DOTW - SRGMP Contests: Who should judge? - Page 12

haha.. dolly, thanks for selecting me as the judge. itne din baad ayee ho, am glad to find u in such an agreeable mode 😆

Originally posted by: chatbuster

haha.. dolly, thanks for selecting me as the judge. itne din baad ayee ho, am glad to find u in such an agreeable mode 😆

thank you rahul for welcome. iam always in a agreeable mode ....you know that dont you 😉 😆

Originally posted by: charades

Topic is Can veiwers and Judges needs to have equal say in the result....

Jaya,


Platform is set by Zee...Rules are Set by Gajji...

Viewers and Judges were never part of framing the rules they just follow those

And we are asking Gajji to only change rules...

Again please don't bring the topic of many guys getting recognised, money, sponsorship and all that stuff into picture....

Unfortunately this weeks course is very narrow and we have to stay on course..

If you want to bring those over and over again then we are getting nowhere is all I can say....

I have given my thoughts on why public should not be included which is based on the mess they have created last 4 times.......

VJ - I think the week's course is definitely not narrow, and by attaching the result just to the winner, some of us are making it narrow....😕

The reason why I have to repeat the same thing so many times is just to stress that the thing has to be seen in totality...

If we cannot see the thing in totality, of course we are not going to reach anywhere and will keep repeating stuff.. So first we possibly need to see eye-to-eye on what the subject wants to target. Me being the topic initiator knows for sure that is what I had in mind..😊 Now its upto you or anyone else to think your way.

At the end of the day - To each his won 👍🏼

Originally posted by: charades

Whomsoever may be the judges you appoint CB....
even siddhu is fine with me 😉

Worst case what happens another bad judgement, where we have digested 4, don't u think we have appetite for another one I think we do. 😉

abhi aadat ho gayi hein ...paet ko assa khana khanae ki .atleast then we can say it is judge not public 😆..phir ek naya debate topic hoga 😆

I feel we can never have a perfect judgement weither it is done by public or Judges.The Judges have the same biases as the common man.If out of two judges one become biased, that is equivalent to half of Indian Public becoming biased in public voting context..

The public is usually under estimated regarding their judging abilities.Public may not know the technicalities of the music but they are very good at judging the total impact.If it feels good to the ears, it is good..

I feel it is the public who is judging the music every day.Absolute good ones do survive, examples include Sonu and Udit..A refreshing ordinary voice is also appreciated..A different voice is also given a chance..

you can have a good judgement with judges, with public voting..or combination of the two...but you can never have a perfect judgement..If Nihira was the winner in C2005, lot of people will have objected to it and may have sided with Himani..just my 2 cents 😃

Originally posted by: Sur_Sangam

I feel we can never have a perfect judgement weither it is done by public or Judges.The Judges have the same biases as the common man.If out of two judges one become biased, that is equivalent to half of Indian Public becoming biased in public voting context..

The public is usually under estimated regarding their judging abilities.Public may not know the technicalities of the music but they are very good at judging the total impact.If it feels good to the ears, it is good..

I feel it is the public who is judging the music every day.Absolute good ones do survive, examples include Sonu and Udit..A refreshing ordinary voice is also appreciated..A different voice is also given a chance..

you can have a good judgement with judges, with public voting..or combination of the two...but you can never have a perfect judgement..If Nihira was the winner in C2005, lot of people will have objected to it and may have sided with Himani..just my 2 cents 😃

Well said, Sur_Sangam! 👏👏👏 I especially agree with the bolded parts!

Originally posted by: jayc1234

VJ - I think the week's course is definitely not narrow, and by attaching the result just to the winner, some of us are making it narrow....😕

The reason why I have to repeat the same thing so many times is just to stress that the thing has to be seen in totality...

If we cannot see the thing in totality, of course we are not going to reach anywhere and will keep repeating stuff.. So first we possibly need to see eye-to-eye on what the subject wants to target. Me being the topic initiator knows for sure that is what I had in mind..😊 Now its upto you or anyone else to think your way.

At the end of the day - To each his won 👍🏼

jaya,

" the topic is SAREGAMAPA- who should judge"

and this show is a music talent show in which you bring contestents from different walks..on a big stage..Its main focus cannot and should not be of buissness and money making only. It should be getting a desrved one a winner ..by the one who knows better. what you are saying is a microscopic part of this debate . yes you are the initiater of the debate and it could be in your mind but i donnt see that coming from your hand on keyboard to the forum 😉

Originally posted by: dolly

Its main focus cannot and should not be of buissness and money making only. It should be getting a desrved one a winner ..by the one who knows better. what you are saying is a microscopic part of this debate .

And again - the main focus is not money making, neither is it getting one deserving winner who gets lost into oblivion. The main focus has to promote and launch 'sustainable' talent. That is the bigger picture....😊

I guess restricting it to find the winner is actually making it a microscopic viewpoint, and not the other way round 👍🏼

Originally posted by: charades

Whomsoever may be the judges you appoint CB....
even siddhu is fine with me 😉

Worst case what happens another bad judgement, where we have digested 4, don't u think we have appetite for another one I think we do. 😉

oh thx. i'll keep sidhu as my assistant then- parrot can fill-in the gaps when i am too bored to yap.😆

as for the case of indigestion, yaar there is no problem that cannot be solved without a daily intake of immodium. khana ke saath immodium is a must. kabhie socha hai?😉

btw, i found all the judgments in c2005 and emaet good. public did a wonderful job. better than the judges. much better 😉

Originally posted by: jayc1234

The main focus has to promote and launch 'sustainable' talent. That is the bigger picture....😊

jaya,

what exactly is promote and launch "sustaianable talent"....

for sustaiable talent you have to have sustaiable voice..after the contacrt will be over and these guys and girls will be in real world then we will have to see if they have sustained...