AR Rahman vs Jatin lalit - Page 3

Originally posted by: Indradhanush

Before we embark further on plagiarism it is imprtant we differentiate between plagiarism, genuine inspiration and blatant copying. The last is pretty clear and one such example is pritam's zara zara kiss me for race from a Taiwani music. I do think that is not very pleasant. But coming to inspirations like back street boys crazy vs ARR's o humdum suniyo re (saathiya) or kelele vs parkathey (where ARR has fitted lyrics on raag deshkar while initial 3 bars are same and what a lovely bassing, I would let any one go for such an experiment. Similarly michael learns to rock ( I am no actor) vs jaane na kaha from Jane tu...again from ARR's house are posted at few sites as copying but they are actually soft rock ballads with similar arrangements hence sound same.

Similarly R D Burman chura liya hai has inspiration from its tuesday, very beautiful extrapolation of few chords or simply two chords from gods of war to aa dekhe zara

or o maria vs mamoniya (Beatles), listen to them they are vastly different, we shouldn't run down some one's creativity and efforts for something posted some where, regarding itwofs let's remember the owner himself has disclaimed he doesn't have sufficient knowledge about music and the postings are not entirely his.

When a composer is writting notation he may actually not remember why he is writting particular bars or whyare they in his mind there.

I at times feel what if nearly 400 raagas were patented we never would have got so many beautiful songs from 60s till now. After all the songs based on raaga also sound very similar.

Originally posted by: Indradhanush

Before we embark further on plagiarism it is imprtant we differentiate between plagiarism, genuine inspiration and blatant copying. The last is pretty clear and one such example is pritam's zara zara kiss me for race from a Taiwani music. I do think that is not very pleasant. But coming to inspirations like back street boys crazy vs ARR's o humdum suniyo re (saathiya) or kelele vs parkathey (where ARR has fitted lyrics on raag deshkar while initial 3 bars are same and what a lovely bassing, I would let any one go for such an experiment. Similarly michael learns to rock ( I am no actor) vs jaane na kaha from Jane tu...again from ARR's house are posted at few sites as copying but they are actually soft rock ballads with similar arrangements hence sound same.

Similarly R D Burman chura liya hai has inspiration from its tuesday, very beautiful extrapolation of few chords or simply two chords from gods of war to aa dekhe zara

or o maria vs mamoniya (Beatles), listen to them they are vastly different, we shouldn't run down some one's creativity and efforts for something posted some where, regarding itwofs let's remember the owner himself has disclaimed he doesn't have sufficient knowledge about music and the postings are not entirely his.

When a composer is writting notation he may actually not remember why he is writting particular bars or whyare they in his mind there.

I at times feel what if nearly 400 raagas were patented we never would have got so many beautiful songs from 60s till now. After all the songs based on raaga also sound very similar.

Originally posted by: Babumoshaai

lol ok.. tell me what u think of it.. and ignore the picturisation if u dont like it 😊

Originally posted by: gumsum

its a beautiful composition with nice lyrics👏... I didn't watch it just heard it, its a short song.. was expecting it to continue and boom.. it was over😊

Originally posted by: Babumoshaai

roshan was excellent.. shame his son gave such horrible songs...
roshan made another masterpiece...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yzZ9vXKm910


but i like the one by abhilasha of voi.. check it out

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eVXxifkFPVA

Originally posted by: gumsum

I don't think its that easy to call out the distinction between copying and orginality specially when there r tiny miny differences here n there. Its very easy for two persons of same IQ to come up with two solutions or two compositions very similar or eaxctly similar in some very rare cases. You can say that one lifted it from the other unless you can somehow prove that the road they took to reach the same destinations are indeed different.

Patent the process but not the outcome. Can the outcome be different if the process isn't, makes me wonder..