SRGMP-Challenge/updates/comments.. - Page 68

About ID smiling in Thursdays epidsode....
ID was just reacting like he always does. He's the only mentor who truely, honestly expresses himself. Rather than focusing on the way ID smiled we should put spotlight on how AS and HR had a Poker Face like they had no clue what was going on. And when the situation was out of control or under ID's control they started panicing since "things didn't go as planned"
Once Again, ID was just smiling as he thought how FUNNY the situation was.

I am just wondering, after getting rid of ID(if they succeed) how AS and HR would fight amongst themselves.

The track record shows that they are not Class A directors. ID's compositions are genuine. HR is a copier - recruits people in the industry to compose for him like what Annu Malik has been doing for year. IT'S TRUE. AS too is probably a good "arranger" and a musician but not a genuine Music Director like AR Rehman or ID.

AS and HR had a Poker Face like they had no clue what was going on.

Hi.Everyone can some one like to tell who got second and third highest votes!
please and thank you!

Guys!!

This is commercial TV - first priority is to profits and ratings which this program got with all the millions of votes not to mention the ads. It caters to all kinds of viewer tastes and they know public gets entertained by Tamasha.

I love Music and this program was superb - excellent quality.

My heart goes to these misguided youngsters who in my opinion alientated some of the seniors of the industry - wrong move if you intend to make a career in the industry. Arrogance and bitching even before starting careers -- na na not in India. Light up folks -- this is not the end of the world.

I Wish them all success in their respective careers.

http://www.silchar.com/cgi-bin/adda/MahaAdda.pl?board=0011&a mp;a ction=display&num=1131701830&start=240

Try going to this site where you will see many people from NE being biased. They only want Debu to win because he is from their state. Some of them even accepted the fact that Debu is not as good as Nihira and other contestants are. But they still continue to find ways to cast thousands of votes for Debu.

Saregamapa is not Indian Idol. It has been a very reputable show for years and it should not lose its integrity by creating regionalism.

The producer of the show should understand that only the best singer should win. If one person is able to cast multiple votes then the system becomes faulty. If people from one region are casting thousands of votes, then it stops conveying the fact that someone who got the most votes is the voice of India.

Besides we want India's voice not NE's voice. I know people say NE consists of 7 states. But think about it 7 states compared to total 48 states of India. Only 1/7th of the India wants Debu to be the winner. He is definitely not India's voice

Hey guies ! Himani is out! Sad. But @ least she is first among girls 😛 😛 . Debu's supporters, well I know u guies wouldn't change ur mind no matter whatever he sings. I just want 2 tell them personally Im very disgusted @ them. Its not about regionalism or anything, they r not giving proper care about music. Guies if he wins & sings in an album what r u gonna do buy 100's of copies each! Thats how u would make him famous? 🤢 . We have not seen any other contestant gatting @ least 2% votes from Assam, dats not fair. Debu might not have any fault in dis but this is not so good advertisement for Assam also. Hell! why do u care b happy with ur guy. Ive stopped voting. as my 1 vote doesnt count anymore as some guy would vote a thousand himself in a day.
Now d show doesnt interest me much.

I wanted to quote this person from one of the forums:

Originally posted by: Gaan

All the members who discuss sa re ga ma pa show must know this,

As i was browsing the net i came across some sites which are giving software tools to vote for Debojit.
You can check the net and one such site is

http://www.silchar.com/debojit/hidden/

http://www.silchar.com/debojit/hidden/java.html .

No wonder he is scoring so much inspite of his not so good singing in comparison to others who have already lost.
What say you all who say the three were wrong in willing to quit?

I completely agree with this person. There are just so many cheat tools people have created to ensure debu wins the competition.
It's no longer a fair competition.

Hi Guys,

This is shear Shameful act, I would say. Voting Site for Debojit.

This show has totally become Commercial show now and has nothing to do with the Real Music Talent..Nihira's Exclusion has already proved this very clearly.

Could I ask everyone to please Vote for good Voice and Not on the basis of Regions. As This Competition is for INDIA's Voice and Not NE's Voice.

I have been reading many of your comments saying that Debojeet is NE India's voice. Now isn't Hemachandra getting all his votes from South of India??

I personally think Heamchnadra has the best voice but he is not at a point where he canfortably sing Hindi songs.

This show has a combination which is presently not working. It has put the participants in Gharana and then their staying is decided by the they get. This is not like other program where judges have no vested interests in the winning or losing of a participant. The judges here are trying to get their person to the the top and worse trying to push others down. Is that how judging should be? Bring in soem 4-5 external judges to give points out to the contestents instead of using 'opponent-memto-meters'.

The other reason why Debojeet has won the last round is because of the sympathy votes he generated. Obviously people from his part of India have a soft corner for him. But when they see scores like 4 and 7 given to his resonable performance, they will be furious. Their fury will come in as support for their favorite.

Also, voting via sms or phone does not necessarily bring in the right contestent. But this is the method we the show chose. Why is Adesh Srivastav now bringing up the numbers. Trying to make sense of the obvious!

Lastly, can someone post the Friday's episode :)

That S/W Tool seems pretty old. Moreover I tested it and it doesn't even work. I guess it was created initially when there was no security code on the Voting web page.

DebuFan:
I personally do not like the singing of Debu but I agree with you when you say "Weather he gets votes from 7 NE states or 5 Southern states or all Northern states, is a moot point. The fact is people of India vote for him. If the format of the program allows them to vote multiple times, the same allowance is extended to supporters of other singers. I don't think anyone has the right to question the numbers that come in. I don't think anyone has the right to shout ULFA to demean the numbers he gets. The NE states like him and they vote for him, and they matter every bit as much as the other Indian states.". I fully support your views on respecting the verdict of NE as it is integral part of India.
However, I do not agree with your comments on South Indians. Please realize that SPB is one of the BEST singers India has produced. Also people from Northern States have been voting for Hema Chandra. The highest he ever got from South was 40%. Assuming that this has been the trend in his votes, he is getting 60% of his votes from other parts of India. If Non-South Indians have not voted for Hema Chandra, he would not have come this far.