Restructuring Saregamapa for 2006 - Page 13

Hi all of you:

I have read all the comments by all of you. One thing we should never forget is RESPECT OF OTHERSWe should not call names to anyone. Everyone has right to their opinion. In my opinion Ismail Darbar used to be very fair. After Nihira was voted out(which is a shame for that particuler time)he started acting unfair. I think when final 6 were left, they were all the best and at that time Debu was singing at the bottom of all 6. He has definitely improved but he is no batter than Hemachandra at all. I agree with the name and where the contestants are from is not to be announced. We are hunting for the Voice of India and that should be the best singer. This should not be voted on emotions but truly on the talent. Put aside whose Guru is saying what. I think that Debu is no comparison to Hema. This is the bottom line.

All judges should have their eyes covered (like Gandhari in Mahabharat) so that they can avoid seeing participant dancing and focus on their singing prowess!
😊

Saw the episode where singers Shreya, Sunidhi, Kunal and others came to judge Vinit and Debo.

By what standard of judgement, they gave both Vinit and Debo 10/10 is something that still mystifies me. But on 2nd thoughts when I remember the threatening looks on Himesh's face ("Look guys, you give Vinit anything less than 10 and I will see that you are wiped out from the film industry!"), I can guess why all the judges played safe (being singers they needed to be in the good books of MDs to get future songs).

Powerful politics at work here!

yes i agree they shd improve the standard of judgement

👏

Originally posted by: punjini

You bet the logistics of live auditions can make people go crazy. Each singer is barely given a minute to sing and that too after waiting 7 hours or so in a queue. Can any singer give his/her best in such condtions?

Well said PUNJINI....👏👏👏

Originally posted by: genuity

Hi all of you:

I have read all the comments by all of you. One thing we should never forget is RESPECT OF OTHERSWe should not call names to anyone. Everyone has right to their opinion. In my opinion Ismail Darbar used to be very fair. After Nihira was voted out(which is a shame for that particuler time)he started acting unfair. I think when final 6 were left, they were all the best and at that time Debu was singing at the bottom of all 6. He has definitely improved but he is no batter than Hemachandra at all. I agree with the name and where the contestants are from is not to be announced. We are hunting for the Voice of India and that should be the best singer. This should not be voted on emotions but truly on the talent. Put aside whose Guru is saying what. I think that Debu is no comparison to Hema. This is the bottom line.

I RESPECT UR FEELING, BUT THIS TOPIC IS "Restructuring Saregamapa for 2006".

PLEASE GIVE SUGGESTION TO IMPROVE IT.

Originally posted by: msr_usa

All judges should have their eyes covered (like Gandhari in Mahabharat) so that they can avoid seeing participant dancing and focus on their singing prowess!
😊

GOOD SUGESTION, LETS TRY ON HR.........

SRGMP has definitely brought a craze for music, good or bad. It's amusing that some kids are being made to learn music so that they can compete in SRGMP. Not exactly the right nurturing needed for classical music to make a grand comeback but at least it won't die in the next generation!

You mean the topic is getting a little too boring?

Thanks and happy birthday to you!