Why ID never praised Hema ? - Page 2

because he never found hema to be worthy of any praise or appreciation maybe
this is the only way u can explain this

Originally posted by: prat29

I'm a big fan of ID.

At the same time, I am a big fan of Hema.

Correct my if I am wrong but I have never seen one sincere appreciation by ID for Hema's singing. He never criticized his singing but he never applauded his singing either the way he did for the likes of VS, Himani etc. I wonder why ?

I've always liked ID for not being biased towards his own contestants. This guy has me confused.

Prat 29, U r wrong, I think u have not seen today's srgmp sunday 22/01/06 10 am to 6.00 pm [no stop programme that is first episode to 8th episode of agnipariksha] in the fourth round ID praised hemu that this boy has bright future and you will go till the final top. I am sure.. This is the word he used for hema ,how come u missed this .Unlike other mentors ID is the only mentor who praise whole heartdly to the deserving challenger irrspective of any gharana.

ismail neva praised hema cuz hemaz songs din touch ismails heart..

Originally posted by: fm_qazi

Id had not given any performance which can be praised. Even his mentor did not praise him. He always sang simple song which suits for his thick voice.

dont be so biased..........u better go check ur ears.......he have tried difficult n different songs every time...........b4 agni paraksha every1 used to praise him a lot..he got straight greens..every1 praised him including ID, HR, JL.......it just happened after agni paraksha.....they were just too scared to praise hemu................all the guests who have came i.e. kunal gunjawala, dia miraza , imran etc etc etc ..they all praised him......u better go check ur ears

Originally posted by: sadaf84

dont be so biased..........u better go check ur ears.......he have tried difficult n different songs every time...........b4 agni paraksha every1 used to praise him a lot..he got straight greens..every1 praised him including ID, HR, JL.......it just happened after agni paraksha.....they were just too scared to praise hemu................all the guests who have came i.e. kunal gunjawala, dia miraza , imran etc etc etc ..they all praised him......u better go check ur ears

Well said. fm_qazi check your brain too in addition to your ears. Well anyway, if ur screen name is based on Qazi from FG, then we shouldn't be expecting any music sense (or any other sense from you).. Right??

[quote]ismail neva praised hema cuz hemaz songs din touch ismails heart.. [/quote]

lolzzz tit for tat.

Even though Ismailji never praised Hemu, I don't think he underestimates Hemu's talent. May be there is no interaction between these two off the sets.

Maybe he is rendered speechless every time Hema delivers his song, he is clean bowled by his voice and performance 😉
Never mind guys, does it really matter.
If some says mind blowing, suberb and gives 10, does that stop the contestent from getting eliminated.
Or for that matter if they do not give any words of praise and give 4 or 6 or 8, does the contestent get eliminated?
At this point the mentometer or the pearls of wisdom from the mentors is not really a driving factor- MHO, unless it boosts the performer to give a brilliant performance.
Looks like Hema's(since we are talking about him) performance is not affected in any way, so let it be, again my opinion only.

HR would have cut a deal with ID that if ID not give any recognition to Hema and praise only Vinit, they will make Vinit and Nihira winners.
HR would have cut a second deal with AS that AS underplay his appreciations for Debo and they could make Vinit and Himani winners.
Its all too evident that Gadhji has become HR's puppet.. HR would have instructed Gadhji to edit any praises showered by guests on Hema...

I remember that even in SLB's episode, Hema was nowhere to be seen neither we came to know what SLB's comment was after he sang.. Even Amritha Rao's request to Hema to sing one more song was cut. Somebody here mentioned that Gadhji has always shown his eagerness to eliminate South Indians from the contest. Perhaps Gadhji thought even a very mild +Ve recognition to Hema could tilt the vote phenominally towards him and so staying clear.

Finally, this is all just my analysis.

Originally posted by: cashmoney

ismail neva praised hema cuz hemaz songs din touch ismails heart..

Ur talking BS....😡 Did u see SRGMP non-stop...in several occasions he has backed the contestants from other gharanas including Jatin-lalits gharana and U r commenting that he never supported...infact he is the only fellow who backed each and every contestant...have u seen how he gives the marks to guys frm other gharanas...watch the video and then talk...just dont talk BS😡