Debojit is in TOP 2 from Neutral Zone too

Here is the final vote tally :

North South East West Total

Debojit 5.5 1.17 34.47 9.88 50.04

Vineet 18.08 2.02 4.87 19.08 45.06

Hem 2.08 17.09 2.19 10.06 30.15

Total 25.66 20.28 41.53 39.02 128.49

First let me clear the misconceptions(deliberate?) Himesh and Aadesh have regarding Neutral Zone. For each candidate Neutral Zone is the zones from which he does not belong to. So for Debojit the Neutral zones are North, South and West. Same for Vinit and Hem are South, East, West and North, East, West respectively.

Here is the vote tally in the Neutral Zone for each contestant.

Debojit : 5.5(North) + 1.17(South) + 9.88(West) = 16.55(Total)

Hem : 2.08(North) + 2.19(East) + 10.06(West) = 14.33(Total)

Vinit : 2.02(South) + 4.87(East) + 19.08(West) = 25.97(Total)

So the rankings are

Vinit

Debojit

Hem

So why were you complaining Aadesh??? Debo is in the final according to your logic too. Don't try to fool the audience...you will not be able to do that.

Here is another analysis. Most of the Vinit lovers(Bachcha party) are complaining about the huge no. of votes received by Debojit from NE. Here
is my analysis:

Debojit got 34.47 lakh votes out of total 41.53 lakh votes from East Zone i.e. 83% of the East Zone votes go to Debojit.

Vinit got 18.08 lakh votes out of total 25.66 lakh votes from North Zone i.e. 71% of the North Zone votes go to Vinit.

Hem got 17.09 lakh votes out of total 20.28 lakh votes from South Zone i.e. 84% of the South Zone votes go to Hem.

If you analyze the above statistics...you will find that voting pattern is very much the same...i.e. a huge percentage of votes from North/South/East are going towards their home contestant. The only difference is that Debojit is able to inspire his home crowd to vote more in numbers than the other two contestants thats why number of votes he receive from East Zone is more...but the percentage is more or less the same. Hem may not be able to do that because South Indians in general do not watch Hindi channels...but Vinit, in spite of being from Hindi belt, if fail to do so then he should admit that openly rather than performing a stupid walkout in protest. Vinit, if you fail to inspire your home crowd...don't dare to point your finger to Debojit who is a great inspiring factor to his home crowd.

A different view can be:

Debu got 34.47 of his total 50.04 lakhs vote (69.4 % from his hometown)
Hemu got 17.09 of his total 30.15 lakhs vote (56.6 % from his hometown)
Vinit got 18.08 of his total 45.06 lakhs vote (40.1 % from his hometown)

Can someone conclude something?

So what you what to prove that hemachandra is weaker than debo and vinit?????Just damn on this public voting....It means that vinit is much much better singer because he is getting more vote from western zone which is a neutral even even greater than his home zone.....

According to mentors neutral zone is west in which vinit got highest ,second was hema and third was debu

Originally posted by: Sarkar

According to mentors neutral zone is west in which vinit got highest ,second was hema and third was debu

Mentors are wrong because

For each candidate Neutral Zone is the zones from which he does not belong to. So for Debojit the Neutral zones are North, South and West. Same for Vinit and Hem are South, East, West and North, East, West respectively.

Originally posted by: sujay1974

Mentors are wrong because

For each candidate Neutral Zone is the zones from which he does not belong to. So for Debojit the Neutral zones are North, South and West. Same for Vinit and Hem are South, East, West and North, East, West respectively.

U SAY MENTORS R WRONG THAN R U RITE. NEUTRAL ZONE IS WEST WHERE VINIT N HEMU GOT MAX COMPARED TO DEBO.

Originally posted by: c_chan_chandan

So what you what to prove that hemachandra is weaker than debo and vinit?????Just damn on this public voting....It means that vinit is much much better singer because he is getting more vote from western zone which is a neutral even even greater than his home zone.....

I am certainly not trying to prove that...and this show is also not trying to decide who is the better singer(from agni pariksha round onwards). As the show has gone on to public voting (which depends on too many things other than singing talent)...they are actually trying to find out who is the most popular singer. HR has figured out from the very beginning ...thats why he has started all the topi, girl friend, maa etc. etc. drama for vinit to raise the curiosity among the general public so that his votes increases. Its real pity that some of us has not yet figured this out and hence after each elimination try to read the verdict as the person eliminated is lacking in singing.

Only future can tell us who is a better singer...not the result of this show.

Originally posted by: bveer

A different view can be:

Debu got 34.47 of his total 50.04 lakhs vote (69.4 % from his hometown)
Hemu got 17.09 of his total 30.15 lakhs vote (56.6 % from his hometown)
Vinit got 18.08 of his total 45.06 lakhs vote (40.1 % from his hometown)

Can someone conclude something?

Debojit : 30.6%(outside his home zone) = 16.55 Lakh votes

Hem : 44.4% (outside his home zone) = 14.33 Lakh votes

Vinit : 59.9% (outside his home zone) = 25.97 Lakh votes

Number of vote matters more than the %

Originally posted by: gvnls

U SAY MENTORS R WRONG THAN R U RITE. NEUTRAL ZONE IS WEST WHERE VINIT N HEMU GOT MAX COMPARED TO DEBO.

Hi gvnls,

Why only West Zone is neutral??? West Zone is neutral for all the contestants but

Why North and South are not neutral zones for Debojit?

Why East and South are not neutral zones for Vinit?

Why East and North are not neutral zones for Hem?

Can you or anyone please explain?

Originally posted by: sujay1974

I am certainly not trying to prove that...and this show is also not trying to decide who is the better singer(from agni pariksha round onwards). As the show has gone on to public voting (which depends on too many things other than singing talent)...they are actually trying to find out who is the most popular singer. HR has figured out from the very beginning ...thats why he has started all the topi, girl friend, maa etc. etc. drama for vinit to raise the curiosity among the general public so that his votes increases. Its real pity that some of us has not yet figured this out and hence after each elimination try to read the verdict as the person eliminated is lacking in singing.

Only future can tell us who is a better singer...not the result of this show.

I agree....this show is the hunt of most popular singer only and not the most talented singer....This is the agony of these popular musical show bi it saregama or indian idol....

And also agreed that the future only will tell who amongst is the best....So lets not fight on these pitty things i mean the regionalism...love....and debo's drama of making her maa's dream fullfilled....