Sa Re Ga Ma Pa - THE SHOW CONTINUES... :)

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Poll

Do you think it was right on part of Vineet, Hema & Himani to walk out

Frequent Posters

@cdac1000N

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#531

It was nice reading all the comments. I really enjoyed them.

Now I've few of mine too.

Personally like few others on this fourm I was also in favour of Nihira. One the most talented singers. My best guess was Nihira & Vineet as final two. Well it was rally sad to see, Nihira voted out, and also the way Zee showed about her performance (the one related to dansing)But does anyone including the people realize that this show is about finding a singer and not someone who's good in shaking the lower body; we have too many of those who're good in moving lower body parts.

Leaving this apart, I do agree with Ismile Darbar's stand. He did the right thing. Debu's voice cracked this time as well just like the last time. He's not really a contender for the last position. So with Nihira gone, he does not have any cards left and also not ready to accept the defeat.

Now looking @ the mento meter from last few show, Adesh has been really possivie about his kids, and not at all spearing others with smallest of mistakes. Same goes for Himesh as he's making quite a fuss about Vinit's love story. He can be in love, what the hell the general public has to do with it? We atleast I'm in for the good singer and not intersted in knowing who's falling for whom.

On the whole, Zee & others made Spegatti out of this show

Quote

hkhan130

@hkhan130

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#532

[well i think himani vineet n hema goes crazy.. they did wrong by walking out. bcz this was d rule of d game to judge by public voting n now when they r scared of being out they themself walkout they r not d challengers at all so i think no matter how good or bad debojit sings he should be declared d winner becoz now he is the only challenger in d competition remaining rest of them proved their cowardness in front of whole india . n himani should think befre speaking she is s arrgant she cnsider herself as d best singer i dnt know y. they should be knowing that all these 12 chalengers were d best thats y their mentors were backing them n now it was public who should select one of them not the best of them bcoz they were already d best thats y among the thousands of contestants they were here sharib n sunannda were as good as nihira hema vineet but it was public wh dint like them n voted them out n now when they r choosing debojit s these 3 are saying that they dint like any1of them to go..y did they want all d three to be winners did they think themself better than d remaining 9? no not at all. everybody is a gem n plz leave it to public to decide i knw in d last episode debojit's [erformance was not good infact just an average but still if he gets maximum votes so its his fate likewise once hema's performance was not good even d other mentors too commented on his performance but still he gets more votes than sharib n sharib was eliminated. at that stage neither aadesh, himesh shaan , audience public , nor himani vineet n hema himself objected . then y they r doing it right now... n this is the strange thing about this game that good singers r eliminated n bad r still there so plz u three let d game go on as it is dont try to gain public's sympathy infact by doing so u have lost many votes of serious music lovers.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

hkhan130

@hkhan130

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#533

himani hema n vineet u r worst performer bcoz u people just know how to dance how to love at an early age n how to make public fool n thats d way ur mentors are. ismail darbar is a man of honour n so his contestants. when nihira was voted out she take that hnurably she respected d public voting but u three are pathetic if i was gajendra i would have have then n there throw u people out f this game n declared debo d winner atleast he have this courage to come other day after performing not so good in the previous episode n after his mentor also walked out... he is the real challenger n second is nihira..u three better move out urself or d public will humiliate u n throw u out..... understand

Quote

gulachi

@gulachi

Beginner

Posted: 19 years ago

#534

helllllo..these three kids are making fools of public by walking out and what about great mentor who is wayyyyyy senior than these kids walking out if he does not have a strong contestant??? I think these kids were courageous to stand upto it and I applaud them---and also they are not like Debo, trying to create sympathy waves in each show talking about his ailing father or his passed away mother's dream..every contestant on the stage has his/her parents dream to make them proud so ask Debo to stop crying and creating emotional drama...

Originally posted by: hkhan130
himani hema n vineet u r worst performer bcoz u people just know how to dance how to love at an early age n how to make public fool n thats d way ur mentors are. ismail darbar is a man of honour n so his contestants. when nihira was voted out she take that hnurably she respected d public voting but u three are pathetic if i was gajendra i would have have then n there throw u people out f this game n declared debo d winner atleast he have this courage to come other day after performing not so good in the previous episode n after his mentor also walked out... he is the real challenger n second is nihira..u three better move out urself or d public will humiliate u n throw u out..... understand

Quote

mskanth

@mskanth

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#535

I have great regards for Ismail Durbar as a musician, Vinit's love, sad demise of Debojit's mom and all other heart touching backgrounds. But they have nothing to do with one's performance. They have been highlighted time and again to gain more popularity.

I haven't seen many episodes but I hardly found any mentor giving a negative feedback when a singer made a mistake (especially in a voting episode).

Before talking about the 'walkout' of the three contestants, I am keen to know Ismail's walkout theory.

1. He was truly upset at Nihira's exit and so are many of us. Point to be noted - the other judges gave her good credits in that performance.
2. When Debu got less points from the Judges in the following episode he quoted 'they ousted nihira and they are trying to do the same to Debu'. Well, who is 'they'.
This high drama might have got enough sympathy for Debu for that round.

Coming back to the next 'walkout' session, it could have been a reply as Ismail quoted. The other three contestants are trying to show their unity thereby gaining enough sympathy for themselves as a group. This could lead to a break-up in the voters as 'pro-debu' and 'anti-debu' and could show its worst effect in the grand finale (if debu makes it).

This is just an analysis. I dont want to make it more political. I agree with most of you on the keeping up the serenity of the program in tact. Let us just hope for it.

Quote

Islam_Killer

@Islam_Killer

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#536

SareGaMaPa was the best show, till it tried to increase its popularity/make money by public voting system, which in itself is a flawed system big time. We have seen the outcome of flawed public voting system in one of the program of other channel( Where a dancing / prancing monkey (Quazi) was voted as the best singer). Not based on his singing abilities but on his looks and getting votes from one particular state and votes from one particular community. The same vicious cycle is being repeated in Saregama too.

The role of some mentors is also questionable. Himesh always harps on vineet and his love life even though that is not even remotely connected with his singing ability. We saw this same pattern in the other channel show as well, where one of the judge, who belonged to minority community encouraging the dancing monkey from Kashmir, at the same time taunting and slamming other deserving, better candidates (Javed Akthar).

The best solution for this problem is to stop the public voting system and keep 10-12 unbiased,qualified people who belong to singing feild as judges.

Quote

somayaju

@somayaju

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#537

In my opinion there is no winner. All the singers have lost their credibility. The families of the singers have lost the audience's repsect for allowinmg matters to precipitate towards this end. The music directors have lost their face and have only their super size Ego to bank upon. Adesh, Himesh and Ismail with their partisan attitudes have shown that they are no different from a corrupt politician. Gajendra Singh is also a big loser for converting a much acclaimed program into a sizzling pot of regionalism and factions. All in all the show has turned into another "also ran" series, which Zee is famous for.

Quote

hkhan130

@hkhan130

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#538

Originally posted by: gulachi

helllllo..these three kids are making fools of public by walking out and what about great mentor who is wayyyyyy senior than these kids walking out if he does not have a strong contestant??? I think these kids were courageous to stand upto it and I applaud them---and also they are not like Debo, trying to create sympathy waves in each show talking about his ailing father or his passed away mother's dream..every contestant on the stage has his/her parents dream to make them proud so ask Debo to stop crying and creating emotional drama...

[

yes i agree with u that debojit is gaining votes by emotinal drama but then vineet is doing d same to by creating love drama no body is interested in her f**k lve life

Quote

hkhan130

@hkhan130

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#539

even the other mentors are doing same himesh always talking about vineet's love more than his singing . aadesh ji always praising himani more than hema n when there was rajeev so aadesh was always overlooking his mistakes n asking for voting him else he will g back to open his chinese restauarnt in chamba .. i think ismail darbar n jati lalit were the true music gems n aadesh n himesh r just trying to gain popularity by overimposing there singers thats it....

Quote

shaun

@digibizman

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#540

yo bitch asshole islam killer. qazi deserved to be the famegurukul jodi. asshole the votes is a very good system. without this extra drama saregamapa wouldnt get more viewers which i think is a good thing

Quote

1 ... 52 53 54 55 56 ... 74

Sa Re Ga Ma Pa - THE SHOW CONTINUES... :) - Page 54

Poll

Related Topics

Explore Topics