Debojit is in TOP 2 from Neutral Zone too - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

39

Views

3k

Users

28

Frequent Posters

sujay1974 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: viper8234

I dont think ppl here know what neutral means....

Pls. explain if you know that

biswita thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: c_chan_chandan

So what you what to prove that hemachandra is weaker than debo and vinit?????Just damn on this public voting....It means that vinit is much much better singer because he is getting more vote from western zone which is a neutral even even greater than his home zone.....

There's a simpler explanation...watch the Rday episode when Hema forgets the lines of his first song...that's a no no in a SRGM final. Again I repeat I still think he's great.

In case you don't know, Nihira was in SRGM 3 yrs ago. She kept winning and winning, and only lost when she forgot the words on stage

biswita thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#13
I've never stressed out over mentor drama...I think their dialogues are written by GS. More drama, more ads.

I strongly feel contestants cannot be held responsible for their senior mentors actions.

Notice the hangdog expression on Vinit's face when HR started his affair drama. If we are annoyed, think how he must feel on stage.

ID is no less. Walkouts, mother's dream, working wife etc. But noone blames Debo. Why fault Vinit?

Message to all...concentrate on the performances.
mskanth thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#14
First of all, I am happy for Hema. He starts his career a couple of weeks ahead of the others. 😊

Secondly, I dont buy Adesh's proposal to change to rule now. Many candidates have been eliminated so far with the same rule. It is only a moral victory for one or the other.

With that said, it is difficult to determine a neutral zone. Each of us can come up with our own reasoning. One would call North + South + West zones as neutral for Debo. While the major chunk of votes from North and South are casted lopsided to the home candidates, it is difficult to consider the rest and compare them. A neutral zone is something where there is no candidate hailing. Again, this is my reasoning.

Secondly, the originator and some others tried to compare the percentages of votes. As we are comparing the actual numbers, we cannot consider percentages either. Vinit, Hema and Debo might have received close to 70% of their home zone votes but the same percentage out of the total votes casted makes a huge difference.

These statistics dont make much of difference as Hema is already out. I am sure there will be similar discussions after the final.

The makers need to take a closer look at these issues while formulating the next round of SRGMP.
Ramsay thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#15
Hello Sujay1974 I d't know what u want to prove from ur post. Every body agreed that Debo & vinit in the finals, why d't u try to come with another post,if u want to really appreciate Debojit.

What happed in the past just ignore it .. lets see coming episode to know another public voting drama.

lets cheer Up for Hemu for his bright future.
fm_qazi thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: c_chan_chandan

So what you what to prove that hemachandra is weaker than debo and vinit?????Just damn on this public voting....It means that vinit is much much better singer because he is getting more vote from western zone which is a neutral even even greater than his home zone.....

Chill man, take it easy. He is not proving Hema wrong, he is proving AS as cheater who cheats the public with absurd logic.

Kruts thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: bveer

A different view can be:

Debu got 34.47 of his total 50.04 lakhs vote (69.4 % from his hometown)
Hemu got 17.09 of his total 30.15 lakhs vote (56.6 % from his hometown)
Vinit got 18.08 of his total 45.06 lakhs vote (40.1 % from his hometown)

Can someone conclude something?

Yes, that people all over India are consistently liking Vinit more than Debo or Hema, not only the people from his own "region" or "zone"; You forgot to mention that almost 50% of the people in the common neutral zone...aka west zone voted for Vinit...and trust me, right now people are voting for Vinit IN SPITE of HR.

By the way, some people have mentioned it in other posts...ID is also gujarati and has actually admitted that on TV waaaaay more than HR has. So ideally, Debo should have received more votes than 10/25 lakhsfrom West Zone 😕. I think that West zone results only are neutral results so as to speak.

Anyways, i personally couldnt care less about who wins between Debo and Vinit...

simranlaks_2005 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: biswita


There's a simpler explanation...watch the Rday episode when Hema
forgets the lines of his first song...that's a no no in a SRGM final. Again I
repeat I still think he's great.


In case you don't know, Nihira was in SRGM 3 yrs ago. She kept winning
and winning, and only lost when she forgot the words on stage

[/
QUOTE]


In case you didn''t realize even Debojit and Vinit have made mistakes and
forgot lines, so your logic does not stand.
Edited by simranlaks_2005 - 19 years ago

usa123 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#19
I think Hemachandra is/was the best. But now since he is out I want Debo to win as I feel HR and Vinit dont seem humble on TV. In fact they act as if they the best,very very proud.
onlyinindia thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#20
great analysis!!!!

I especially like the part that Vineet got 74% of votes from the north. Why were AS and HR crying about Debojit getting 80% of votes from the East❓

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".