Update for 21/10/05 - Page 2

Happy to see that Debu has made it to the finals.

The song keka sang was Aankhen band karke jo ek chehra nazar aaya.........

Even i don't like raktima's voice- it is very nasal. Keka is more full throttle kind.

New here. Now that the audiance vote starts, I think Dilshad should be voted back. He really touches people's heart. HR had once said that if people where judging him on the episode he lost, he would have won and Niladri would have lost. I guess HR should use this opportunity of Brahmastra to bring back Dilshad instead of Aaiswarya as widely expected. I am sure Dishad would be in top three if this is done. Also, Dilshad lost very narrowly in his episodes and all the mentors always praised him. Is HR hearing???

We in US will see the ChakraVyuha today and tomorrow. But was very disappointed to hear that Keka is out. She is the girl who won against Ujjaini, and Raktima is better than her?? Pataa nahin Raktima ne kya Jadu kar diya hai. She is so nasal. Innocent, sweet sab theek hai, this is not Fame Gurukul to select a non-singer just because they are good at heart. Keka should have been in and Raktima out.

I agree.. In my opinion, Keka was a really good singer and still should be in the competition. Anyways, Thanxx for the update Priti! 😛

Strictly to my opinion from overall singing perspective, Ujanni and Joita should have reached chakrvyuh round. But then I agree keka was better than Raktima.
Raktima has reached so far is a surprise, Joyita had sang better overall than Raktima in Round 3, but then again all Diler Mendhi did was count 'SUR. Not a good way of judging.

Also Viswas was much better then Irfan. Which again was wrong judgment by Delir Mendhi, just based on 'SUR'.
Also Abhijeet sang much better than Rajeve in round 3.

Originally posted by: Devil_in_Heaven

So does that mean there will be 12 contestants in the Agnipariksha

6 directly voted
6 from chakrivyuh
2 from SMS

Is there a final round after Agnipariksha or Agniparisksha is the last round ?

6 directly voted - Nihira, Twinkle, Swananda, Rajeev, Vineeet, Hemachandra

4 from chakrivyuh (not 6)- Himani, Raktima, Debojit, Sharib

2 from SMS -Brahmashtra- I think 6 contestants have been selected from various gharana and now they will go through this round (shown over 2 days) this week and 2 will be selected to go to agnipariksha

Originally posted by: sangeetrocks

Strictly to my opinion from overall singing perspective, Ujanni and Joita should have reached chakrvyuh round. But then I agree keka was better than Raktima.
Raktima has reached so far is a surprise, Joyita had sang better overall than Raktima in Round 3, but then again all Diler Mendhi did was count 'SUR. Not a good way of judging.

Also Viswas was much better then Irfan. Which again was wrong judgment by Delir Mendhi, just based on 'SUR'.
Also Abhijeet sang much better than Rajeve in round 3.

I agree with you on the vishwaas bit as i thought vishwaas was a better singer than irfan but on joyita i disagree- though she was good in initial round- she was not that good. Ujjaini - i again agree - she should have been here and i think her chances of coming back through public voting are high.

Rajeev- i actually like his voice- i know he is the black sheep here and is not consistent in his sur.

Originally posted by: pmahesh

I agree with you on the vishwaas bit as i thought vishwaas was a better singer than irfan but on joyita i disagree- though she was good in initial round- she was not that good. Ujjaini - i again agree - she should have been here and i think her chances of coming back through public voting are high.

Rajeev- i actually like his voice- i know he is the black sheep here and is not consistent in his sur.

Pmahesh..I appreciate your updates and all but I disagree with you one few points, I just watch friday version here in USA, Raktima was actually better than Himani. The song she sang was perfect. Odhni odh kar. And she sings without any effort. Earlier I did not like her singing but now I feel she is one of the finalists. Vishwas is good but there is lot of hype with him just. Aadesh Srivastava presents his contestants nicely. He has been successful in creating hype for his contestants. Irfan is also very good singer. He knows what he is singing not like other. Actually all contestants are good, I am just expecting good fight ahead.

Hey fm_qazi...........it is ok- all of us can't have the same opinion and favs...

I like raktima's singing and do find her singing effortless (i think one of the mentors actually mentioned, i think it was Jatin, that she sings most difficult songs without a shikan on her face whereas lot of others are unable to do so)- but i do not like her voice quality, i think it is a little too nasal to my liking.

I disagree on vishwaas bit- i don't think there is hype around him- there is more hype on Aishwarya, dilshaad, Niladri......vineet, rajeev. I think vishwaas's aaja meri jaan song was sung really well and he is real potential. I don't like irfan's singing because i think his singing is one- dimensional- he can only sing a particular kind of song and his voice lacks energy.