's again you feel we are telling tales about them.

I think it's useless continuing this argument now. I feel it's simply useless. Because finally you will never believe what we say.

Originally posted by: vijay

Well Shady I am sure in that case I feel that all our members are quite smart, intelligent and courage to fight for themselves. The kind of talent pool IF has is certainly enviable. I can get thousands of IF members to testify this fact. Would you like to try it out?

Please do not try to divide the forum by calling certain members as "underdogs".

Cheers,
Vijay

Shady, it appears that you did miss out this post of Vijay. Bumping it up for you.

allow others to fight their causes.

and yes, do not try to divide the forum.

Originally posted by: shadyhtown

Adi - I have interacted with Mohini, who told me she didn't do anything of the sort. I have proof in the form of the posts, like I said.

I have also interacted with Bhaskar. From what he told me, and what the other 3 members told me, it was clear that Bhaskar was not honest. The specific message that Mohini allegedly told him on PM, Bhaskar said she told him on the forum. But the other 3 neutral members can guarantee that she did not say that on the forum at the time Bhaskar said she did.

For more details, you can PM me and I will forward you what Bhaskar told me, because I don't want to bring the Viewbie's name up in this thread.

Sorry again for being direct - but all your questions leave me with no choice.

Error number One : Mohini started the trouble with me.You did not contact me or talk to me/

error number two : how can you guarantee the witnesses are neutral witnesses?

Error number three : how many of these witnesses are actual members of that forum where it happened.

error number four : I have personally had issues on Pm's with her for the next 3 days. Were u aware of that.

error number five : A neutral witness just the day before appreciated the Q& A openly in a forum and praised us. NExt day turns table.Can we call it neutral

error number six : The viewbie of that section , was her report on this taken? Was the report of feed bacik of that section mederator taken?

error number seven : Can one make allegation based on some witnesses speaking only one thing but when the other opinion of other witnesses have not been taken into consideration??

error number eight: What gives you the liberty to decide who is honest and who is dishonest ?

How can a verdict be passed on speculation?

Originally posted by: s.priya

Shady, it appears that you did miss out this post of Vijay. Bumping it up for you.

allow others to fight their causes.

and yes, do not try to divide the forum.

Priya - how can Vijay assume, that I was referring to the forum members as underdogs??

Is my life only restricted to this forum - no it's not. Some examples of underdogs I supported are Debojit, Zimbabwe Cricket Team, Himesh Reshammiya (in the case).

Please clarify things with me before placing such allegations.