Sa Re Ga Ma Pa - THE SHOW CONTINUES... :) - Page 56

Originally posted by: sunil_bang

...for those who haven't seen SAREGEMAPA earlier, Debu have beaten Vineet fair and square, that's how he became wild card contestent in challehe 2005, no voting, no Assam, no ULFA, judges were Pundit Jasraj, Chitra, Biddu, he did it once with is talent and he will do it again with public support.

Originally posted by: Soniya.

Over here, in toronto, episodes air a bit late. I JUST saw the episode in which Himani gets voted out. Shocking thing is though, Ismail D didnt say a single word to her, despite the fact she apologized to him and everyone for what she, vinit, and hema did.

Personally, i think Himesh and Aadesh put them up to do this tedious deed.

Same, it's kinda sad after yesterday's clash of the debates episode.

Now the ratings will plunge down...thanks to Zee TV.

Why the hell did Vinit not hug her! Jeez! They're like...made for each other! Damn you public for killing off her!

Now, I have to rely on Hemu...

hi friends..

i really agree with vinit, himani and debu... what's all this nonnence .. you r not doing any drama on show.. this show for singing not for drama that how to get vote..i think even DEBU know that he is not better singer than other three... but still he doing all emotional drama to get votes and ISMIAL DARBAR is suppoting him..

do u guys thinks this valid that u show your emtional part and get some vote... it's also valid that u asking from your region, not from all over india.. .. i don;t think u have to tell that my dad is in hospital so he is not here..

Originally posted by: Soniya.

Over here, in toronto, episodes air a bit late. I JUST saw the episode in which Himani gets voted out. Shocking thing is though, Ismail D didnt say a single word to her, despite the fact she apologized to him and everyone for what she, vinit, and hema did.

Personally, i think Himesh and Aadesh put them up to do this tedious deed.

They still did not explain their actions. If they are going to rely on public for votes and annouce such a decision on national televsion AFTER a contestant gets highest number of votes, they better have a darn good explanation for why they did what they did. It was a very unsatisfying episode for me. They had the balls to take this decision but then after the hoopla go sit and go on about the show. It's too late, they have already hurt Debojit and Ismail D. It shows arrogance and it's uncalled for this early in their careers. They were pretty much short of telling everyone that Debojit didn't deserve to be #1. Of course AD and Himesh have no qualms with Himani, their pupils made the fuss together and the 2 of them singled out ID. If the reasons for walking was anything but the fact that Debo got the highest # of votes and that his majority votes came from one region, it would've been understandable if explained well. But apparently they have been sleeping through the competition to understand it's basic rules.

Originally posted by: shettypatel

Himesh doesn't need to keep harping on Vinit's sappy love story everytime he gets a chance to speak. I just wished they realized this is NOT a dating show. And they are just so sure of themselves to say that he'll reveal the girl's name on the last show...so they know he'll be the last "handpump" standing?? The only overt behavior has always come from Himesh and AD...I have noticed that Ismail has always given credit where its due, be it commending Vineet's or Himani's performances.

If Debo has been doing drama about his father then these 3 have done the mother of all dramas by staging this so called "walk out". Of course I knew they weren't going to go through with this...this was all to get the attention back on them coz how dare Debo get more votes than them. If they are such credible singers then theys didn't have to stoop to such levels. Debo has always been giving honest performances throughout the show and hasn't let any of the success go to his head. If the voting system is going to be left to public then don't expect to control where the votes can from and where they can not. If this is the system and it has been working for weeks (esp when Vinit was coming up with highest # of votes) then there is absolutely no reason to complain now. They only end up looking like sore losers.

Originally posted by: shyam0701

have few questions for the 3 Contestants who threatened to Walk-out

1. While replying to Ismail's question when they decided that they would walk-out, Vinit said, they decided the day before to quit the Challenge . However, before the Debo was announced at #1 with the highest vote, Shan asked all the contestants what they felt & what are their chances of being voted out on that day. All the 3 contestants (Hema, Himani & Vinit) said they would accept public judgment. Why this double standard?
2. Do they not have respect for the public? It's public decision to give highest # of votes to Debo. These 3 are challenging public voting. It doesn't matter the votes have come from which part of India. If Hema receives highest vote from South, would Vinit walk-out? If you don't want to respect public judgment then why are you in the contest. Vinit said, all three of them know how better they sing. In that case Please Do Quit
3. Hema said, "We thought of walking-out when Nihira was out". Did you discuss this with Debo at that time?
4. I think all the 3 Contestants believe in God. I would request these 3 contestants to keep hand on their heart & then confirm that nobody else (particularly any mentor) has suggested them to take this stand.

I am not prejudiced for these 3 contestants , but I think, they have brought politics to the music show which is meant for good music & nothing else. And their mentors are to be blamed more. I strongly believe all this happened either with their guidance or they at least knew about it. If not, then they would have given right advised to the 3 contestants when they announced they about walking-out.

Himensh, please grow up & stop cashing on Vinit's girlfriend.

Completly agree with you Shyam. Apparently the 3 of them had discussed this "walk out" at an earlier occasion but didn't feel like they should include debojit in this discussion. How hurtful! I don't see any fuss when Vinit's come out with the most votes. And Himesh has lost all credibility as a mentor along with Aadesh.