Why ID never praised Hema ?

I'm a big fan of ID.

At the same time, I am a big fan of Hema.

Correct my if I am wrong but I have never seen one sincere appreciation by ID for Hema's singing. He never criticized his singing but he never applauded his singing either the way he did for the likes of VS, Himani etc. I wonder why ?

I've always liked ID for not being biased towards his own contestants. This guy has me confused.

Id had not given any performance which can be praised. Even his mentor did not praise him. He always sang simple song which suits for his thick voice.

Id had not given any performance which can be praised. Even his mentor did not praise him. He always sang simple song which suits for his thick voice.

I'm sorry but I completely disagree with you.
There are several commendable performances that Hema gave. And AS has praised Hema's original voice and his unique singing style quite a few times, not so much as he did for Himani but still.
Thick Voice ???? What does it mean anyway ?

Originally posted by: fm_qazi

Id had not given any performance which can be praised.
Even his mentor did not praise him. He always sang simple song which suits
for his thick voice.

I believe you have never heard Hema sing or know the songs - you are just
blindly following someone ...

you may like some other contestant but do not belittle others!!!

The fact is that while Hema impressed all with his excellent voice quality and grip over sur and taal, he never really showed us his full range. I blame his mentor whose fixation with Himani was obvious to all.

Agree with Raghav64..

But saathiya and Bumroo were mind blowing

Originally posted by: Jeddah_Boy

well ... fm_qazi is right ... i m with u fm_qazi .. i dont think so that chindichor had gave any performance like debu and vinit ... so hu diserves get gud comments from mentors ... and i must say that ID ne kabhi Debujeet ko bhi itna praise nahi kia jitna HR and AS apne contestants ko karte the ... itna ziyada hype karna acha nahi hota man ... or jesa ke aap sab ne dekha hoga ke HR and AS ne kabhi apne contestant ko unki ghalti par nahi daanta balke ID ya JL ke contestant ki ghalti par unko unki ghalti ka ehsas dilaya .. to sorry ye sab baten achi nahi hen ... everybody knows ke ID ne hamesha acha gane wale ki tareef ki or ghalat gane wale ko uska ehsas dilaya chahe wo ID gharane ka hee Q na ho ... got it ! ! !

i luv ur avi...atif aslam iz soo hot!!

well he ahs gotten me confused too. he claims to be unbiased especially of late but i'm sorry to say ID i think u r very biased towards hema. he ahs given him a lot of high scores but not once did he take the trouble of throwing a compliment his way. may b this is ID 's way of discouraging and demeaning hema. he probably thinks it will affect his confidence or votes... if so than ovbiously his plan hasn't been very successful till now.
or may b each time hema sings, IlD is so awed by his performance that he wished he was his student instead of adesh'.
may b he fears that since hema has always been a notch higher than debu, if he praises him, it will b unfair to debu, his shagird. y did he praise himani us ask? he thought it wont have any affect as according to him it was very ovbious that nihira was a notch higher amond the gals. why vinit?.... cuz gajji pays him to 😛
if it is none of the above, than its just that ID has serious hearing issues.

Originally posted by: prat29

I'm sorry but I completely disagree with you.
There are several commendable performances that Hema gave. And AS has praised Hema's original voice and his unique singing style quite a few times, not so much as he did for Himani but still.
Thick Voice ???? What does it mean anyway ?

i agree w/ u hemus voice quality is one of its kind